Obama's Economic Ideas are Popular, So Why isn't He?

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

U.S. President Barack Obama makes a statement about his proposed federal deficit reduction plan in the Rose Garden at the White House September 19, 2011 in Washington, DC. (Chip Somodevilla/Getty)

"This is not class warfare. It's math." That was President Obama's blunt assessment of why higher taxes have to be a part of his proposal to Congress to decrease the deficit by $3 trillion over ten years and pay for his $400 billion jobs bill proposal.

That kind of straight talk is a surefire hit for on Twitter, but it's not proven too effective at winning the confidence of the American people. Obama's handling of the economy and his general standing among American adults scored an all-time low in the Wall Street Journal's poll at the end of August, and things haven't improved much in surveys taken after his jobs address are any indication. Even though Obama particular proposals are popular among those polled, they don't give good odds to the president's ability to get his proposals passed, and more importantly, to improve the economy and create jobs. 

For example, consider this: in a Bloomberg poll of Americans conducted after Obama's jobs address to Congress earlier this month, 52 percent said that the president doesn't have a clear plan, and 51 percent said taht the president's jobs bill package of tax cuts, aid to local government and infrastructure spending won't help lift the employment rate.

But they expressed enthusastic support for some of key aspects to that plan: 71 percent support that local aid to prevent teacher and police layoffs. In a New York Times/CBS News poll last week, 80 percent agreed that it's a good idea to invest in infrastructure projects right now, and 81 percent support cutting taxes for small businesses. 

And even on the hot button question of letting Bush-era tax cuts expire for householders earning more than $250,000, 56 percent told the NYT poll and 54 told Bloomberg that they support that. That's in line with how Americans polled about a year ago on the same question, before Obama signed a bill to re-up the Bush-era tax cuts as part of a deal with Republicans at the end of 2010. 

This mixed political bag comes at a time when Obama's standing with key constituencies in his coalition are on the decline. After Republican Bob Turner's win in New York's heavily Jewish 9th Congressional District, much was made about Obama's declining standing with Jewish voters.

While Obama's support among Jews is falling, a Gallup poll last week found that the gap between his approval rating among Jews and the nation overall “is essentially no different” than the trends throughout his term. More than a third of Obama supporters told Bloomberg pollsters last week that they still like Obama -- just not as much as before. The Wall Street Journal poll at the end of August showed how Obama's slipping favor broke down among key constituencies

Some 56% of women voters supported Mr. Obama in the 2008 campaign; now, 43% back his re-election. Support among white voters has fallen from 43% in 2008 to 31% in the most recent poll, and support among independents has collapsed from 52% in 2008 to 26% today. Two-thirds of Hispanic voters supported Mr. Obama in 2008. Barely a majority, 51%, now say they will vote for him.

Obama also fared poorly among independent voters in the latest NYT poll, with 59 percent registering their disapproval, though as we've reported, it's difficult to pin down exactly what these independent voters want from Obama. That could explain why the White House's efforts to seize the political center over the last year have failed to get Obama back in their good graces.  


More in:

Comments [1]

Gordon Raupp from Long Valley N.J>

Our President isn't more popular because we remain firm in our faith that there is a Santa Clause and Mr. Obama has the disagreeable task of advising that there is none.
The mindless minions love a persistent rumor that the President (any president) can make jobs, despite evidence that few will be made by actions of that office, excepting by declaration of war.
As few of us have been hired by the President, some intuitive sense that jobs come from elsewhere, seems more appealing.
We have learned that American companies have created millions of jobs in other countries. We can see, by reading the labels of nearly every item we purchase, that few consumables are produced by fellow citizens. Yet we remain stubbornly inclined that some magic our chief executive can conjure, will replace work and jobs that our most prosperous CEO's have farmed out.
We are feeling a little desperate now and imagine that if we bleat noisily and stare at the barn, soon The Farmer will emerge with food, shelter and good news. If he doesn't, we'll continue to bleat in a different direction.
Obama isn't more popular because he has asked us to prepare for more hardship and for some sacrifice (to wake up). He has asked the powerful to do more and take less. He has asked the remainder to retrain, to exercise fiscal restraint, to be compassionate.
WE don't want to hear that crap! Just leave us alone to be ruggedly independent, but for God's sake, make some jobs and don't mess with Social Security!

Sep. 22 2011 01:43 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


About It's A Free Country ®

Archive of It's A Free Country articles and posts. Visit the It's A Free Country Home Page for lots more.

Supported by

WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public.  Learn more at


Supported by