Not All Teachers Falling in Line Behind Thompson

UFT Endorsement Swayed Few in Non-Scientific Survey

Friday, September 06, 2013 - 03:28 PM

Bill Thompson, receiving the endorsement of the United Federation of Teachers in June, 2013. (Beth Fertig/WNYC)

The United Federation of Teachers has gone all-out in its endorsement of mayoral candidate Bill Thompson, spending more than $1 million through its political action committee and producing a new television ad. But will teachers follow their union’s lead?

Schoolbook reached out directly to dozens of city teachers the week before the Democratic primary, and also gathered comments through social media. We’ll be the first to admit this was not a scientific, representational sample but we heard from a lot of teachers who do not plan to vote for Thompson.

Megan Moskop, who said she teaches at a Washington Heights middle school, spoke for many of those we heard from when she explained why candidate Bill de Blasio is her choice.

“His idea of universal pre-K is almost like a no-brainer because we’ve known for a really, really long time that early childhood education is one of the best ways to close the achievement gap,” she said. “So when he came out early with that plan, I think it made it clear that he was a good candidate most committed to making our system better and making our schools stronger for all students, not just for some students.”

A Manhattan elementary school teacher, who did not want to be identified, agreed that de Blasio “understands that pre-k for all NYC kids is an essential if we are ever going to bridge the huge divide between the haves and have nots.”  

Some teachers said they weren’t happy with the way the union endorsement was handled, claiming that the fix was in from the start. They pointed to the fact that the influential president of the American Federation of Teachers, Randi Weingarten, threw her support early behind Thompson, whom she knew from when she headed the UFT and he was president of the former Board of Education.

Sam Coleman, a member of the MORE caucus and a teacher at P.S. 24 in Brooklyn, questioned the process.

“The union (Unity) leadership has its own reasons for supporting Thompson that have nothing to do with the rank and file. There was no democratic process for that decision,” he said.

Arthur Goldstein, a chapter leader at Francis Lewis High School in Queens, said  initially he backed Thompson but has changed his mind.

“I supported Thompson until de Blasio surged,” he said. “I think he's the better choice. Thompson sways with the wind.”

But other teachers said their union’s endorsement does matter to them. One, who teaches special education Washington Heights, said it meant Thompson would represent their concerns.

Anna Maley, who teaches at  I.S. 181 in the Bronx, also cited Thompson’s experience and family background.

“I want a mayor that supports and respects teachers,” she said. “Since Thompson's mother and daughter were both teachers I feel that he has seen, first-hand, the tremendous work we put into this profession and will stand by us through this new teacher rating and will give us a fair contract that we are entitled to.”

Maley also summed up why few if any teachers have come out in support of Christine Quinn.

“Christine Quinn is just another Bloomberg and we all know that Bloomberg has targeted teachers,” she said.

Quinn was booed, in fact, when she appeared at a candidate’s forum in the spring sponsored by the union. Many teachers were upset that she didn’t strongly object to Bloomberg’s focus on test scores and to the closing of low-performing schools. She is also the only Democrat who said she would be willing to appoint a chancellor who is not an educator, because she wouldn't want to rule out someone with other solid credentials.

But long-time teachers also know they can’t count on any candidate’s campaign promises, especially now when the city faces contract negotiations with all of its major unions.

Martin Haber, a chapter leader at John Dewey High School in Brooklyn, said he preferred de Blasio but, he added: "I do think of [de Blasio] as a politician, though, and fear that he will make a deal to continue to sell out public school teachers."


Comments [1]

Katie Lapham from Brooklyn

I am a UFT teacher but was never a Thompson supporter, primarily because of his ties to the Board of Regents' Merryl Tisch. Also, he is not progressive. Bill de Blasio has been a disappointment too. His understanding of education seems limited and he mostly just talks about pre-K for all and funding for after school programs. While important, there are many other pressing issues that he (and Thompson as well) have not addressed. John Liu, on the other hand, knows what is going on at Tweed and gets why teachers and administrators are so frustrated. I heard him speak at two education forums and was impressed with his in-depth knowledge of a wide range of issues. Here is a copy of a letter I sent to Michael Mulgrew, the UFT's president, in June.

Dear Michael Mulgrew,

I am writing to strongly urge the UFT to endorse John Liu for mayor of New York City.

I heard Liu address education issues at two different mayoral forums: one at the Brooklyn UFT office, and last night at a forum on education for parents.

Having a son in a New York City public school, John Liu sees firsthand the struggles and burdens of our city’s teachers. Unlike the current administration, he does not believe in high-stakes testing and he feels that we should be “running schools, not marketing firms.” In addition, John Liu is in the unique position of having audited the Department of Education as Comptroller of New York City. He’s identified the areas of wasteful spending, and he will reduce the Department’s pet projects which enrich outside consultants, not students.

John Liu comes across as authentic and genuine and he trusts teachers to teach. I truly believe that as mayor he will engage with teachers in an open dialogue to brainstorm real education reform for New York City schools.

Kind regards,
Katie Lapham
NYC public school teacher

Sep. 06 2013 09:31 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.