Council Speaker Quinn Opposes Paid Sick Day Legislation

Thursday, October 14, 2010

City Council Speaker Christine Quinn said she won’t support a bill requiring businesses to give workers paid time off when they get sick. This comes after more than a year of intense lobbying from business groups, who called the legislation too costly, and supporters, like the Working Families Party, who said it provides vital protection for poor New Yorkers and health protection to the city overall.

Quinn, a liberal Democrat from the West Village whom many expect to run for mayor in 2013, said she supports the goals of the bill, but worried about its impact.

“My main concern was doing this in a recession and doing this at a time when many small businesses in the city of New York are not even breaking even,” Quinn said.

She said pushing the legislation forward now would backfire, and actually hurt the very workers that the bill was targeting.

“It would be a great thing if we could mandate that every worker got paid sick leave,” Quinn said. “But, if we do that and it in fact causes people to lose their jobs, what benefit have we actually forwarded?”

Supporters noted the bill has support from a veto-proof majority of members in the 51-person City Council. But the bill’s sponsor, councilwoman Gale Brewer of the Upper West Side, said she won’t push for an up-or-down vote on the legislation, yet, saying its fate would not be certain.

Brewer said she didn’t understand her fellow Democrat’s position.

“Having spent decades in the women’s movement –- this is a women’s issue, it’s a public health issue –- and I don’t understand from her perspective as a woman why she wouldn’t be more supportive,” Brewer said after Quinn’s announcement.

Quinn denied politics played a factor in her decision.

“I have to go to bed tonight as the Speaker of the New York City Council. And I have to go to bed tonight knowing I made a decision that was not easy, based on the requirements of the job that I hold,” Quinn said. “That’s all I can do today.”

Blocking the paid-sick day legislation could potentially earn Quinn support among the city’s business leaders who will likely be looking for a candidate to support. Many of them have enjoyed an open-door policy with Mayor Michael Bloomberg, who says he will not seek a fourth term.

Referring to the politics of a possible run in the  2013 mayoral race, Quinn said, “I’m not thinking about it.”


More in:

Comments [4]

linaspopswife from New York City

As a woman with two children, running my own business, I NEVER get paid sick leave (for 20 years now). One of my children has autism (we struggle with that) and my other teen, who is getting acceptances to colleges (and is a great student) but has to go the CUNY route because we cannot afford a private college(she was accepted to two wonderful ones)... I am appalled with Ms. Quinn. For the record, when I am sick as a dog, I work while I am sick, because otherwise, I do not get paid. (Hope I don't spread all my germs to everyone!) There is no break for me. Ms. Quinn has become another egotistical politician, who is power hungry, just like so many of them. She obviously does not understand where the rest of NYC is coming from. When Ms. Quinn first came on board, I thought - here is a Democrat who is going to get things done and fight for the middle class people... but I'm sorry to say, she definitely just lost my vote for good.

Apr. 11 2013 09:03 PM
linaspop from Upper West Side

Christine Quinn is another corporate hack disguised as a gay liberal. Just what NYC needs, another politician in the back pocket of the rich. Remember everyone, "working class people don't deserve paid sick leave", some Mr. Bag O' Money might lose a couple of pennies. Excuse me while I wretch!

Apr. 11 2013 08:39 PM

St Vincents ran itself into the ground by running up its debt and treating patients who are hypo-condriacs.

Oct. 18 2011 03:22 PM
key from West Village

Christine Quinn is increasingly on the wrong side of the issues. She is personally responsible for the closing of St. Vincents Hospital by voraciously opposing their modernization proposals. She ran them out of town and cost NYC a valued resource.

Oct. 15 2010 10:47 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


Latest Newscast




WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public


Supported by