Photo credit: @julesdwit.
A not-for-profit media organization supported by people like you.
The person who suggested that the city utilise the unused buildings, formerly used as parochial schools, is on to something. Why not let us all be a bit more practical and less confrontational?
We have children to educate. FOR CRYING OUT LOUD!
There is no such thing as "secular religion." The former is defined as not the latter.
I understand why the religious want to refer to "secular religion" when they are challenged about the separation of church and state, but that doesn't make it valid.
Talk to religious people -- those whom others would label 'observant' or 'devout' -- and I think you've find that their beliefs have something in common.
* An origin/creation story.* Moral stricture.* Reference to mean/purpose of life, at least of death.* Claims of universality.* Reference to an external god or the supernatural that unites these pieces.
I don't think that the devoutly religious would take a group claiming religious status seriously if it lacked that last point. And few non-religious would label it a religion either (at not when pressed, "Is that *really* a religion?").
Sure, there are secular equivalents to some aspects of religion, but that doesn't make for a secular religion. Pig hearts are a lot of human hearts, but we don't think that pigs are humans. Not all distinct cultures are religions. Not all belief systems are religions. Not all value systems are religions. Not all creation stories are religions.
I know Brian (rightly) does not want to argue with is guests, but this claim of secular religion is such a common dodge from serious questions that I do not think that he should just let it slide by.
I completely agree with the caller who states that education in catholic schools is far superior to that in public schools. I have experienced both as a teacher and as a student.Just take a look at the parochial school students on the subway in their uniforms, the boys wear ties at school and the girls wear skirts (not jeans). I am not implying that the outfits indicate a superior education but they do signify that the students are being trained to conform to a work ethic when they become responsible adults.
I found the father disingenuous on a number of points. In particular, I found it offensive when he referred to 'secular beliefs' as a 'kind of religion'. Religion is based on faith, revelation and authority; all things that cannot be directly tested or disputed. The secular is based on direct, observable, repeatable facts. In the end it is possible for both to show truth, but they are in no way the same.
I chose that as a particularly offensive equivocation. He made other such comments on sex education and other issues that the Catholic Church in its position as arbiter of what is taught in its 'charter' schools would control.
I do not wish to finance that.
The priest would have a real problem if we were to refer to his "religion" as a superstition...why does he get to refer to secular rationalism as "secular religion"? It is not a religion...that's the whole point.
My mom is an administrator at a charter school in Youngstown, Ohio that used to be a Catholic school, and it is her responsibility to make sure they adhere to federal and state regulations, while maintaining their philanthropic mission. And I think you should hire her because I really want her to move to New York!
"Love" as a response to the question of fourth-grade sex ed in a Catholic charter school is wildly inappropriate.
As a former charter school teacher at the high-school level--and as a Catholic--I hope more rational minds prevail and establish some clear standards way before these school transformations take place.
The argument that being Catholic wouldn't impact schools because doesn't impact hospital isn't accurate. There are many Catholic hospitals that won't provide basic women's health care - like performing tubal ligations or giving our birth control - becuase of the religious beliefs.
I have no problem with the city opening a limited number of chartered schools in conjunction w/the Catholic church. Separately, the city should be looking to rent space from the recently closed parochial schools to reduce overcrowding.
should an organization so conservative and out of touch with mainstream amerika and with it's molestation history have anything to do with education?
Brian - Yes, charters are 'public' schools but they are VERY different from regular DOE public schools. Please talk about accountability, funding, performance, unions etc.
Why must the city jump right to the selection of charters as opposed to opening regular public schools? It is outrageous! We have seen this happening all over upper Manhattan, sidestepping parents, administrators and even the city's elected parent bodies which are supposed to vet such things. The city needs to invest resources in improving its public schools.
I hope you will discuss the enrollment levels, student populations and community feelings about the current public schools in this neighborhood.
Communities are changing across this city. My friends in some Brooklyn public schools report that their schools are half empty and are being considered for charter schools.
(1) There are other City public schools located in rented space (from converted warehouses to the lower floors of high rise apartment buildings). Are we going to start letting all those landlords have a say in choosing the curriculum?
(2)Can the City now convert other private schools into public schools and give preference to students who's parents had been paying $30,000 in tuition ?
This deal sets some bad precedents that go beyond the obvious issues of church and state.
Email addresses are required but never displayed.
Brian Lehrer leads the conversation about what matters most now in local and national politics, our own communities and our lives.
Subscribe on iTunes
Brian Lehrer Weekend: Losing Faith, First-Gen College Students & NYC Pizza
WNYC 93.9 FM and AM 820 are New York's flagship public radio
stations, broadcasting the finest programs from NPR, PRI and American Public Media, as well as a wide range of award-winning local
programming. WNYC is a division of
New York Public Radio.