
How to Fix Penn Station
Transcript
[MUSIC - Marden Hill: Hijack]
Brian Lehrer: Brian Lehrer on WNYC. If you haven't heard, a Long Island Rail Road strike could be heading our way as early as this weekend. What are the issues between the MTA and the unions? If you haven't heard, President Trump is trying to put his stamp on redevelopment of Penn Station. What would that look like? Now we turn to some of the latest news in transit, especially on those things, as seen by the think tank that tries to center the interests of the whole greater New York/New Jersey region, the Regional Plan Association.
Back in April of last year, the Trump administration took control in a way of the Penn Station rebuild from the MTA, and they assigned Amtrak. Remember Andy Byford? They assigned Andy Byford. Somehow he is the political-- everybody loves him, the universal donor [chuckles] of politics. Everybody loves Andy Byford seems like on the left, on the right. The former New York City Transit president, he's leading the project.
A master developer is expected to be chosen this month, some company or another. The Federal Railroad Administration has commissioned an 18-month service optimization study on this idea of through-running in order to unlock greater capacity within the extension footprint. What is through-running? Instead of having NJ Transit and the LIRR and at Penn Station and turn around, they would pass through in a new regional system. You could go from, I don't know, Mineola to Montclair without getting off the train.
The Regional Plan association is a nearly century old nonprofit research and advocacy organization focused primarily on transportation and infrastructure policy in the New York, New Jersey, Connecticut metropolitan region. They've been deeply involved in the Penn Station and Gateway project debates for years. Their new report lands in a pretty heated debate between those like Andy Byford, who believe through-running is a good idea, and those like the RPA, who argue physical expansion is the key. We'll explain what that means.
Meanwhile, the union representing Long Island Rail Road employees and the MPA are set to resume talks to avoid a strike that could affect so many thousands of riders. The shutdown could begin as soon as this Saturday, we are told. Joining us now to talk about all of this is Tom Wright, CEO and president of the Regional Plan Association. Tom, thanks for coming on. Welcome back to WNYC.
Tom Wright: Thanks, Brian. It's always a pleasure to be with you.
Brian Lehrer: Would you remind us how, if I put it right in the intro, the Trump administration took control of the redevelopment of Penn Station from the MTA.
Tom Wright: Sure. This is all connected, of course, to the new tunnels under the Hudson River. I think just for your listeners, you should understand people have been trying to fix Penn Station almost ever since it got torn down 50 years ago. Really, it started heating up as the Gateway project, which is building two new tracks under the Hudson River, which will then allow Amtrak to renovate the existing tracks and essentially double capacity under the Hudson River. That project is underway. It's a $16 billion project. The federal government is funding about 3/4 of it now.
As that project is moving forward, the railroads, Amtrak, which owns Penn Station, the MTA and New Jersey Transit several years ago started a kind of two-step process to think about, "What are we going to do to try and renovate the existing Penn Station to make it a suitable place for more commuters, and what are we going to do about the capacity that we're going to need when we double the number of trains coming from under the Hudson River?" There was a kind of process going forward with advisory groups that I and others were on, and the railroads had consultants working on them.
Essentially what happened about a year ago was the Trump administration stepped in, I guess I should say, too. The MTA was leading the renovation plans for Penn Station. They'd done a successful job with the Long Island Rail Road concourse and fixing that up. They were leading the charge in figuring out how best to try and renovate Penn Station and get whatever additional capacity could be gotten out of the existing footprint and the existing system there. Meanwhile, Amtrak and New Jersey Transit were focused on, "How are we going to handle twice as many trains coming in?"
What happened a year ago was really that the Trump administration said, "Well, wait a minute. Amtrak owns Penn Station. It's a federal asset. Let's focus on that first." They started this process that we expect will have some major milestones in just a couple of weeks, where they started a procurement process to invite private bidders, private companies to come in under what we would call a public private partnership to make proposals for how they would fix Penn Station or transform it.
Brian Lehrer: On this additional capacity that would be needed, a lot of people who are not very involved have heard this term, "The Gateway Tunnel," and maybe they know President Trump is using it as a political football. It's this big project that's been in the work for maybe decades to increase capacity between New Jersey and Penn Station. It needs federal funding. It's got some federal funding.
Trump pulls it, puts it back, pulls it, puts it back. It goes to court, trying to punish New York and New Jersey over things having nothing to do with transportation, DEI, whatever. Is it really up to 90 trains per hour once it gets completed, or is the Gateway Tunnel just trying to repair something that got damaged way back during Superstorm Sandy?
