Photo credit: @julesdwit.
A not-for-profit media organization supported by people like you.
Ever feel like you missed the beginning of an important news story? Leonard will catch you up during Backstory.
Journalist Quinn Norton, contributor to Wired magazine's Threat Level blog, returns to give us an update on what the Internet collective Anonymous has been up to recently.
" . . . I’m going to repeat in every thread about this that the fraud is not that [Peter Gleick] got documents under false pretenses. That’s investigative reporting and resourcefulness. HURRAH HURRAH HOO-RAH.
The fraud is that he took a document of unknown provenance (that he now says he got anonymously in the mail) and mixed it with documents of known provenance (the Heartland documents he used his fake identity to get) and then presented the resulting document collage to the press. . . ."
" , , , it’s cut and dried Piltdown Man style fraud.
And furthermore many of us think Gleick faked the strategy memo his own self and “Anonymous” was his Lucy Ramirez."http://www.lesjones.com/2012/03/02/an-analogy-of-what-peter-gleick-did-in-fakegate/
RE: gene's "heartland-insider-exposes-institute-s-budget-and-strategy" link
From Wikipedia on "Peter Gleick":On February 16, 2012 Gleick resigned from the American Geophysical Union Task Force on Scientific Ethics citing “personal, private reasons”. On February 20 he confessed he had obtained and distributed documents from the Heartland Institute under a false name, and apologized. On February 24 he asked the board of the Pacific Institute to grant him a "temporary short-term leave of absence" from the Institute.
From http://dotearth.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/02/20/peter-gleick-admits-to-deception-in-obtaining-heartland-climate-files/#:" . . . Gleick has admitted to an act that leaves his reputation in ruins and threatens to undercut the cause he spent so much time pursuing. . . ."
Perhaps the admitted fraudulent nature of the "source" of the alleged Heartland documents explains why neither Mr. Lehrer or his guest wanted to get "on top of the story". Admittedly, various ways to"photoshop" reality (what is that?) are praised as "truth enhancing" or condemned as "duplicitous" (http://www.onthemedia.org/blogs/on-the-media/2012/feb/06/bobs-new-guardian-column/)In each and every case, you, the reader, must be the judge for yourself and the guardian of your own integrity.
This Quinn Norton wrote a 3-part article on the history of Anonymous and it's the most accurate history/account I've seen anyone write; very recommended.
Also, I hope none of you are using your real names in any way on here: that's not safe internet practice.
What I find troublesome is Ms Norton's cagey demeanor regarding Anonymous. While I certainly support a journalist's obligation to protect its sources, Ms. Norton's lack of transparency about so many aspects of this story is infuriating. regardless of whether she is afraid to upset Anonymous and therefore plays into their hands or, in fact, supports the Anonymous' mission, this crosses a journalistic line and consequently, Ms. Norton cannot be trusted.
Actually, if they are criminals and this giggling "lady" is a supporter, shouldn't she be invited by someone else ... somewhere else?The last time I checked, criminality was still illegal and criminals are still supposed to be punished.
I can't help but think that there will be a major overreach at some time on the part of Anonymous. 1/ Does the FBI have much of a staff by now to police against a terrorist act on the Internet? 2/ Doesn't Ms Quinn see a likelihood of 'the next Timothy McVey' coming from Anonymous?
The so called "content industry" lobbying isn't about protecting intellectual property, it is about old media's effort to control new media through legislation. The piracy language is an excuse for an attempt to subvert the Internet on the most fundamental level.
I still see a fair amount of antisociality in Anonymous, sometimes incredible amounts. Is the Anonymous community starting to break into "white hat" and "black hat" subcategories?
I'm shocked neither you nor Lehrer have gotten on top of the story of the Heartland Institute's anonymously leaked documents on funding and strategy in global warming and secondhand smoke science.
Email addresses are required but never displayed.
Leonard Lopate hosts the conversation New Yorkers turn to each afternoon for insight into contemporary art, theater, and literature, plus expert tips about the ever-important lunchtime topic: food.
Sign up for the Book Club e-newsletter
Subscribe on iTunes
Leonard Lopate Weekend: Melissa Clark on Alternative Thanksgiving, Jazz singer Sheila Jordan, Growing Up in the Bronx
WNYC 93.9 FM and AM 820 are New York's flagship public radio
stations, broadcasting the finest programs from NPR and PRI, as well as a wide range of award-winning local
programming. WNYC is a division of
New York Public Radio.