A Colombian Model for the MTA?

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

New York City's transit system faces two almost-certain realities. Its ridership will swell. And it will continue to struggle financially. But planners are hoping to bring a new type of transit to the city -- Bus Rapid Transit, or BRT. More than an express route, BRT is designed to act like an above-ground light rail system, but at a fraction of the cost. Reporter Steven Dudley begins a WNYC series on BRT with a report from Bogotá, Colombia, which has emerged as an unexpected model for BRT systems around the globe.

About 10 years ago, Bogotá's main artery, known as the Caracas, was filled from side to side with a hodgepodge of yellow, blue, green, white and red buses of all sizes and shapes. The shops were covered in a layer of soot, and the street sat beneath a grayish haze, as the buses coughed out diesel-laced smoke in their futile effort to navigate the constant traffic jam.

Sanchez: Esto era una troncal.

Oscar Sanchez has a picture frame shop on 60th Street with Caracas.

Sanchez: Los arbolitos hasta se danaban.

This was so full of smoke, he says, even the trees couldn’t survive. What’s more, he adds, we used to call this the “neckbreaking path” because of all the crime.

Sanchez: El desnucadero de la Caracas. Lo robaban a usted.

Then Bogotá elected Enrique Penalosa, whose obsession with rebuilding urban landscapes had already led him to the small Brazilian city of Curitiba. In Curitiba, buses work like a subway with dedicated lanes and long, caged platforms that process payments and serve as de facto stations. Penalosa did the math: it was up to five times cheaper to build the bus system and would service the 75 percent of the people that didn’t have a car. Then, he says, he fought off the naysayers.

Penalosa: Road space is the most important space a city has. Its more important than diamonds. And one of the most important ideological and political decisions is how to distribute such road space between pedestrians, bicycles, public transport and cars. I would say the way this is distributed says a lot about the democracy.

Within a year, the new system was up and running. Sleek red buses cruised up and down the avenue. The smog dissipated. Business picked up. Penalosa’s own popularity soared, and political controversy has largely subsided, along with commute times.

These days, Sanchez prefers to leave his car at the office when he has to pick up supplies in the city center.

Sanchez: Anteriormente cuando uno ir al centro.

To get downtown before, he says, it used to take me 45 minutes to an hour. Now I get there in 15 to 20.

Sanchez: Estoy alla en 15 minutos.

The change along the Caracas made Bogotá the envy of planners and politicians around the globe. From Jarkarta to Cape Town, cities are trying their own BRTs.

It was also the beginning of a city-wide renaissance. Bogotá coupled its BRT with 180 miles of bicycle lanes, over a 1000 new parks and plazas, several new housing projects, and refurbished schools.

At the Tintal Library, on the western edge of Bogotá, users crowd the information desk. The library sits near one of the city’s main bus lines on what was once a garbage dump. Now, Andres Lara, who works for the Institute for Transportation and Development Policy, an independent think tank promoting mass transit systems like the Transmilenio, says the library services hundreds of users a day in this, one of the poorest sections of the city.

Lara: Transmilenio is not only a solution in terms of urban transportation. It is an integrated policy in terms of urban renovation, urban revitalization and urban public space recovery.

But in the 10 years of servicing Bogotá, a city of seven million people, the Transmilenio has also manifested a BRT’s limitations. The Transmilenio has eliminated hundreds of buses like the ones that once clogged the Caracas, lowering CO2 emissions and opening up the city's lanes.

But that's forced many people to depend on its overcrowded feeder system and main stations, and made rush hour often like a rugby match.

Rodriguez: El servicio es pesimo.

This bus service is terrible, says Omar Rodriguez, an office messenger on his way to work. You feel like a hamburger squeezed into a bun.

Rodriguez: Como una hamburgesa apretado.

As he speaks, the bus doors open and dozens squish each other to get on. The city administrates the service, but contracts out the buses and bus lines. The contracts stretch for years, and there are bureaucratic hurdles each time the system needs a tweak or two.

Jorge Matiz is a former professor of urban development at the National University in Bogotá.

In spite of the permanent imprint they’d like to make with Transmilenio, he says, the whole city cannot operate in the same way. We have to reestablish which type of corridors require which type of public transportation, he adds, and not wed ourselves to one single system. Implementing a BRT in New York City may require a similar flexibility. Despite a bailout from Albany, the MTA is facing shortfalls, and the population has an already established rhythm to its commute.

But Jaime Fernando Paez, the general manager of the Transmilenio system in Bogotá, believes New Yorkers will quickly take to a BRT.

Paez: Creo que lo mas importante...

The important thing, he says, is that the New York City government needs to sell the system for what it is: a quicker, but not necessarily a more comfortable, means of transport. Still, Penalosa, who has lived in New York, says its important to understand that the BRT is not just a glorified bus service.

Penalosa: Nobody who takes Transmilenio says they’re going to take the bus. It’s as if it were a flying saucer or something, it’s a completely different perception. So the color is important, the name is important. To have very beautiful sidewalks. Improve the whole environment around the system so that you raise the social status of using the bus.”

The former Bogotá mayor adds that if New York is committed to this project, it could do something that could help cities throughout the United States: make buses sexy again.

--Steven Dudley

The Transmilenio police force. Four attacks have occurred in 10 years.
The bus system saves time with passengers paying before boarding.
A passenger studies the Transmilenio map in Bogota.
A Transmilenio services 1.5 million people a day.
The current system has close to 50 miles of specialized bus lanes.
Passengers pass fare cards over an automated machine to speed entry.
Passengers can switch lines without leaving the depot, like a subway.
Discounted rates for off-peak travel may be used to reduce crowds.


More in:

Comments [6]

WNYC - WNYC News Blog » Should NYC Turn Stre

[...] A Colombian Model for the MTA? Tags: BRT | | Posted in Infrastructure, Metro [...]

May. 28 2009 12:32 PM

great idea

May. 26 2009 01:01 PM
Barbara Orlando

Listening to your BRT report just now, you seem unaware that New York City Transit and the City DOT launched the City's first Bus Rapid Transit system in the Bronx almost a year ago, in June 2008. It uses specially fitted articulated buses on the Bronx 12 express route, off-board fare purchases, front and rear-door loading, special bus lanes and a traffic-priority system at stop-light intersections. For more info, call the NYC Transit press office at 646-252-5850. Or, check on line. (sorry if I missed coverage of this before I tuned in.) I think you own your listeners an update. (Last I knew, additional routes were being considered based on lessons learned from this first route.)

Regards, Barbara Orlando

May. 26 2009 06:26 AM
Kofi Martin

I interned at WNYC last summer and now I'm where they're focusing on quality transportation; small world. I'd have to admit that I find the Transmilenio very convenient in comparison to the NYC transit system... and safer.

May. 23 2009 11:00 AM
Clark Morris

BRT will take as much lane space as a streetcar. The station sizes will be comparable and it will carry fewer people. It will be less wheelchair friendly than a streetcar and the bikes will be outside as opposed to inside the streetcar adding to stop time. People won't tolerate the crowding that is present in Bogota, Colombia. The streetcar will cost more to build but it will cost less to operate. New York has the passenger volume to justify rail (5000 passenger miles per route mile per day) on many of its bus corridors. Le Mans, France believes that light rail has made a difference and was well worth the expenditure. Maybe New York can learn from them.

May. 22 2009 01:33 PM

Good article. Bike racks on the buses too?

May. 22 2009 10:01 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


Latest Newscast




WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public


Supported by