Tom Wright: Sure. I've actually been working on this for over 30 years myself so I have some experience on this thing. I'll say back in the spring of 1996, when RPA produced our third regional plan, we called for the crazy idea at the time of building the Second Avenue Subway, connecting the Long Island Rail Road to Grand Central Terminal, charging people to drive into Manhattan and building a new tunnel under the Hudson River. Here we are 30 years later and three of those four have happened. The one that I would have thought-- [crosstalk]
Brian Lehrer: The Long Island Rail Road does go into Grand Central now, so you can get from Long Island to the east side, not the west side.
Tom Wright: Exactly.
Brian Lehrer: That's the importance of that. The Second Avenue Subway, at least partially, has been built. This is the third leg?
Tom Wright: Yes, and congestion pricing, by the way, in 1996.
Brian Lehrer: Ah, right.
Tom Wright: There was no London congestion zone. The technology didn't even exist. We've knocked off three of those four. The new tunnel under the Hudson River, in the '90s and then the early '00s, it started under the name Access to the Region's Core or ARC. Some folks will recall that Governor Christie, when he came into office, decided to cancel the project under the threat of cost overruns. I think it was a situation where Governor Christie was not going to take yes for an answer when he tried to come up with reasons to cancel it. Now the project is moving forward.
I think, folks, it's important for people to recognize this. This tunnel is absolutely vital to the long-term health and success and prosperity of New York and New Jersey and the entire tristate metropolitan region. Just to give people a sense of context, basically since 1990 or so, about 2/3 of the net new commuters who have started coming into New York City for jobs, about 2/3 of them have been coming from west of the Hudson River.
Brian Lehrer: Really?
Tom Wright: Most of the net new. When a job is created in New York City, the person working in that job is probably either living somewhere in the five boroughs, where obviously we have a ridiculous housing crisis and it's very hard to find housing, or that person is probably coming from New Jersey and west of the Hudson River because New Jersey is building more housing than the rest of the region combined. It's really important long-term that we have this capacity and continue to grow.
There are about 5 million jobs in New York City right now. About a million of them are occupied by people commuting from outside the five boroughs and about half of those are now coming from New Jersey and most of the growth again. It's really very important that we get all of the capacity we can. You threw out some numbers earlier. I'll just say right now the capacity is about 24 trains an hour under the Hudson River. There are more coming through the four tunnels under the East River. Just if you look west from Penn Station, it's about 24 trains an hour under the 115-year-old Hudson River North River Tunnels.
Brian Lehrer: It's 24 coming from Jersey? That will go to 90?
Tom Wright: No. The goal is to double it to 48.
Brian Lehrer: I see.
Tom Wright: I think 90, you're probably combining the East River Tunnels to that.
Brian Lehrer: Ah, right. I see. Between the Long Island Rail Road and New Jersey Transit, that would be 90 going to Penn Station. Got it.
Tom Wright: Yes. Essentially the question becomes, we're building a tunnel that will allow us to double the number of trains under the Hudson River. Do we have a station that can handle twice as many trains under the river? As you talked about in your introduction, in the next few weeks we're going to see the results of the procurement process that Andy Byford has been, I think, doing a very admirable job leading. A team will be selected, and they'll start to go through public review process and environmental impact statement and all of that.
At the same time, the Federal Railroad Administration has commissioned consultants to look at regional connectivity and capacity and see what they can do. It was actually a two-part process they were commissioned. The first part was to figure out what improvements can be made to Penn Station to try and essentially squeeze more capacity out of the existing footprint of it. Then the second part, which I believe they've just embarked on recently, is to look at the entire regional connectivity, and would additional rail yards improve capacity, and what other kinds of things are necessary to make the system work better.
Brian Lehrer: All right. Let's get to this debate about the best path forward. This is you versus Andy Byford.
Tom Wright: I won't agree with that. I'm sorry. I don't think Andy and I are actually in violent disagreement about this.
Brian Lehrer: Okay. Let me tell you the way I've read it, and you can correct me. My understanding was that Andy Byford, the former New York City transit chief who President Trump has tapped to be the federal lead on redoing Penn Station, he thinks that they can squeeze more capacity out of the existing Penn Station through what's called "through-running." That's trains would not end at Penn Station, both Long Island Rail Road trains and New Jersey Transit trains. Maybe the distinction would be lost.
You could go from Huntington to Hazlett or Montauk to Montclair. I don't know. Pick your alliteration. On the other side, so to speak, I thought was your report that calls for a different kind of expansion but that through-running like that would force them to widen the platforms too much at Penn Station and stuff. You tell me, what is it, actually?
