Streams

Senate R’s pining for an Orthodox Jewish district, but at what cost?

Tuesday, February 21, 2012 - 04:48 PM

[Note: There were a number of errors in an earlier version of this article, including the misspelling of Congressman Bob Turner's name. They've been corrected and I apologize.]

In a month, voters in the 27th State Senate District in southern Brooklyn will go to the polls for a special election to replace former senator Carl Kruger.

This race has generated a considerable amount of interest in what would normally be a sleepy off-season political event. But Senate Republicans are making a strong run for the seat, buoyed by the strong showing in the Brooklyn side of Congressman Bob Turner’s district, which he won in a special election last fall. That Brooklyn slice just happens to represent about half of Senate District 27.

They’ve settled on David Storobin, a trial attorney and vice-president of the Republican Party in Brooklyn, emigrated from Russia two decades ago. He’s reflective in many ways of the young, Russian Jewish population Republicans are hoping to mobilize on Election Day.

On the Democratic side, the man who had long been seen as Kruger’s likely successor, City Councilman Lew Fidler, was chosen to keep the seat in the “D” column. Early on the Fidler campaign stirred up controversy by suggesting Storobin had ties to neo-Nazi and white supremacist groups. He later backed off that line of attack,saying he never called his opponent a neo-Nazi, while Storobin’s campaign has used it as a rallying cry. At least some in the Orthodox Jewish community appear to be listening.

Behind the rushed campaigning of this special election has been the impending redistricting process. No matter who wins the special election next month, they’ll be running again later this year in a district that will likely look very different than the one they win in.

Senate Republicans have made it clear they want to carve out a conservative Orthodox Jewish district, one they believe a Republican can win and hold.

How the current district is cut up in the proposed lines. (RUNYweb/PolitickerNY)

The first draft of the senate maps appear to divide the current district up into four parts of four other districts—and neither candidate is currently living inside the proposed lines.

Regardless, a Storobin win would likely see the candidate either living in or moving into a district that was specifically carved out in the hopes of attracting conservative Jewish candidates that Senate Republicans hope will win on their party line.

But carving out two districts that are perceived to be Republican-friendly carries some risk. Even with an additional seat upstate, each district has to grow and Brooklyn is by and large a Democratic-friendly borough.

The Democratic-favored proposed Orthodox district. (CUNY Center for Urban Research and New York World)

To wit, according to the analysis done by the CUNY Center for Urban Research and the New York World: Were Republican State Senator Marty Golden to run in his proposed district and receive what was cast in 2010 by the voters within those proposed lines, he would have received 1,225 less votes. When it comes to the Orthodox Jewish district, a theoretical Democratic candidate did better than three-to-one than a Republican in the CUNY/New York World analysis.

Indeed, the two new supposedly Republican-friendly districts would appear to divide the area that sits in what is now the 9th Congressional District which vaulted Bob Turner over his Democratic opponent last year. It remains to be seen if the divide-and-conquer strategy will actually help Senate Republicans. Who ends up winning the election next month might be a big step for either party hoping to win the new seat later this year.

Tags:

More in:

The Morning Brief

Enter your email address and we’ll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.

Comments [10]

The Empire Blog

I see that my replies via the back end of the site aren't coming up so:

The misspelling of Congressman Turner's name was a mistaken. It's been corrected and I apologize for that.

The district in red is Golden's district, but the 17th is above that in a blue highlighted boundary. The maps are colored that way and I have no control over it. The pop-out box shows the statistics for the 17th. If you click through to make the map a bit bigger I think it becomes a bit more clear.

Feb. 22 2012 07:18 PM
The Empire Blog

I don't know if you'll believe this, but I was looking at the lines and reading about the upcoming State Senate battles in Westchester and transposed the names. But, yeah it would appear that way, wouldn't it?

Feb. 22 2012 07:17 PM
The Empire Blog

 I went ahead and dug into the issues you brought up:

http://empire.wnyc.org/2012/02/new-orthodox-jewish-state-senate-district-revisited/

Feb. 22 2012 07:15 PM
Colby Hamilton

The misspelling of Congressman Turner's name was a mistaken. It's been corrected and I apologize for that.

The district in red is Golden's district, but the 17th is above that in a blue highlighted boundary. The maps are colored that way and I have no control over it. The pop-out box shows the statistics for the 17th. If you click through to make the map a bit bigger I think it becomes a bit more clear.

Feb. 22 2012 05:11 PM
Colby Hamilton

I will say this: It's good to know you guys are pay attention.

Feb. 22 2012 02:36 PM
Ridiculous

1. who the hell is Bob Cohen and when did he become a Congressman?
and
2. The district you're showing as the supposed "proposed Orthodox district" is actually the proposed Marty Golden district.  You have the right number, but the wrong map.  You folks ok over there?

Feb. 22 2012 01:35 PM
VJ Machiavelli

Go David GO

Win the special and shake up the Democ"RATS" at their core.

Before there was the "Oracle of Delphi" there was Count Vampire J. Machiavelli

VJ Machiavelli
Power to the People who "VOTE"

Feb. 22 2012 05:30 AM
mugwump

What this article neglects to mention is that most of the D senators in that area were unopposed in 2010, and this simulator doesn't correct for that since it uses raw vote totals. So what you're saying is that Democrats will win SD-17 if no Republican runs. In reality the number of R votes in the Orthodox seat (and in Golden's as well) is likely to be far higher.

Feb. 22 2012 03:15 AM
Refni

"Bob Cohen", "Citycouncilman"... Hey, Empire, need an editorial assistant?

Feb. 22 2012 02:33 AM
Ned Berke

Bob Cohen? Did you just Jewify Bob Turner?

Feb. 21 2012 11:40 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Sponsored

"The Capitol Pressroom" with Susan Arbetter at 11 am

For show archives, please visit The Capitol Bureau's website here.

About The Empire

Everything you need to know about New York politics and governance. We aim for a ground-up approach to politics, reverse engineered to make the effect just as important as the players and the game they play. From the Long Island to The Thousand Islands, New York City Hall to the Capitol Building, The Empire's got you covered.

Check out WNYC's 2013 Mayor Tracker--the one-stop shop for info about the candidates, issues and trends in the upcoming New York City mayoral election.

 

Our Reporters

Feeds

Supported by