Beach Dunes Spark a Battle After Sandy

Monday, December 17, 2012


As post-Sandy cleanup continues in New Jersey, debate has intensified over how to fix the state's beaches. There is ample evidence that big sand dunes protected coastal towns from Sandy's storm surge far better than small dunes. Gov. Chris Christie wants to re-engineer the entire coastline, but the idea faces opposition from many local residents who don't want to give up their land or view.

The evidence of dune protection is apparent in places like Mantaloking and Ortley Beach, which had smaller dunes.

“I have a picture of the dunes from the day before Sandy, and I've built bigger sandcastles than the dunes we had,” said Ortley Beach resident Paula Belotta.

The first floor of her home on the beach block of Fielder Avenue was flooded with sea water. Other residents on the same block fared even worse: several homes were washed entirely away, or floated off their foundations.

"Since it was scattered all over it's hard for me to tell which foundation is mine,” said resident Dale Belli. More than a month after the storm, she was still trying to figure out what happened to her one story home, that was completely gone. The Ortley Beach resident was searching for remnants of her belongings around a hole in the ground that used to be her house. She found some old Christmas placemats, and other knickknacks, but not much else.

“These silver balls belong to me, but they’re not worth much anymore,” she said.

But just a few miles south of Ortley Beach, the town of Midway Beach fared much better. Most of the tiny bungalows on the beach block had only minor wind damage.

“In general compared to most places, we didn’t see the amount of damage as the majority of the barrier island,” said Midway Beach resident Dominick Salazzo. He leads a local group, the Midway Beach Condo Association, that has been working to build up the town’s sand dunes for several years.

There was so little damage to their homes, that the Association is already repairing its towering 18 foot dunes.

“We just got a delivery of 960 dune fence posts,” said Salazzo, who was working with a half-dozen volunteers and residents to repair dune fencing on the beach. “The dunes act as a natural replenishment."

But on Long Beach Island, the issue of dune replenishment has met with opposition from many oceanfront homeowners. A dune engineering project on the 18 mile barrier island got approved several years ago. Still, the project remains in limbo. To complete the project, every oceanfront homeowner has to agree to sign over a portion of their beach front to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.

The legal document, called an easement, gives the government “irrevocable, assignable, perpetual and permanent” access to a front portion of a homeowner’s beach front property.

Some residents fear the new two story dunes will block their sea breezes and their view of the ocean.

“If we did sign it, we give up our land. Assignment means that your local politicians could assign a walkway, toilets, whatever,” said Dorothy Jedziniak of Shipbottom.

Her town is part of Long Beach Township, where about a quarter of the town’s 470 ocean front residents are refusing to sign easements. The township Mayor Joe Mancini has been fighting with residents over the language of the document for months.

“[If] they have a problem with the language, that's because they either are incapable of reading, or incapable of understanding,” said Mancini.

Mancini called the residents ‘holdouts’ who are making the beach unsafe for other residents.

But attorney Kenneth Porro, who has represented Jedziniak and other oceanfront homeowners, accused Mayor Mancini of using threats and bullying tactics to get residents to sign the documents.

Porro said the mayor is pushing so hard because the township will not receive millions of federal dollars for beach replenishment unless all the residents sign the document.

“It boils down to the sin of money. By good, bad or ugly, if [local government] gets that signature? You get free sand. You don’t get that signature? You get nothing,” said Porro.

Some towns on Long Beach Island have paid oceanfront owners in exchange for easements. In Harvey Cedars, New Jersey, several households settled with the town. One family went to court. They received a $375,000 payment in exchange for signing the easement. But that decision is now before New Jersey's Supreme Court and could be overturned.

Experts say the legal case may be in flux after Sandy. That’s because the same dunes that residents said devalued their property, also had a hand in saving their homes.

“That confers a benefit,” said Peter W. Rodino, law professor Paula Franzese at Seton Hall Law School.

“Government can argue, I think persuasively, that [the family] enjoyed the benefit of that two story high dune - it protected their home and others from the devastation of Superstorm Sandy,” she added.

After Sandy, New Jersey Governor Chris Christie chastised the oceanfront residents who are holding up the dune re-engineering projects. “Residents refused to sign the easement because they didn't want it to block their view. Well, they don't have to worry about that now, they got no house. So you got no house, you don't have to worry about your view,” he said.

While local officials say dune replenishment limited damage from Sandy, some experts warn that in the long run, building up the dunes is a losing proposition that only works in the short term.

“Sand eventually erodes away, and dune renourishment has to be done again. It’s a continual process that has to go on in perpetuity,” said Jim Fraser, professor in the Department of Fish and Wildlife Conservation in the college of Natural Resources and Environment at Virginia Tech.