Tom Wright: Yes. Sure, sure. Here's the thing. I get that I'm here, the representative of the Regional Plan Association. People would expect me to come in and say, "Yes, absolutely. Connecting eastern Long Island to central New Jersey is a huge priority, and that's what we ought to do." It wouldn't be that great to connect the region together. Here's the simple problem and the challenge we face here.
New York, the Tri-State metropolitan region, the motherlode of jobs, the greatest amount of prosperity is still concentrated in the core of the region, in Midtown Manhattan and Lower Manhattan. The job of our commuter rail system is still primarily to get the hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of commuters and travelers from the periphery of the region into the core each day to earn a living, to earn wages, and then bring that money back to their home community.
Brian Lehrer: Intuitively, I have to say that makes sense to me because Manhattan is where presumably the commuters are going, both from New Jersey and Long Island. Who's really going from Setauket to Secaucus? You like that one? Does anybody actually do that?
Tom Wright: Right. Exactly. New Rochelle to New Brunswick. The answer is very few people do it.
Brian Lehrer: That's Metro-North. Don't confuse people. Go ahead.
Tom Wright: [laughs] That's exactly the question, Brian, because for each person doing that reverse commute in the morning, it's roughly looking at the numbers. It's probably about 100:1 ratio in terms of people who are traveling into the core of the region in the morning to take a job and then traveling in the evening back out. The demand on the system is not balanced.
If every train that started in, say, Trenton, New Jersey, was traveling through the core of the region and then continuing on to eastern Long Island, you would be running a lot of empty trains out of New York City in the morning and a lot of empty trains into New York City in the evening because the demand just isn't there. What the railroads do is-- and by the way, Metro-North Long Island Rail Road and New Jersey Transit are all trying to squeeze every bit of capacity they can out of the existing rolling stock and the legacy systems that they own.
What they do is they prioritize those commutes, they prioritize getting as many people in in the morning on a one-seat ride as quickly as possible. Especially if they're coming from further out, they try and give them express service so that they don't have to make all the local stops. In the evening they do the reverse of that. You asked how many people would be doing-- what was it you said? Setauket to Secaucus?
Brian Lehrer: Setauket to Secaucus.
Tom Wright: Secaucus or something like that. There's just a handful of people trying to do that. Whereas today there are, say, we'll look at the Raritan Valley line in New Jersey. That is an historic line that runs through a lot of traditional downtowns, Transit Village locations, that has over 20,000 daily riders on it today, and they don't get a one-seat ride into Manhattan. The reason they don't get it, off-peak they run a few trains directly into Manhattan, but only when it's off-peak because they don't have capacity under the Hudson River.
When they build the Gateway Tunnel, the Raritan Valley Line, the Bergen and Main Lines up in northern New Jersey, the passengers on those lines who currently have to transfer either in Secaucus or Newark could be getting a one-seat ride into New York Penn Station where they're trying to go, but only if there's sufficient capacity under the river, which Gateway will address, and then at New York Penn Station.
This is where the argument comes out. Through-running is a great operational thing, and it would be marginally an improvement. It probably can get you a little more capacity. I do think that the emphasis that Andy is doing appropriately with his transformation. I think that out of the bidding process, a team is going to come forward, and they're going to talk about ways to try and improve the station.
They're going to take out the B level, so there's one big concourse. They're going to remove columns from the platforms to the extent they can so that there's more space on platforms. They're going to add staircases. All of that is going to do is hopefully reduce the dwell time so the trains can get in and out more quickly. At the end of the day, that's going to be a long way from doubling capacity at Penn Station. That's why we wrote our report.
Brian Lehrer: Let me just give you one Andy Byford quote, because, before I read the quote, let's say you do want to go from Long Beach to Long Branch. Good one, right?
Tom Wright: Yes.
Brian Lehrer: If he says, "If the trains spend less time on the platform, then you can run more trains through. There are a lot of reasons why I think through-running should be explored." Our transportation reporter Stephen Nessen quoted Byford saying that in November.
Tom Wright: I guess here's where I'll try to massage the difference. I think it should be explored too. It may be a way of creating some more capacity. You'd have to bring Andy onto your show to ask him. My guess is that if you asked Andy Byford point blank, "Do you think that through-running can double the capacity at Penn Station?" I'll just say I don't think that that would come close to getting it. I think you'd still have a very large gap between the capacity that Gateway is going to create and what the station could handle.
Let me give you a couple. A lot of folks who are proponents of through-running, they talk about international best practices, and if they're doing it in London and Paris, why aren't we doing it here? There are a couple of really important distinctions that I think people need to understand about those other world cities.
