Five Tips for Identifying a Good School

Monday, November 07, 2011 - 09:56 AM

Peg Tyre, a longtime education journalist and the recipient of the Spencer Fellowship for Education Journalism at Columbia University, is the author of “The Good School: How Smart Parents Get Their Kids the Education They Deserve” (Henry Holt). She has mined three decades of education research — and written about it in a way that parents can understand. This week she will be taking your questions about how to identify a good school for your child. Your questions can be submitted through the query, below.

You have been checking the Web sites. Talking to friends. Maybe you have even been on a conga line of parents snaking through a classroom on an overcrowded school tour. This much you know: choosing the right school for your child is an important decision.

But in your quiet moments, you recognize that you have almost no objective criteria for making this decision.

Here are five research-based tips for identifying what makes a “good” school.


What makes a good preschool?


Good preschools do not looked like scaled-down versions of fourth grade. Worksheets? Not a good sign. All learning should be embedded in play.

That said, there should be plenty of emphasis on letters and their corresponding sounds (B makes the buh sound) and ample opportunities to speak and listen, as well as rhyme and sing.

Crabby preschool teachers? Beware. Research shows that good preschool teachers take obvious pleasure in their young scholars.


How should I evaluate test scores?


Choosing a school by test scores is like buying a car based on the color of its paint. There are better measures.

A school that serves mixed-income children that has high tests scores may be doing a fantastic job, or cheating those students out of a good education.

On your tour, ask this question: What has the school done to raise test scores for a subcategory of students in the last five years (say, English language learners, or children who are designated special education)?

If the answer is “adding more test prep,” be wary. Questions on standardized test are pulled from the lower third of course material. Schools that align their course material with the tests are really dumbing it down.


What does a good reading program look like?


There is a significant disconnect between how scientists know children learn to read and how children are taught to read in school. Word to the wise: Make sure your first-grade child gets a solid dose of that old Eisenhower bad-boy phonics.

How fast you learn to read has nothing to do with how smart you are, but by the time children are in first grade, they should be making steady progress toward mastery.

Ask this: What does the school do when a child is not reading at grade level? Correct answer: There should a rapid comprehensive intervention that helps them build basic decoding skills. Giving them another year of the same flawed instruction is not a strategy to create a class of good readers.

After grade three, make sure there is plenty of reading going on in science, history, social studies and nonfiction, as well as fiction reading in English class.


What does a good math program look like?


Math ability builds on math experiences. From the first day of preschool, children should be exposed to numbers and simple math concepts (greater than or less than, bigger or smaller) and algorithms (add and take away).

A good elementary school math program (yes, I'm talking about you, Singapore math) helps children harness their innate sense of number, their mental math, to understand math concepts. Being able to compute quickly and accurately is a must, too.


How much free play should I expect to see?


The data is clear: All children need at least 20 minutes of recess a day to keep their focus and behavior in check. But more recess would be better.

Rat studies show that rats that run on treadmills do better on rat-appropriate intelligence tests than the ones who lie around on cedar chips all day. Human studies show that physically fit children — especially ones with a high aerobic capacity — do better in school and in life.


News, weather, Radiolab, Brian Lehrer and more.
Get the best of WNYC in your inbox, every morning.

Leave a Comment

Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more. Learn more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting. By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.