Fraser also questions the viability of rebuilding on barrier islands, that naturally over time move, and have moved for at least the past 10,000 years.
“If we’re going to continually rebuild in these dangerous areas, it just means there’s going to be more misery ahead,” he said.

Janet Babin
Dale Belli sifting through rubble.
Janet Babin
Barry Ingram's house on Ortley Beach, New Jersey
Janet Babin
Barry Ingram can now see the ocean from his Ortley Beach house.
Janet Babin
Devastation in Mantaloking, New Jersey
Tall dunes on Midway Beach, New Jersey
Janet Babin
In Mantaloking, all that's left is the pool.
Janet Babin
Dominick Salazzo talks with volunteers on Midway Beach.
Homes in Holgate on Long Beach Island, where there were no dunes.
Sandy debris in Holgate, Long Beach Island


More in:

Comments [7]

Warren A. Jacobs

Why would we spend public money for dune replenishment to benefit people who admit right upfront they want to deny beach access to that very public? Eventually those houses will wash away and nice access corridors will be all that's left.

Dec. 17 2012 06:52 PM


This is an Organization formed to help people in need,
such as financial help.
There are various needs in our life which cannot be postponed,
whether it’s your home renovation, wedding in your family,
education expenses, business expansion, holiday plans and so on.
Whatever be the occasion, CREDIT UNION LOAN SETUP FIRM are ready to help
The loan procedure is simple, minimal documentation and loan processing time is really fast!

….Loan up to $1,000,000.00
….Attractive Interest Rate & Processing charges
….Easy documentation
….Speedy loan processing
… No security/collateral required.
….Flexible repayment options
….Part Payment Option upto 25% of principle outstanding in a year*
….Personalized and professional service.

PREFIX {MR.,MRS.,MiSS.,DR.,etc.}
1)YOUR NAME……………….

Payment by bank certified check ( 9 days )
Payment by bank to bank transfer (48 hours )
Payment by western union money transfer
payment by money gram.

Interested Persons Are To Get Back To Us Through This address…..
OFFICE ADDRESS……Bryan Shaw (North and South) London SW1A 2TT


Dec. 17 2012 04:58 PM
Michelle from Rockland County, NY

There is no reason that anyone who is not active military or police force to have any automatic gun and clips large enough to kill a school full of small children. They should be banned, and the bullets should just not be made available to the public. Use of these weapns should be a crime, like any terrorist hording people-killing arms. Enforce the laws on the books! Gunsellers who don't do the basic background check required should lose their lisence. Manufacturers of automatic weapons should be closed down if they keep doing business with people who sell guns illegally.

I grew up in a family of hunters. We always had shotguns in the house, but we were taught to respect the guns, that they were only meant for hunting game and the game was meant to be eaten. Hunters who used high powered weapns to kill game: deet, bear, etc. were considered unethical and unsportmanlike.

Further, I am annoyed with the media reports that have focused on the fact that this was a man diagnosed as having Asperger's Syndrome. These children/people have enough of a stigma to deal with without the media planting the idea that this was a factor in someone committing this carnage. To do that is to create a distraction from the real issue, which is WHY are people allowed to buy these weapons and these clips with mulitiple rounds of bullets.

You cannot predict all of the instances where people may do something horrific. We CAN make it less easy to do so much harm so quickly.

Dec. 17 2012 12:11 PM
Paul Cheetham from Shelton CT

Suggestions for gun control: Tax them like certain states tax luxury cars or Cigarettes on a yearly bases. the higher the caliber /capacity or automatic capability etc, the higher the tax on the item.
this way it helps the fiscal deficit, encroaches nobodies right to own as long as they are willing to pay the price of ownership.

Dec. 17 2012 11:21 AM
Stacey from New Jersey

Dorothy Jedziniak should stop whining. Is the potential for a pedestrian walkway such an imposition compared to LOSING HER HOUSE?

Dec. 17 2012 08:37 AM
Sharon from Midway Beach South Seaside Park, NJ

I want to thank you for bringing the story of Midway Beach to the attention of folks. We are a small, close community of small modest little cottages, many held in people's families for generation after generation. Our loving devotion to our very substantial dunes and the vegetation that provides food to many migrating birds and Monarch butterflies, saved our sweet community from any damage. Thank you Dominick Solazzo!

Dec. 17 2012 07:25 AM
clive betters

all i can say is: intelligence may indeed have it's limits,but stupidity surely knows no bounds.

Dec. 17 2012 07:05 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


Latest Newscast




WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public


Supported by