Cell Phones in Schools: Lessons from the Front Line

Monday, May 19, 2014 - 04:00 AM

Said Muwalled, keeping his headphones out of his ears, during class with English teacher Erin Bauer (Beth Fertig/WNYC)

New York City’s Department of Education officially bans students from bringing cell phones to school, but at one high school in Brooklyn the faculty has surrendered to the reality that their students have their phones and will sneak them out at any chance.

West Brooklyn Community High School allows phones in the classroom while faculty members try to teach students about responsibility in the digital age. Principal Gloria Rosario said the policy evolved by trial and error.

"If you get into a power struggle with the young person, you will never win," she explained. Rosario said teachers used to waste too much classroom time on "pointless battles" and prefer instead to help students focus on classwork.

They also use a system that emphasizes positive behavior, giving their students up to five points per class for good engagement, which includes showing up on time and not using electronics. Students told WNYC they liked the point system and the emphasis on personal responsibility.

"If they’re taking off points, that’s you," said 17-year-old Ariel Bravo. "You’re going to be here way longer. And if you want to see all your friends and be with them and texting them, you’re going to be delayed on graduating."

West Brooklyn is a transfer school for students who enrolled somewhere else first and now are behind in the credits needed to graduate.

"We should be mature enough not to take out our phone because all of our friends are also in class," added 18-year-old Christina Rodriguez.

If a student does not abide by a teacher's request to put away the phone, the teacher may call his or her advocate counselor. One counselor, Bernard Greene, said he uses those moments to give the students a lesson about real-life consequences.

"If you’re at a job and they told you to put your phone away and you didn’t you would get sent home," he said. "And I know that because I’ve been sent home before at previous jobs for doing that same thing."

During a recent English class, students worked quietly on their writing assignment. Only one student was warned for looking at his cell phone; the teacher told him he'd sit at a different desk the next day.

Seventeen year-old Said Muwalled kept his white headphones fully visible, but they were draped over his ears, not in them. At the end of class, he swore he had managed himself well: "I took it out to get somebody's number once," he confessed but promised that was it. 

This report is part of American Graduate, a public media initiative addressing the drop-out crisis, supported by the Corporation of Public Broadcasting. Our ongoing "Educating on the Edge" series is here.


Comments [5]

Unfortunately since our lives center around cell phone use it is very hard to stop the kids from having them in school. However....I believe they are misused by students in school. I have seen netflix open, constant texting and video. They must be so hard to put down.

I hope that in the next few years the younger students have learned to balance and managing their cell phone and computer use. Focusing on using them as a tool.

Jan. 15 2015 08:54 AM
Priscilla Murtha

It's simple--no cell phones in class, both teachers and students. Teachers set the example.

May. 22 2014 03:59 PM
Geraldine maione

As a former high school principal I have to say that each principal should do what they see fit in regard to cell phones . To be honest minority students are the students most effected by the ban. Many pay at least one or two dollars to store their phones due to scanning. I was the principal at William Grady and always felt the ban was discriminatory.

May. 21 2014 03:51 PM
Ax from Hawaii

Engage the students in new ways using the devices ala Is what is used in many schools already...

May. 20 2014 06:42 PM
Angela Sanders

it doesn't always work

May. 19 2014 11:14 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.