Opinion: After Loose Airplane Seats and Salmonella, Why isn't Deregulation a 2012 Issue?

Tuesday, October 09, 2012 - 09:22 AM

Of the many different issues both presidential candidates are trying to emphasize, a big one is the matter of 'deregulation.' The Democrats want to regulate banks and other businesses in order to "protect consumers" and the Republicans who want to deregulate and “get government off the backs of business.”

Ask the American Airlines passengers whose row of seats came loose and fell backwards last week if they think government regulation of airline safety should be reduced. Ask the people who became ill with salmonella when they ate contaminated peanut butter if government regulation and inspection of food plants should be reduced. A total of 240 different products are now subject to the peanut butter recall.

What about the folks all over the United States who received spinal steroid injections to relieve pain and are now holding their breath to see if they develop symptoms of meningitis. You’ve seen the stories about injections made at New England Compounding Center of Framingham, MA a pharmacy that “compounds” medication and sells them all over the country.

These outfits fall between the state and federal regulatory cracks and so no one regulates them. Apparently the compounders are supposed to meet some sort of minimal standards. Wow really? No extremely diligent regulations for injections designed to go into your spinal cord!? If I want to start a salon and cut and style hair I need to be certified and I get inspected. If I want to sell tacos I need a load of permits and I get inspected. But if I want to cook up some meds to shoot into your spine, not so much!

It is hard to believe that Americans will actually vote for candidates at any level who want to let companies big or small set their own rules and not take into account the rights and interests of consumers.

It’s daunting and depressing not to see more storytelling in this election campaign of the tragedies of not having robust and sufficient regulation of services and products. It’s distressing that the Republicans have staked out a position on the ”absolute deregulation” end of the political spectrum. I don’t understand. Don’t Republicans get spinal injections? Don’t their kids eat peanut butter?

The “deregulation regime” approach relies on lawsuits to punish perpetrators rather than proactive prevention. Have you ever tried to sue your credit card company, bank, dry cleaner, or boat shipping company? It is a daunting, expensive, time consuming and extremely difficult way of correcting dangerous or deadly mistakes made by companies.

After his poor performance, if I were Barack Obama I’d talk meningitis at the next presidential debate.“Mr. Romney, what’s your position on the need for regulation by the federal government of pharmacies that compound pharmaceuticals injected into the spine by doctors, clinics, and hospitals all over the US which have the fungus Aspergillus that has killed patients?”

BOOM! Debate won. Deregulation and politics 2012. It’s not such a complicated problem at all is it?


More in:

Comments [2]

John from Bklyn

20+ years of listening to The Fat Pig's talk radio show and his ilk has rotted the brains of most Americans. They see everything in black and white. They think everything exists in a vacuum. Good luck trying to use reason with these slugs. Sorry! I didn't mean to insult slugs.

Oct. 09 2012 12:03 PM

Some believe it is daunting, depressing and distressing to have a 20 trillion dollar debt in a few years which all but certifies the decline of the United States in the 21st Century.
What kind of regulations will this nation have when that economic collapse happens?

Try talking meningitis to a Obamacare bureaucrat at a hospital run like the DMV and try suing the Federal government if their service doesn't satisfy.

Oct. 09 2012 09:53 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


About It's A Free Blog

Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of a blog, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.

Supported by

WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public.  Learn more at



Supported by