Cops May Be Behind Some Racist Facebook Comments, NYPD Says

Wednesday, December 07, 2011

Marchers in the 2011 West Indian-American Day carnival parade. Marchers in the 2011 West Indian-American Day carnival parade. (Mansoor Khan/WNYC)

At least 20 offensive comments on Facebook that called West Indian Day parade-goers “savages” and “animals,” may have been made by NYPD officers, the police commissioner said Wednesday.

“It is disturbing when anyone denigrates a community with hateful speech,” Police Commissioner Ray Kelly said on Wednesday in a statement. “It is unacceptable when police officers do it.”

Kelly said the NYPD’s Internal Affairs Bureau began interviewing the identified officers and subpoenaing computer records.  

The results of the IAB investigation will be submitted to the Department Advocate for possible administrative charges.

Those could include charges of “conduct unbecoming of an officer.” While this is a broad charge, it can be used as a sanction against officers who make offensive or racist comments, Paul Browne, spokesman for the NYPD, told WNYC.

Browne could not confirm if the department had an official social media policy, but did say officers were prohibited from externally sharing “any information they pick-up while on active duty.”

At a press conference on Wednesday, Mayor Michael Bloomberg said the situation was “concerning,” but emphasized it was necessary to let the police department conduct its investigation.

“If it’s true, it’s totally inappropriate,” Bloomberg said. “And I could use lots of other words to describe it.”

The “No More West Indian Day Detail” Facebook page, which had more than 1,000 followers, was discovered by Benjamin Moore and Paul Lieberman, lawyers for the Brooklyn Defender Services, who represented a man arrested for gun possession near the Brooklyn parade route in 2010.

The page was taken offline shortly after the discovery, but the lawyers saved the data from the page.

Moore and Lieberman said their client, Tyrone Johnson, was acquitted last month in part because, they argued, the arresting officer, who was a member of the Facebook page, might have been biased. (That officer did not make any comments.)

Many commenters, identifying themselves as cops who worked on the West Indian Day Parade, complained about being put in harm’s way and called on Bloomberg to shut it down. One commenter called the parade a “ghetto training” for officers.

Several commenters said they were instructed not to arrest people for smoking marijuana or drinking – something they said only applied to this parade.

Councilman Jumaane Williams, at a press conference on City Hall steps Wednesday, said it wasn’t enough that the IAB was looking into the incident and that it points to a larger problem about the NYPD’s treatment of minority communities.

“We need an acknowledgment of a problem,” Williams said. “We need an acknowledgment of a systemic issue within the NYPD.”

He and other Council members said they would like to see an external body provide oversight for the NYPD rather than the IAB. That agency, they suggested, should be under the Department of Investigations and get more funding than the IAB does currently.

Bob Hennelly, Kathleen Horan, Mirela Iverac and Claudia Morell contributed to this report.


More in:

Comments [7]


This is the real NYPD RANT site.....

Dec. 09 2011 09:54 AM

joeydee, the first amendment means the government can't persecute you for free speech. It doesn't guarantee your continued employment.

Dec. 08 2011 12:22 PM
joeyDEE from staten italy

1st amendment rights baby! dont like it? leave the country!
cops have the same protection as everyone else as long as its during off duty time....and non threatening!
1st amendment example...ray kelly is an irish donkey!!!!!!! ya see that wa easy!\
ray keely trying to be god now!!!! you are a moron!

Dec. 08 2011 09:30 AM
juan pena

Hey, wasn't that the same parade where some cops were being criticized for dancing with some of the paraders?

Dec. 07 2011 08:22 PM
SKV from NYC

The entire text of the Facebook page was captured and should be made public, along with the names associated with each comment. This was posted on a public forum, and the public should get to see what our law enforcement said about us. And an independent civilian review board should decide what should be done with the officers who posted.

Dec. 07 2011 08:07 PM
clive betters

so not surprizing: after all, these are the working class, white racist best,from the "islands" .... staten and long.........

Dec. 07 2011 07:51 PM
earl from Brooklyn

So... Is the problem here the officers or the parade-goers? Slurs are never okay, but is there an actual, systemic problem with the parade-- which has a history of violence-- that the patrolmen are looking to address?

Also, should officers be prevented from commenting on their experiences in any public forum? Or is it just that FB attaches names to them so that's not okay?

I'm no specific fan of the NYPD, but I think most people's complaint about them is they're too insular and close-ranked. If they get hit with "conduct unbecoming" everytime they speak out, of course they're gonna be insular.

Dec. 07 2011 07:06 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


Latest Newscast




WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public


Supported by