Report: New Yorkers Pay a Price for Longer Unemployment

Email a Friend
Unemployment insurance form

A new report on the status of workers finds the period since the 2008 market crash may turn out to have long-term effects for New Yorkers, as wages stagnate and the average time for unemployment lengthens.

The Fiscal Policy Institute, a union-financed think tank, found that the current economic recovery continues to be the weakest on record since the Great Depression of the 1930’s.

FPI economist James Parrott said that while New York had the sixth-best job growth performance among all 50 states, the rate of unemployment stayed above 8 percent for four years, until it dropped slightly in April. An 8  percent or higher unemployment rate is one of the key indicators of a recession.

Parrott said the average length of time that unemployed New Yorkers have been out of work is 37 weeks, or about eight months. That’s longer than the national average of seven months. Those lengthy periods of joblessness have ripple effects that range from defaulting on payments for houses and cars, to depleting retirement savings, to health problems, he said.

“Divorce rates are higher among people who have been unemployed for long period of time,” Parrot said. “Their health is poor, suicide rates are measurably higher, and their life time earnings take a hit.”

College-educated unemployed New Yorkers are out of work longer on average than high school graduates. Older workers also have to wait longer to find new jobs and they are often lower paying than the positions that they lost. The job growth that has occurred is in lower-paying industries like restaurants and retail. Those who are still lucky enough to have jobs have not seen pay increases that keep up with living expenses, and in many cases, have seen their salaries cut. “Wages in 2012 are less than they were in 2002,” Parrott said. 

The survey finds a wide gap between the financial conditions of downstate residents and upstate residents. New York City is doing relatively well: there are nearly 5 percent more jobs than before the recession began in 2008. But wide swaths of upstate are mired in recession, with an average of 1.6 percent fewer jobs than before 2008. The exceptions are Long Island and the Ithaca area, where jobs are growing faster than the national average. 

Parrott attributes New York City’s success to the government’s massive financial bailout of Wall Street. He says the 2009 stimulus program of $800 billion helped for a period of time.  “But the effects of that have long since worn off,” Parrott said. 

Parrott believes that the federal government needs to spend more money to stimulate the economy. But he concedes that given the current political dynamics in Congress, that’s not likely to happen.

The average working New Yorker hasn't had it easy. Unlike past recessions, where governments spent more to boost economic activity, he said that state and local governments have been further cutting spending and jobs. There’s been a 5 percent decline in government jobs, mostly due to teacher layoffs.  “There’s nothing inevitable about this prolonged high unemployment,” said Parrot. “We know the economic policies that need to be pursued.” 

There are some bright spots, though. Parrott said New York raised the minimum wage this year, though he thinks the long phase-in won’t boost wages fast enough. And he said New Yorkers who are wealthy have mostly recovered from the recession, largely due to the stock market's rebound and soaring corporate profits.