Protesters Stay Awake All Night at Zuccotti Park

Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Protesters chanting in Zuccotti Park after being allowed back in. (Stephen Nessen/WNYC)

About a dozen activists stayed awake all night at Zuccotti Park where a handful of skirmishes erupted between police and protesters who were evicted in a nighttime sweep Tuesday tried to figure out what to do next.

Protester Leina Bocar, an unemployed artist, managed to smuggle a sleeping bag into Zuccotti Park Tuesday night but it was later confiscated.

"It's a pain," she said. "It's cold. We don't have tents right now. People are sleeping in McDonald's. I had an umbrella, I had a sleeping bag with a heating blanket. It's a pain, but I'm here for a reason, you know?"

Mayor Michael Bloomberg said the park will remain open "to all who want to enjoy it, as long as they abide by the park's rules."

New barricades have been set up around Zuccotti Park, with green-vested, private security guards checking the belongings of anyone entering and waking up people who fall asleep. 

Park owners, Brookfield Properties, said the guards are there to enforce the existing rules of the park, such as no lying down on sitting areas or walkways and no storage of personal property. On Wednesday, guards turned banned a folding chair, shopping cart, blankets and sleeping bags from the park. Some of the items were confiscated, if the owners would not relinquish them.

Brookfield Properties would not disclose the name of the security firm or ho long they expect the guards to be stationed at Zuccotti Park.

Uncertain Future for Occupy Wall Street

The first General Assembly meeting since the eviction Tuesday was well attended, with loud applause coming when the meeting leader said they had a lot to be proud of. The meeting went over how people could recover their things, reviewed Brookfield Properties rules and tried to figure out how to move forward.

"People are really recognizing that we need to build a movement here," Hans Shan said. Shan is an organizer who has been trying to find places for protesters to sleep. "What we're dedicated to is not just about occupying space. That's a tactic."

But without a place to congregate, protesters will have a harder time communicating with each other en masse. The leaders of the movement spent most of Tuesday gathering in small groups throughout the city — in church basements, in public plazas and on street corners — and relaying plans in scattered text messages and email.

Some protesters said the last 24 hours had been heartbreaking, but they remained committed. Occupy Wall Street released a statement after the meeting stating, “We will overcome the obstacles placed before us. We will not be deterred. We will persevere. Our message is resonating across America, and our cause is shared by millions around the world. We are the 99%, and we want to live in a world that is for all of us — not just for those who have amassed great wealth and power. You cannot evict an idea whose time has come.”

Aside from the lack of tents, there were other noticeable changes, such as the lack of fixed garbage cans. Instead, Brookfield Properties had staff wearing yellow vests sweeping up and carting around garbage cans. There were also more lights around the park.

(Photo right: New signs were put up throughout Zuccotti Park, greeting protesters who returned Tuesday night./Courtesy of Andrew Adler)

Clean-up Without Warning

In the early hours of Tuesday morning, NYPD entered Zuccotti Park and told protesters that they would have to vacate the park so it could be cleaned — and that they could not bring with them sleeping bags, tarps or tents when they returned.

Protesters who wish to collect any of their belongings collected during the clean-up, may do so Wednesday through Friday at a Department of Sanitation garage on West 56th Street between 11th and 12th avenues. They will need photo I.D., fill out a claim form and provide proof of ownership.

The New York raid was the third in three days for a major American city. Police broke up camps Sunday in Portland, Ore., and Monday in Oakland, Calif.

The timing did not appear to be coincidence. On Tuesday, authorities acknowledged that police departments across the nation consulted with each other about nonviolent ways to clear encampments. Officers in as many as 40 cities participated in the conference calls.

The city waited until Supreme Court Justice Michael Stallman on Tuesday denied a motion by the demonstrators seeking to be allowed back into the park with their tents and sleeping bags to let demonstrators back into the park. 

Protesters were slowly allowed back into Zuccotti Park through a small space in the barricades. NYPD used bullhorns to announce that no tents or large backpacks would be allowed in, and there was a large police presence trying to maintain order, as a crush of people waited for their turn to re-enter the park.

Bloomberg — who said conditions within the park had become "intolerable" — said he intended to allow protesters back into the park after it had been cleaned.

"Protesters have had two months to occupy the park with tents and sleeping bags," Mayor Michael Bloomberg said in a statement. "Now they will have to occupy the space with the power of their arguments."

Arrest of a City Council Member

Still, by Wednesday some city council members had questions for the NYPD, particularly surrounding the eviction and associated arrests near Zuccotti Park that night.

Council member Ydanis Rodriguez demanded to know why he and others were arrested near Zuccotti Park. Rodriguez said he was two blocks away from the park when he came across a large number of NYPD officers who eventually arrested him.

“Whoever gave the order it was a wrong thing. I was not looking to be arrested. I did not provoke a situation to be arrested. I was assaulted by NYPD Officers…Thousands of people, especially in the Black and Latino Community, are mistreated. I am pretty sure that I have more chance to go through that situation being black and Latino than any other member of the council,” said Rodriguez.

Deputy Mayor for Operations Cas Holloway said Rodriguez was processed like everyone else and not singled out because he represents poor Latinos.

According to Rodriguez, he was held in a police van for two hours and then had to wait more than 12 hours before he could contact his lawyer.

Rodriguez was released without bail after being charged with resisting arrest. A court complaint said the council man tired to push past a metal police barricade and tried to keep from being handcuffed.

