NY Minimum Wage Bill Stalls in State Senate

Tuesday, March 05, 2013

The New York State Assembly on Tuesday approved a measure to increase New York’s minimum wage, but the measure is facing resistance in the State Senate.

Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver added yet another reason to his long list of reasons he thinks the state’s minimum wage is too low and needs to be increased. He says we are in the midst of a “jobless recovery,” with the Dow Jones Industrial Average closing at a record high on Tuesday at 14,253.

“Corporate profits are as high or higher than they’ve ever been,” said Silver. He said at the same time, economic growth is weak and unemployment is high.

“Not because workers are enjoying big wage increases,” he said. “They are not.”  

Speaker Silver was the first to call for an increase in the state’s minimum wage more than a year ago. He has raised the amount, after President Obama proposed a $9 an hour minimum wage hike in his State of the Union speech in February.

As part of his budget proposal, Governor Cuomo has recommended raising the minimum wage to $8.75. But there is some doubt that it will remain in the final budget agreement.

Speaker Silver says that’s all right with him, as long as the measure passes by the end of the legislative session, so the higher wages can begin next January.

“The important thing is that it gets done,” said Silver.

The Speaker said the minimum wage bill could get a vote before the budget does later in March, if the Senate is amenable.

“We should send it over today, and tomorrow the Senate should take it up,” Silver said.

But Senate Republican Leader Dean Skelos continues to express reservations about the raising the minimum wage.

He has said repeatedly that he’s concerned it would result in job losses, and be an undue hardship for struggling small businesses. Speaking at a presentation to give tax breaks to the middle class earlier this week, Skelos said raising the minimum age would likely result in many teenagers losing their part time jobs.  

“The last time there was a minimum wage increase by the legislature, 20% of the young people in the state actually lost their jobs,” Skelos said. “Many of those individuals in minority communities throughout the state.”

Senator Skelos said lawmakers should consider a lower wage for teens and farm workers. And he says the minimum wage, which is currently $7.25 an hour, was last adjusted in 2009. He says if it were to be increased solely on the basis of inflation, it would still be under $8 an hour.

And he called the escalating proposed increases a “bidding war” between Assembly Democrats, Governor Cuomo, and President Obama.

“It just seems to be ‘how high can you go?’ with them,” Skelos said.

The Senate GOP majority co-leads the Senate with five breakaway Democrats, known as the Independent Democratic Conference. The leader of the IDC faction, Senator Jeff Klein, has been a champion of raising the minimum wage.

Under the Senate’s power sharing agreement, Senator Klein must decide jointly with Senator Skelos which bills come to the floor. Senator Klein says he thinks a minimum wage hike should be part of the state budget.

“It’s not a job killer. It’s a job creator,” Klein said.

Governor Cuomo, who hopes to wrap up budget talks in order to complete the spending plan by March 21, says he is not ready yet to take anything out of the budget.

“There’s nothing in the budget and there’s nothing out of the budget,” Cuomo said. “We don’t have a budget.”

There’s been speculation that Senate Republicans might be willing to trade an agreement on raising the minimum wage in exchange for their plan to provide some middle class tax breaks, which they say would cost $2 billion. Speaker Silver panned the idea, saying the state enacted a middle class tax break last year and does not have the money for any more right now.


Julianne Welby


More in:

Comments [2]



Aug. 19 2013 06:50 AM

My issue with the proposal of such a large increase in minimum wage is that what happens to the individuals who don't get the same wage increase? I'm an 18 year old college student working part time and attending classes full time. I work in a store that is similar to Home Depot, but the products are guaranteed cheaper. I make $8.89 an hour. So I'd get bumped up $0.11 to reach the $9.00 an hour mark. While that seems fine and dandy, it doesn't change the fact that big corporations are still going to want to have the same profit margin that they already have. This has some potential to do damage to the economy. These corporations will look at this new increase in minimum wage and say "Well, we can do one of two things. We can raise the cost of our product keeping our profit the way it is." This means that the overall prices on products would increase, so now there has just been a neutral shift in the economy, and could harm families that did not receive any type of raise because now they have to pay more for products, but they still make the same amount of money as they did before the hike in minimum wage. Another way the corporations will look at it is "We can keep the price the same, but make cuts somewhere else in the company." This could be detrimental in many ways. Companies could cut any type of benefits they may have, be it medical insurance, dental plans, or retirement plans. They could cut costs for the production of goods, but this would risk having a lower quality item at the same price as the previously made higher quality item. Worst of all, they could possibly lay off individuals. With less employment they are able to keep their profit margin, but now unemployment has risen, and now these unemployed individuals do not have money to put back into the economy. Unless corporations will say "okay, we will pay the new minimum wage and not change anything else about our product" there are bound to be negative impacts on such a heavy increase in minimum wage. If one looks back in to the past, FDR started to wiggle the United States out of the Great Depression via the New Deal. A major part of the New Deal was a creation of jobs, which was funded by the government. My question is, why can't we do something similar to that now? If jobs are created and unemployment decreases, that would increase the amount of money flowing back into the economy. Although this approach may take a little bit longer, it will be a relatively permanent fix. Raising minimum wage would only be a quick temporary relief. I say vote it down, but that's just my opinion.

Apr. 10 2013 10:35 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


Latest Newscast




WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public


Supported by