Profiting from Offenders When They Get Out of Jail

Tuesday, June 24, 2014

Sarah Stillman investigates the industry of extra-carceral justice options, which include private-probation companies, halfway houses, and residential treatment centers. Her article “Get Out of Jail, Inc.” in the June 23, 2014, issue of The New Yorker, looks at the legality of a system of "offender-funded justice" that seems to profit from offenders, many of whom cannot pay their fees.

Stillman explains why courts are increasingly turning to private companies to collect fees and fines: “These courts are so starved for cash and they’re so desperate…to use the courts as revenue centers that they’re pursuing money from even some of the poorest people.”

On whether these companies are targeting indigent offenders: “Often what you’re finding is that these companies really wouldn’t make a whole lot of money if they weren’t able to collect from indigent people. I mean, that’s really a lot of their business practice, revolves around the very poorest clients. That’s why they’re there in the first place is that they weren’t able to pay their tickets or weren’t able to pay their court costs.”

Some defendants, unable to pay their fees and fines, have become desperate to avoid jail. In her reporting, Stillman talked to one professor who had conducted a survey of people who were on private probation and found that “about a third of them had resorted to committing a crime simply to try to pay their fees and fines to get out of jail or to ensure that they didn’t go to jail.”

Some have compared this system of “offender-funded justice” to 19th century debtors’ prisons: “I spoke to many attorneys who pointed out if this were happening in any other context – if this were credit card companies or if this were other industries that were going after people for debt – we would certainly all say, ‘Hey, this is a debtors’ prison. This is unconstitutional.’ But because it’s happening in the context of courts being the ones collecting the cash, somehow it’s managed to proliferate.”


Sarah Stillman

Comments [3]

Pat from NJ

This problem sounds like more evidence that we are slowly devolving into a feudal society. I am grateful that we still have journalists like your guest that are willing to shine the light on to these deplorable practices. Unfortunately, we need both knowledge and action to solve the problem, and with our dysfunctional government, I fear that we will never see the latter.

Jun. 24 2014 02:00 PM
DC from Brooklyn, NY

It's deplorable that the costs of law and order have to be levied on the poor, who commit most crimes because they can't afford anything in the first place. If the rich commit a crime, they are praised for it and untouched because of "collateral consequences."

Jun. 24 2014 01:48 PM
Amy from Manhattan

This does sound like debtor's prison, in all but name.

Jun. 24 2014 01:37 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.