NJ Transit Problems at 2014 Super Bowl Were Underrated, Report Reveals

Friday, August 08, 2014 - 06:24 PM

Super Bowl ad at Newark Penn Station (Julianne Welby/WNYC)

New Jersey Transit's struggles with large crowds at February's Super Bowl game were worse than previously known, a new report revealed.

The transit agency spent roughly $350,000 on the report, prepared by the New York law firm McElroy, Deutsch, Mulvaney and Carpenter, which most notably detailed poor crowd management and disagreements between high-ranking New Jersey leaders.

Because crowds at the game exceeded estimates by more than 200,000 passengers, NJ Transit was already at a disadvantage. Disorganization at a temporary tent that housed commuters, where they waited to board a shuttle train from the Meadowlands Station to Secaucus Junction, only worsened the situation. On-site staff directed some passengers to line up in the tent — Pavilion 6 — while other passengers were allowed to move freely in front of those passengers who already lined up. As a result, crowds rushed to the front and a melee ensued.

“The thirty-three minute delay was caused, in part, by the amount of time the [New Jersey State Police] took to set up corrals inside Pavilion 6 and outside Pavilion 6 near the entrance doors,” the report stated. “This delay was exacerbated by the time it took for the passengers to exit Pavilion 6 due to the bottlenecks created inside the tent by the configuration of the corrals.”

As news of the growing crowds near Pavilion 6 spread, Gov. Chris Christie's chief counsel, Christopher Porrino, and NJ Transit Executive Director Jim Weinstein disagreed over whether to use buses when people were waiting nearly three hours for trains. Eventually, they did bring in buses.

Despite these issues, the report said the transit agency moved all passengers safely and didn't turn anyone away — even if overall operations for the big game could have been more efficient.

New Jersey State Senator Bob Gordon said the report goes too lightly on the agency. He said the delays could have been avoided and that officials relied on faulty assumptions to execute their plans.

Final SuperBowl Report 


Comments [3]

DB from NYC

"Because crowds at the game exceeded estimates by more than 200,000 passengers, NJ Transit was already at a disadvantage."

I assume this number was supposed to be 20,000 not 200,000. (33,000 mass transit riders - estimated 12,000 = ~20,000 underestimate.)

Otherwise, the field would have to be used for General Admission, or it would have been the biggest tailgate party ever.

Aug. 18 2014 05:49 PM

I still say and continue to say that somebody DROPPED THE BALL AND I DON!T MEAN THE FOOTBALL in this instance. Everybody from Senator Chuck Schumer on down came out to try and promote this Superbowl football game yet, there were no extra plans or meetings that I know of on the transportation side that would place extra transit service into effect to Met Life Stadium for this event and New Jersey Transit only offers Sunday Service and only certain train lines under the control of New Jersey Transit are allowed to operate on a Sunday. A little common sense upstairs would tell these officials that extra transportation MUST be considered for this event or it should have been moved to another city. CASE CLOSED!!!

Aug. 12 2014 08:55 AM

$350,000 to tell them what they could have figured out by reading Twitter?! Just one more example of mismanagement and waste at NJ Transit.

Aug. 08 2014 10:50 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.