After 5-Year Wait, Ballfields Near Yankee Stadium Finally Set to Open

Friday, April 06, 2012


The gates were locked on Friday at MaCombs Dam Field alongside the new Yankee Stadium. That's despite reports the field had opened this week, a year behind schedule and five years after a set of neighborhood baseball diamonds were paved over to make way for a stadium parking lot.

The field, which was also known as Heritage Field and is actually a set of three fields, saw its first action on Monday with a game between Cardinal Hayes and All Hallows high school varsity baseball teams. But the long-suffering residents of the south Bronx neighborhood will have to wait until Saturday to get their first access to the10.8 acres of Kentucky bluegrass, installed where the old Yankee Stadium once stood.

Resident Carlos Juarez stood by a fence surrounding the fields and gave a kind of capsule summary of the difficult history behind the paving of parkland to build the new stadium and the slow replacement of those parks in new locations.

"In the beginning, people refused to support this construction," he said. "They took down the old Yankee Stadium and people were like, 'What are they going to do?' But when they saw the result, they just loved it."

Similarly, Parks Commissioner Adrian Benepe stressed the end result rather than the lengthy and sometimes rancorous process that delivered it.

"Frankly, I think a lot of the rancor was not from the neighborhood but rather from a self-styled park advocate who had it in his head that this was a terrible thing," he told WNYC. "But when you talk to people in the neighborhood about the old MaCombs Dam Park, they knew they were not particularly great. The old MaCombs Dam ballfield was sort of in a pit surrounded by elevated roadways."

The new MaCombs Dam Field will be open from 10 a.m. to dusk and will give priority to teams with permits from the city. But when those teams aren't playing, the public will be free to step on turf where Babe Ruth and Joe DiMaggio once plied their trade. Blue polymer fiber stitched into the sod marks where home plate once stood. Anyone can straddle it and, in their minds eye, knock a long ball out of the park.


More in:

Comments [4]

Harriet from Highbridge

It would have been helpful if WNYC was going to bother to do a "report" on this important issue they would have at least put in a tiny effort to not only fact check but pretend to do a little research and provide background.

Let's start with the headline: " After 5-Year Wait, Ballfields Near Yankee Stadium Finally Set to Open"
The removal of the five fields seized to build the new Yankee Stadium began in August 2006 - do the math - hint it's not five years.

"In the beginning, people refused to support this construction," he said. "They took down the old Yankee Stadium and people were like, 'What are they going to do?' But when they saw the result, they just loved it."

Your reliance on the one supposed "man on the street" interview meant to represent the feelings of our community was not only an incredible disservice to your listers/readers but to the people of the Bronx. (Not to mention the city's tax payers as a whole) WNYC has access to people and sources who have been following this issue closely over the years including people in the community but apparently you couldn't be bothered. You took the same embarrassing approach the NY Times did - except, I hope for your sake, you didn't purposely ignore critics.

Apparently it is not enough that Mr. Benepe is regularly allowed use Brian Lehrer at will for his relentless spin and misrepresentations without his "answers" being challenged in informative follow up questions. Now the supposed, "news" division is playing along. How can anyone forget Benepe's outright lies he told on the Yankee replacement parks on Lehrer's show in April 2010. People are tired of the lies - and in this media outlet allowing them!

If your readers want a well researched account of these issues from unbiased sources, here it is.

My heart goes out to the person who commented that he had to move his family out of the community because of this project - the air quality etc. I googled his name and saw that he was a person who was extremely involved in the community, including informing people about the Yankee project. What a shame.

City officials like Benepe continue to insult our community and you publish it without a problem Shame on you.

We will feel the numerous impacts of his project for the rest of our lives. This administration can pretend all they like that everything is whole but unfortunately the facts do not support this.

Your reporting is what it is - sloppy, lazy "journalism," but you should realize this impacts people. This administration may not care but we certainly do.

Apr. 10 2012 01:22 PM
Bettina Damiani, Good Jobs New York

It’s disingenuous for Parks Commissioner Benepe to whitewash the Yankee Stadium project as something to be proud of when in fact it cost hundreds of millions of public dollars, was void of any meaningful democratic decision making processes and replaced natural parkland with Astroturf and parking garages.

There WAS broad debate despite a desperate attempt to drown the voices of residents; the Yankees were given use of the park land after an emergency vote in a dead-of-night legislative session. (The Mets, which also benefit greatly from subsidies, opted to build its new stadium in existing parking facilities, not nearby parks.) Was the Commissioner not in attendance at the numerous hearings and meetings where Bronxites passionately defended the parks, urging for upgrading, not razing them? It’s bitterly ironic that Park officials prioritized – and continue to defend – the use of excessive public funds for a project that destroyed parks simply because the Yankees asked them to.

Apr. 10 2012 01:01 PM
Lukas Herbert from Yonkers

I served on Community Board 4 at the time of the Yankee Statdium review...and I can tell you that it was bona fide community opposition. I don't know what Adrian Benepe is talking about. He is probably trying to re-write the history of the project, because the whole thing was such an embarrassment to his agency at the time it was happening.

For anyone who thinks this park is so much better than the old is a fact for you. As soon as my wife found out she was pregnant, we moved to Yonkers. Why? So many of the kids in the community have ashtma, and we didn't want to condemn our son to the same fate. When that stadium was constructed, over 300 mature trees were chopped down. How will the air quality improve under those circumstances? Even though the park is new, don't tell me that air quality improves when you chop down huge trees to build parking garages with artificial turf on top. Despite all the bells and whistles of the new parks, I'd take the old parks over the new in a second for the sake of those trees and the air quality benefits they provided. They never would have done a project like this in Central Park.

Apr. 09 2012 10:09 AM
James Jospeh from Morrisania

Adrian Benepe has obviously forgotten that Community Board 4 rejected the stadium plan in a two-to-one vote. That had nothing to do with a "self-styled park advocate" -- whoever that is -- but rather with a neighborhood that wanted to keep a natural park with 377 mature trees. Macombs Dam Park was in bad shape, but it was in the middle of the community. It was not surrounded by elevated roadways but by apartment buildings. (I don't know where he gets that description from -- it's as if he didn't remember the park at all. I live across Jerome Avenue.) Now a stadium sits in the middle of my neighborhood, and our new parks are treeless lots next to the Deegan Expressway. Half of them are on top of a parking garage two stories off the ground. The tennis courts moved a mile away on the other side of the Deegan and now charge fees of up to $80 an hour -- in the South Bronx!!! The city didn't even bother to replace a three-acre lot at 161st and Macombs Dam Bridge -- they just put up a five-story parking garage on it. Two of the "replacement" ballfields are not even in the neighborhood -- one is in a different community board. We knew this plan had nothing to do with us and everything to do with the Yankees. News reports have documented the failure of the massive parking garages dumped in my neighborhood and the harm the stadium has caused to the small businesses on 161st Street. Well, I guess all of that is fine now that it's over -- we'll just take city officials at their word and let them rewrite history. Thanks a lot, Benepe.

Apr. 08 2012 07:52 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


Latest Newscast




WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public


Supported by