For one thing, the commutes in those other cities tend to be shorter trips so that their train lines, they're more like subways where people can be standing. New Jersey Transit, Long Island Rail Road commuter riders tend to be coming from quite far out on fairly long trips that can be 45 minutes or longer. They don't want to stand that whole trip. They want a seat, they want to be able to work on their computer, other things.
Another thing is that in all those other kind of world cities, their CBDs, their downtowns are distributed along a line. The trains come in and they make one stop and maybe 20% of the people get off and some other people get on. They make another stop, another 20% get off and on, et cetera. They might be making five or six stops in the core. In New York City, it's Penn Station, essentially. If we could create a stomp on the east side for New Jersey Transit riders, they'd love it.
Basically, this isn't going to connect Lower Manhattan and Metro-North and New Jersey and Long Island Rail Road riders can already go to Grand Central on a different line. It's a very different kind of animal because essentially it's one stop where the entire train is going to end up. Sorry, go ahead.
Brian Lehrer: No. Did you want to finish a thought real quick then? I have an interesting-looking caller ready to go.
Tom Wright: Oh, okay. I'll just say two other things about those international pressings. Another is that there are 10 different lines in New Jersey that come into Penn Station and then go out between Metro-North and Long Island Rail Road. Eleven different lines. Whenever you try to make a pairing up and say Setauket or something else like that, that passenger only cares if that line starts on the line they care about and goes to the line they care about. The Elizabeth line in London, for instance, is one single line that runs east to west across all of Greater London, and so anybody getting on it is going to go to all the other destinations on it.
Whereas what you got to think about is that the timetable for a through-running operation in the Tri-State metropolitan region, the chance that your train is picking you up where you want to go and taking you where you want to go, it's really going to be a pretty poor service because 10 other trains are going to be going somewhere else and you don't care about those destinations. Rather than one train every two or three hours, you're more likely to say, "I'll just take the first express into New York, give me a nice clean transfer, and then I'll take the next train out to where I want to go."
Brian Lehrer: Let me take one high concept, very high concept-
Tom Wright: Sure thing.
Brian Lehrer: -question from Jenny in Brooklyn, then I'm going to ask you about the prospects for a Long Island Rail Road strike as early as this Saturday, and then we're out of time. Jenny, you're on WNYC. Hello.
Jenny: Hello. First time, long time. Thank you. I'm loving your guest, and I love this topic. My question, not so high-concept, is just about how much we expect people to continue to commute into New York City for jobs as we look ahead. I work in HR. I think return-to-office is clinging to the past. I realize there are lots of kinds of jobs in New York, but it sounds like you're building infrastructure that you also projected 30 years ago we would need. Congratulations on being right three out of four. There's nothing like saying I told you so. Are we going to continue to need this degree of transit into New York?
Brian Lehrer: I think that's extremely about as high-concept as you can get when you're talking about commuter transportation. Is Manhattan going to continue to be the jobs hub in the-
Tom Wright: Sure.
Brian Lehrer: -remote work era, in the general decentralization era that's started ever since the internet made it more possible for finance or other sectors to work in multiple cities? Is it going to be like this going forward? Do you have a projection?
Tom Wright: We do, actually. It's a wonderful question. I'm going to cite from my colleagues' work. It's a report on our website that folks can go to called Commuter Dividend because we asked exactly that as we were coming out of COVID. Essentially it's like, is the region going to flatten out and people are going to work from home and so they don't travel as much? Do we not need the new Gateway Tunnel or any of this?
What we did was we all know that people are traveling, say, less frequently. That if you live in Long Island and your job is located in New York City, you may-- 10 years ago you were going in five days a week, and today you might be going in two, three or four days a week instead. Of course the data reflects that in terms of the ridership on the system. In fact, whether it's subway or commuter rail or even Amtrak, what we're seeing is people ride more for leisure and other things, but still overall ridership is still down.
Here's the key question we asked, is what's the economic relationship between the suburban communities, between southwestern Connecticut and New York City? Are fewer people going in, and is there less of a connection between the two? We looked at payroll data. Not number of daily riders, say, on Metro-North, but how many people in southwestern Connecticut or Long Island or the Hudson Valley earn their living from a job that's located in New York City? It was pretty shocking.
What we saw, and this is 2022 data, we're trying to update it now, but I think it's probably still pretty strong, is that if you compared pre-Covid to post-Covid, the amount of household income in the suburbs that was derived from a job that was located in New York City increased, did not decrease, but went up in both absolute and relative terms, which is to say that more of the wealth in northern New Jersey today is derived from a job located in New York City than it was 10 years ago in absolute and relative terms.
