What Turner's NY-9 Win Means for Obama in 2012

Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Republican Bob Turner on Election Day in New York's Ninth Congressional District. (Spencer Platt/Getty)

In a district where 74 percent of voters told pollsters that they believe the country’s on the wrong track, voters wanted no more of the status quo. By an 8-point margin, the voters who turned out in the special Congressional election in Queens and Brooklyn opted for Republican newcomer Bob Turner over Democratic Party Assemblyman David Weprin.

Turner was quick to declare himself a harbinger of things to come. “I am telling you. I am the messenger. Heed us,” he declared in a victory speech early Wednesday morning. “This message will resound for a full year. It will resound into 2012.”

National Republicans gleefully embraced the victory as a rebuke of the president:

“Tonight the voters overwhelmingly rejected the Obama agenda,” Republican National Committee Chairman Reince Priebus tweeted after the race was called. Conservatives also argued the results signal a major allegiance change among Jewish voters, or as the Drudge Report dubbed Turner's victory, “revenge of the Jews.”

National Democrats moved quickly to try to contain the symbolism of losing the district ater spending hundreds of thousands of dollars and mobilizing grassroots volunteers in support of Democrat David Weprin. Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee Chairman Rep. Steve Israel (D-NY) dismissed the results as “not reflective”of the 2012 campaigns, when “Democratic challengers run against Republican incumbents who voted to end Medicare and cut Social Security while protecting tax loopholes for big corporations and the ultra wealthy.” 

Still, there's no question it's a humbling defeat for Democrats — particularly after they celebrated the predictive power of special elections after their win in a House special election in May. Then, Israel declared that the election signaled that “we can win back the House” on the Medicare issue. And the embarrassment comes as a time when President Obama is trying to position himself as the one person in Washington with the American people on his side as he tries to drum up support for his jobs bill, including at a stop today in North Carolina. 

In the midst of all this breathless positioning, Nate Silver argues at the New York Times that while the meaning of mid-cycle special elections are often overplayed, there is a statistically significant relationship between their results and the next general election. At the very least, he concludes, “they imply a reduction in the odds that after three consecutive “wave” elections, 2012 will show a tidal shift back toward Democrats.”

Leaving 2012 aside, in the immediate term, Bob Turner’s victory means a stark change in optics for New York's Ninth Congressional district. In place of Anthony Weiner’s brash, outspoken defense of liberalism in Washington, there is Bob Turner’s call for cutting the federal budget by a third over the next 10 years.

Here, a few comparisons:

Taxes and Spending:

Then-Rep. Anthony Weiner, April 2011

"You know, you can say that you’ll slash federal spending on something, but it doesn’t mean that someone doesn’t have to pick up the slack, and for New York City taxpayers, unfortunately, it’s going to be them holding the bag."

Incoming Rep. Bob Turner, August 2011

"It’s not only possible, it’s absolutely necessary [to cut spending by 35 percent and not raise taxes]."


Federal Health Care Legislation

Then-Rep. Anthony Weiner, March 2010

"Health care's 20 percent of our economy and it's a tangent? This is the problem -- we've got to solve the problem but let's do it some other time. For eight years in this country this problem was festering. Incomes were flat. Why? Cause every single spare dollar an employer had had to go into health care, not into wages. