New York Health Exchange Gears Up for December Rush

Officials say system capacity adequate

Thursday, December 05, 2013

Health insurance exchanges are in the middle of their version of the holiday shopping crunch.

Millions of Americans who want coverage in place for the start of 2014 have to buy it by Dec. 23.

In Albany, the people behind the New York State of Health say the website — which slowed to a crawl when the exchange launched in early October — can handle whatever crowds arrive online in the coming weeks.

“That was a spike no one could’ve planned for,” said Chris Harmer, the project manager from Computer Sciences Corporation, the contractor that largely operates the state exchange.

In August, Donna Frescatore, the top state official in charge of the exchange, told WNYC the system would be ready Oct. 1, and she emphatically said it was passing all the simulated “stress tests.” But for the first week, it was extremely difficult to get onto the website, and those who did make it a few pages in frequently got frozen out.

Harmer last week said that technically, the system didn’t crash. It was just running very, very slowly.

“It was a load beyond any reasonable modeling, given the population of the state,” he said.

Since the early days, the site has run relatively smoothly compared to the federal website, which operates in New Jersey and most states. And yet many problems persist. Most days bring new complaints to the exchange’s Facebook page.

"I've spent over six hours trying to navigate the site only to get spinning rainbow wheels and the site not responding,” wrote Maryann Manelski, a New York City-based filmmaker and writer.

Exchange officials say they address each problem as it arises. But Frescatore said there are no serious patterns of trouble — just individual issues.

“We try to listen to everything — to social media, to customer service, to our navigators — and work every day to make it better,” Frescatore said.

About 50,000 people have enrolled in private insurance plans through New York's exchange so far. The state’s goal is to enroll about 300,000 people by the end of next year — a sum that does not include up to 1.6 million New Yorkers whose policies have been cancelled for failing to meet new federal standards.



Hosted by:

Marc Garber


More in:

Comments [2]

New Yorker from New York City

I signed up for a plan via the New York State of Health website in early November and printed out a confirmation page that showed my transaction went through, but I have yet to hear from anyone about actually signing up for the insurance. I called the state twice and was first told I would hear within 7 to 10 days from them via email as well as my chosen insurance company via mail, but I didn't. So I called back and was promised I would hear from both entities by the end of the month. I still haven't heard anything. I contacted the New York State of Health on Twitter a couple of days ago and was told they would look into the status of my application but still haven't heard back. I am panicked now. My current insurance plan ends on Dec. 31 because of Obamacare. I can't be without health insurance on Jan. 1. I don't know who else to contact at this point.

Dec. 06 2013 12:45 PM
Joan from Westchester

Just a warning to people using the NY State Health Exchange Website -- the information about what doctors and hospitals participate in the various plans is NOT accurate. We signed on with a plan that both the site AND the insurance company itself said included a certain doctor, but when we checked with the doctor's physician organization, we were told that was totally NOT true. He was NOT in that plan at all. I contacted the NY State Health Exchange and told them about this and they said yes they know their information is inaccurate. The companies and doctors don't update them. But even though they know they're peddling inaccurate information, they don't warn people of that on the website...The website is working better now but providing inaccurate information is troubling.

Dec. 05 2013 08:16 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


Latest Newscast




WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public


Supported by