Gillibrand: Keystone Pipeline 'Poison Pill' for Payroll Tax Cut

Monday, December 12, 2011

Recap from It's a Free Country.

Welcome to Politics Bites, where every afternoon at It's A Free Country, we bring you the unmissable quotes from the morning's political conversations on WNYC. Today on the Brian Lehrer Show, New York Senator (D) Kirsten Gillibrand rounded up news from Washington as the legislative session wraps up, from the payroll tax cuts to unemployment benefits and more.

Insider trading in Congress?

Among the bills that Kirsten Gillibrand is working on before year's end is a bipartisan one that would make it illegal for members of Congress to trade on privileged information that private citizens can't. That there are no laws explicitly banning the practice for congressional officers may be surprising; that there should be such a law, Gillibrand says, is a no-brainer.

If you have access to non-public information because of your job, you should not be able to go home and buy yourself stocks and benefit from that.

Chances for Obama's payroll tax cut

Of course, the biggest thing on Gillibrand's plate is the payroll tax cut extension sought by President Obama. Republicans in Congress have repeatedly opposed the measure because Democrats would pay for the extension by raising taxes on the wealthiest Americans. The GOP's latest move has been to attach a provision to an extension bill that would force President Obama to make a decision about extending the Keystone oil pipeline from Canada into the U.S. Obama has delayed a decision about the pipeline until 2013, but such a provision could force his hand earlier—and during an election year, no less.

Gillibrand, citing environmental concerns, is less than thrilled about the GOP's bringing Keystone into the negotiations.

I think it's a terrible idea. I'm very concerned about it...It's a poison pill; I think [Republicans] are trying to introduce it as a reason for it to fail.We shouldn't be trying to score political points here. We have to get this [extension] done, because we just can't allow taxes to increase by an average of $1,000 for 160 million hard-working Americans.

An unlikely pay-for?

Gillibrand said that there were many possible "pay-fors" that Democrats and Republicans could look for in the coming weeks and agree on as they try and offset the cost of extending the payroll tax cut. Perhaps there's a way to do it that doesn't lean too heavily on tax increases or spending cuts.

One source might be another bill that the Senator is working on, which would improve law enforcement first-responder communication systems.

We want to relegate 10 Mhz in our communications network just for first responders. We'll auction off all the available spectrum and consolidate 10 Mhz. We would would raise tens of billions of dollars, and that money would be spent to build the communications infrastructure.

Gillibrand said that even after spending on new systems, there would be $6 billion left over just to go to deficit reduction. That's just a fraction of the over $100 billion needed to pay for the payroll tax cut extension, but this is the kind of "pay-for" members of Congress should be eyeing.


Senator Kirsten Gillibrand

Comments [11]

Sophia from Broad Channel, Queens

Thanks Sheldon from Brooklyn; you are correct. We are getting results without any assistance from Sen Gillibrand or our other rep, Uncle Chuck -- our state senator Shirley Huntley, Audrey Pfeffer and Helen Marshal have been immensely helpful. Interestingly, Mr. Schumer too did not dignify my visits, calls or emails regarding our neighborhood issues with a response -- rather, one of his staff told me that our issue was not national enough. Sen. Gilli, responded not at all -- your insights about her being under Uncle Chuck's tutelage seems accurate.

Dec. 12 2011 07:04 PM
Mike from Inwood

Tax cuts have to be paid for? I thought the Republican mantra was that tax cuts paid for themselves because the stimulate the economy...

Dec. 12 2011 11:16 AM
Mike from Inwood

I am a life long Democrat and strongly support both President Obama and Social Security. Won't this payroll tax holiday mean that the Republican ideologues, who are against Social Security in principle, will be able to attack Social Security funding more directly than they have in the past?

Dec. 12 2011 11:16 AM
Sheldon from Brooklyn

Well Sophia - Uncle Chuck made sure that she ran unopposed, her whole senatorial life.

To be fair - for issues on your block, a federal Senator should not be your first choice. Maybe you should perhaps try your: Council person, Borough Pres, Mayor, state rep, state senator, 311?

Dec. 12 2011 11:16 AM
Tom P from Fanwood, NJ

Banning insider trading is a nice start. How about our representatives having their own rich healthcare plan, seperate Social Security benefits and being exempt from most mandates that employers are subject to, such as OSHA and EEOC rules? When will that stop?

Dec. 12 2011 11:14 AM
Fishmael from NYC

Please ask Sen. Gillibrand to give her position on hydrofracking in NY State, particularly in the NYC watershed

Dec. 12 2011 11:12 AM
Fishmael from NYC

This is fine, but, there also needs to be an independent investigation into the practice to see what members may have used this unethical practice.

Dec. 12 2011 11:10 AM
Asaf Soof from Union Sq

Please ask your guest ! What about commuter (Transit Checks) benefits? Are we really going back to $125 from $230 per month benefit?

Dec. 12 2011 11:09 AM
Sophia from Broad Channel Queens

Senator Gillibrand appears to have adopted the political class elitism. I have contacted her on more than one occassion regarding issues on my block, but she never responded in any way shape or form. She is supposed to be my rep, but I don't know if she got that memo.

Broad Channel

Dec. 12 2011 11:06 AM

will congress ever pass a budget again?
i understand it's been 3 years

Dec. 12 2011 09:44 AM
herb from nyc

please discuss the loss of women's rights as a result of the arab spring. the arab spring that president Obama supports.

Dec. 12 2011 09:02 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.