Teens And Mall Culture: The Fading Love Affair?
Tuesday, August 19, 2014
Part of a series on the past, present and future of America's malls
For half a century, the mall was a place to meet and hang out for teens and tweens. It was also a source of jobs for youth. There were about 3 million retail jobs for 16- to 19-year-olds in 1990, but today, it's closer to 1 million, according to the Labor Department. In addition to dwindling jobs, the rise in technology is making it hard to even get teens to spend time in malls.
I head out looking for teens in an unscientific search to see if they are hanging out at the mall.
I don't have much luck.
I hit two popular malls in Atlanta. First, I go to Lenox Square, a traditional indoor mall that's been around since 1959. I wind up at Urban Outfitters, where I meet Nicole Sullivan. She looks like someone I might find at my high school.
"This is my first job, but I really like it. I enjoy it," she says.
The numbers show not many teens are working in malls. But here at Lenox Mall, I don't even see many teens hanging out. And that has nothing to do with the job market.
I ask Sullivan — she's actually 20 — if she sees many teens.
"A lot of younger kids, maybe just touching 13. They'll be in huge groups and they'll buy stuff, but it's always, like, 'OK, where are your parents?' " Sullivan says.
I get a similar response from Ashleigh Berglund, also in her 20s, who works in the junior section of Macy's. "I see a lot more preteens in the mall. Teenagers not so much actually."
Okay, so maybe for tweens, this mall has some staying power, but teens are another story.
My next stop: Atlantic Station. It's one of the newest malls in Atlanta, opened in 2005. It's outdoors, with sidewalks, and has apartments above the shops. I lived in Atlantic Station for a few years, and my friend Maya Pines, 17, still lives here. We used to hang out with our friends in the mall, but that's changed.
"Over time, movies would be the only thing that made me want to hang out," Pines says. "Then also, the officers, if they didn't know me, after a certain time they'd start asking me, 'Where's your parent? Where are you going?' That would get pretty annoying so I would not want to come outside."
Atlantic Station is strict with teenagers. After 8 p.m., no one younger than 17 can buy a movie ticket or walk around without an adult. And after 11 p.m., people between 17 and 21 years old aren't allowed on the property. These rules make it pretty hard for teens to have much fun at Atlantic Station, especially since none of us are ready to head home by 8 o'clock.
And although I did find a few teens hanging out here, I also got asked to stop recording, because a story about teens and malls didn't fit the company's branding.
So where are the teens? Pines says her idea of fun with friends doesn't include malls anymore. "It's usually something simple like going over to their house rather than hanging out outside."
On a recent Saturday night, I was hanging out at my house with my friend Allison Rapoport after watching Monsters Inc. I spend a lot of my free time like this. And my mom, Renae Veira, says she prefers it that way.
"As a parent, I personally don't like the idea of you going to the mall," she told me. "The more time you spend at the mall, the more likely you'll spend money at the mall. I'd much rather have your friends at the house and I can keep an eye on you. I don't have to worry about predators out there."
I don't really care for going to the mall with friends. I ask my mom if she thinks technology has anything to do with it.
"I would definitely say that technology is the No. 1 factor affecting the mall culture today. More so than the danger of going to the mall and the waste of time," she says.
It's true — Allison and I spend a lot more time with technology than at the mall.
"I definitely will sit in the house watching TV or Netflix for several hours straight and just be like, 'I feel fat and like I need to go move.' But then again, Netflix is so wonderful," she says.
To be fair, Allison likes doing active things too, like going to the park to play Frisbee or soccer with friends. But the stereotype of teens hanging out together while on their devices isn't totally off the mark.
"We are all constantly on our cellphones," she says. "That's true, but that doesn't mean we don't speak to one another. We still talk to one another. And sometimes we talk about things that are happening on social media. For example, Twitter fights are very entertaining to observe and so are Facebook fights. It's great entertainment. Free entertainment. I don't think it's laziness. It's just inconvenient to go to the mall. Why would you go to the mall? It's unnecessary."
As for shopping, Allison does it online.
But does that mean malls are dying? Hard to say. I still visit the mall every once in a while to shop, and I'm not alone. Teens spend an average of $165 a month at malls, according to the International Council of Shopping Centers.
I definitely make one mall visit before school starts. I can't have a lame wardrobe my senior year.
This story was produced by Youth Radio.