With reporting by Kathleen Horan, Ailsa Chang, Claudia Morell, Arun Venugopal and the Associated Press


More in:

Comments [11]

I support OWS. I say that. Others say that. but what are we supporting really? the concern is OWS means something different to everyone. OWS has done its job in protesting the corruption of Wall Street and bringing attention to the 99% disparity. My frustration comes from spending time defending the movement and why camping out is necessary and away from getting behind an action that will bring about change. My fear is all this may be for naught if the group/cause/movement doesn't get clear on a message and defining what it wants.

Nov. 16 2011 04:57 PM
DJ from Brooklyn

I appreciate much of the reporting WNYC has contributed to the events and issues surrounding OWS, and the focus Brian Lehrer, his staff, the news staff and particularly bulldog reporter Bob Hennelly has brought to under and sloppily reported aspects of the spectacle. Such aspects include the one Mr. Goldmark includes in reporting on the collusion and coordination of various municipal politicos and police authorities in their determination to rout protestors across the country. Unfortunately, WNYC often joins its media counterparts in failing to provide context and falling into media shorthand. Goldmark fails to mention, in quoting the mayor, that the "park's rules" have been promulgated only after and in response to the occupation of the park. Amy Eddings in her newscasts seems particularly prone to standard media formulations. Who writes/edits her copy?

Nov. 16 2011 01:49 PM
bobsled from westchester, ny

if i was going to clean the park, i would do it exactly the same way it was done. catch people off guard and very few or no one was hurt or injured attempting to mount resistance. to me, it was a brilliant move. the ows people can still speak, protest and coordinate their activites, no rights were taken away.... if you want to camp out, go to a camp ground.

Nov. 16 2011 01:06 PM
Laraine from Bronx

In the 1970's I read the Gulag and remember how they would come in the middle of the night to arrest people, so they would be their most vulnerable and unpreparred. None of the neighbors protested "thinking the authorities must be right." I never thought I'd see this in the USA. But Mayor Bloomberg proved me wrong. What a cowardly act.

Nov. 16 2011 12:52 PM
mjanuary from Long Island

My family visited Zucotti Park over the weekend. I wanted my children to see it and I'm glad we went when we did. While the park was crowded, we found it to be clean, and people to be civil and polite. While I didn't necessarily agree with everyone's agenda, I do support OWS and the right of people to voice their dissatisfaction with the direction our country is taking. I do believe that there is a concerted effort to silence OWS throughout the country and it is my hope that the movement will not fade away but rather evolve in a way that will gain influence and spur change.

Nov. 16 2011 12:50 PM
Elissa from Manhattan

This is a great opportunity for all the Occupy groups to descend on the Capital to pressure the supercommittee to to do their job, compromise to reduce the deficit and save the economy. Even your guest yesterday, Gene Sharp, was critical of the Occupy Wall Street protest, saying they weren't moving forward to the next stage of activism.

Nov. 16 2011 11:27 AM
Farrish Carter from NYC

I, along with my boyfriend, have been involved with OWS on a daily basis since day three. I think the rise of the tent city aspect of OWS made our lovely park a mess, housing opportunists who were sometimes violent, sometimes dealing drugs and frequently doing them. Some of my fellow activists loved the tents but many of us came to find them abhorrent. I hope/pray that Bloomberg comes to rue his clean-up, as he eliminated the element that was gradually alienating true activists and attracting the worst aspects of society. This new phase is clean, not as attractive to hangers-on and more focused than before. Let's work shifts through the winter and bring a new spring, as well as a Spring, to the the park and this nation.

Nov. 16 2011 10:20 AM

It was a cowardly and predictable act by Mayor Bloomberg and the NYPD to evict the Occupy Wall Street protestors at 1:00 a.m. The greedy 1% bankers and Wall Street CEO's are celebrating.

Nov. 16 2011 09:24 AM
bocephus from nyc

"In a statement, multi-billionaire Mayor Michael Bloomberg said the park was now open to the public."

"Billionaire Mayor Bloomberg — who said conditions within the park had become 'intolerable' — said he intended to allow protesters back into the park after it had been cleaned."

"'Protesters have had two months to occupy the park with tents and sleeping bags," the multi-billionaire Michael Bloomberg said in a statement. "Now they will have to occupy the space with the power of their arguments," said the billionaire. Doesn't carry much weight coming from a man who doesn't have to argue anything; he just buys it; including his last election.

What a farce.

Nov. 16 2011 09:21 AM
k webster from nyc


This "occupation" had medics, a non-violent security staff, food, teach-ins, shelter, a library, music, art, sustainable practices, and a viable democracy.

Meanwhile, our libraries are closing, our schools in trouble, our health care costs skyrocketing, artists can't afford to live here, our Parks aren't required to recycle, our homes insecure.

And our democracy? Bought and paid for by the likes of our mayor.

Nov. 16 2011 07:07 AM
now from all for one, one for all

Strive for what's good for the individual and what's good for society.
Education for cost
Eliminate the fed reserve and all debt (a fresh start)
Issue $200,000 credit, for now, to each USA citizen;
to keep the game rolling while we weed
out the greed and find ways to find a better way for all.
No more tax to fund corruption.
Transition of control from paid government to voluntary
community groups; formed by local citizens who will communicate
and with other community groups;
to bring government to the level of the people.
"For the people, by the people"
"Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness"

Nov. 16 2011 02:23 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


Latest Newscast




WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public


Supported by