When you think about it, not from the New York City perspective, but think about it from the suburban perspective, if you live in Long Island and you're offered a job in New York City today, 10 years ago that meant schlepping five days a week in and out, but today it may only mean three days a week. That job is really quite attractive. New York City continues to be the great generator of prosperity, the greatest invention for human prosperity that our species has ever created. Creativity and innovation all flourish there. Access to New York City is absolutely going to continue to be a priority and something very important. I really love that question.
Brian Lehrer: We're going to have to pull that clip and play it every day. How did you put it? New York is the greatest invention. Can you recreate it?
Tom Wright: It's, I think, New York City is the greatest invention to create and generate human prosperity that our species has ever invented.
Brian Lehrer: Wow. All right. We have a minute left. We're going to probably have to do a separate segment later in the week on this prospective Long Island Rail Road strike. Perhaps on Saturday. It actually ties to your through-running concept between Long Island and New Jersey, but it's also about labor, about wages, but also involves the question of work rules. Give us the one-minute version, then we're out of time.
Tom Wright: Sure. I would say we're all very concerned and hoping that the MTA and the Long Island Rail Road can strike a deal. We saw this last year with New Jersey Transit and the train engineers there, too. Of course, commuters are the ones who suffer the most. I do think it's really important to try and see what can we do to try and make operations more efficient and make sure that we're keeping commuter rail and transit on a sustainable financial path is something really important to do.
Brian Lehrer: Tom Wright, president and CEO of the Regional Plan Association, think tank and advocacy organization. Thank you so much for joining us.
Tom Wright: Oh, thanks for having me, Brian.
Brian Lehrer: Brian Lehrer on WNYC. Kimberlé Williams Crenshaw, who invented the term "critical race theory" and the term "intersectionality," coming up after the news with a new memoir. First, we have the latest news with Michael Hill, including news, and I think it's not good, from the US-Tehran negotiations. Hi, Michael. What's happening?
Michael Hill: Good morning, Brian. The United States and Iran are in a deepening standoff after President Trump rejected Tehran's latest offer to end the war. Officials have told the Associated Press the proposal included some concessions on its disputed nuclear program. The stalled diplomacy and recent exchanges of fire could tip the Middle East back into open warfare and prolong the worldwide energy crisis sparked by the conflict. Iran's chokehold in the Strait of Hormuz and America's blockade of Iranian ports are still in place. President Trump is expected to use a trip this week to China to urge it to pressure Iran, but the US and Iran remain far apart on a host of issues.
The California man accused of storming the White House Correspondents Association dinner while armed with guns and knives has pleaded not guilty to trying to kill President Trump. Also, Cole Thomas Allen's lawyers have asked a judge to disqualify Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche and US Attorney Jeanine Pirro from handling the case because they're potential witnesses. Republicans and Democrats are locked in a fight to redraw the US's congressional maps before this fall's midterm elections. A growing number of Democrats are pushing for New York to get into the redistricting fight. Brooklyn Democrat and Congressmember Yvette Clarke tells ABC she supports that effort.
Congressmember Yvette Clarke: We cannot unilaterally disarm in a situation like this. What we're seeing is a distortion of the political landscape in the United States of America.
Michael Hill: State lawmakers say redistricting is more cumbersome in New York than in some other states. That means the earliest voters here would face an election with new maps is 2028. New York City will convert blocks near 50 schools into car-free streets for kids to play soccer and enjoy other activities ahead of this year's World Cup.
Mayor Mamdani says New Yorkers should be able to take part in the festivities for the tournament even if they can't afford tickets to the games. City hall officials say the initiative already has started and will run through the end of the school year on June '26. Schools interested in getting an open street can contact the nonprofit organization Street Lab for more information.
The New York Knicks are heading to the Eastern Conference finals for the second straight year. They swept the Philadelphia 76ers with a barrage of three pointers. Another dominating win for the Knicks' 144 to 114, and it really wasn't that close. The Knicks now wait the winner of the Detroit-Cleveland series.
Upper 50s now. Some sunshine. Some clouds too. Mostly cloudy today in mid-60s for high temperatures. Tomorrow, sunny and 68. Wednesday, afternoon showers likely, mid 60s, and high gusting winds. Michael Hill, WNYC News.
[00:30:21] [END OF AUDIO]
Copyright © 2026 New York Public Radio. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use at www.wnyc.org for further information.
New York Public Radio transcripts are created on a rush deadline, often by contractors. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of New York Public Radio’s programming is the audio record.