Do Emergency Sirens Really Have to Be So Loud?

All Of It with Alison Stewart | May 8, 2025

Note: This conversation was interrupted by the breaking news that a new pope has been selected. Pope Leo XIV, from Chicago, is the first ever pontiff from the United States. Tune in on Monday when we'll continue our scheduled discussion about sirens. 

When and why did emergency sirens get so loud? These are questions that Ben Naddaf-Hafrey, senior producer for Pushkin Industries, tried to answer in a recent episode of Malcolm Gladwell's "Revisionist History" podcast. Naddaf-Hafrey lives opposite a fire station in Brooklyn, which means he is often exposed to the high decibels of an engine's siren. But, as he discovered in his reporting, loud sirens may not be as effective in saving lives as we think. Naddaf-Hafrey discusses what he found and listeners share their experiences with sirens on the streets of New York.

Top Stories

Throngs of Knicks fans surge into Lower Manhattan to witness historic parade

How an alleged NYC real estate scammer stayed in business despite years of complaints

What Are Ultra-Processed Foods and What Are They Doing to Us?

How to be a Good New York City Tour Guide

YOU ARE ONLINE