Romney or Obama? The Stock Market Might Have the Answer

Friday, August 03, 2012 - 12:00 AM

A trader reacts to the market downfall on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange at the closing bell August10, 2011. A trader reacts to the market on the floor of the Stock Exchange. (STAN HONDA/AFP/Getty)

There’s a lot of hand wringing going on over the stability of financial markets after a wild morning of trading this week. 

By all accounts, a computer glitch in the trading program at Knight Capital caused the firm to buy and sell millions of shares of stocks of nearly 150 companies. 

In the end, the New Jersey based company said the malfunction will cost it $440 million.  That’s stoking worries it might file bankruptcy.

What can’t be measured as easily is how yet another stock trading problem — Facebook’s stock offering, the “flash crash” — will change investor confidence in the markets.

While data from the Investment Company Institute shows people have been pulling money from stock mutual funds every month since April of last year, it’s more likely because they’re worried about the dismal state of the economy than traders (albeit the electronic kind) gone wild.

It’s the drop in confidence in the economy that will likely be the real driver for where the market goes in the months before the presidential election.

And which direction the market goes might just tell us who’s going to win.

Sam Stovall, the chief equity strategist at S&P Capital IQ, and his team crunched the numbers, going back to 1900, and found that 80 percent of the time when the S&P 500 rises from July 31 to October 31 in an election year, the incumbent is re-elected. If the index falls during those three months, 88 percent of the time, the incumbent loses.

So, what will move the markets in either direction before November 6? 

A positive move might be further stimulus by the Federal Reserve in September after it decided to stay the course this week.

But even if that happens, if unemployment fails to drop significantly before the election, they’ll be a lot of pressure pushing stocks down.

And let’s not forget that what happens in Europe doesn’t stay in Europe.  Not good for stocks

And back home, Congress's inability to agree on budget matters is taking the country straight for that fiscal cliff of automatic tax hikes and spending cuts.  Definitely not good either.

So while past performance is not a guide to future returns, the case is strong — so far — that stock performance can tell us who’ll be in the Oval Office next year.


More in:

Comments [2]

I agree. There's definitely a worry that the market is "rigged" against non-professional investors and that regulators can't keep up. But people could be pulling money out for many reasons in addition to a lack of confidence in the markets: to pay bills, to readjust their portfolios (corresponding increase in investments for bond funds), to put money in savings accounts (increase in the savings rate). And if Bill Gross is right, the belief in buying and holding stocks is dead.

Aug. 03 2012 09:20 AM

Completely disagree with your statement: "it’s more likely because they’re worried about the dismal state of the economy than traders (albeit the electronic kind) gone wild."

I don't know about anyone else but for me, the fear belongs to not trusting the marketmakers, the banks, brokers and institutional traders who manipulate the markets. 3 days of runups and a huge slam down for another week= a loss, we are all suckers to the big boys and I for one and done with it until regulations are written, because what is being done is manipulation, not letting the market run on its own.

Aug. 03 2012 07:35 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.



Supported by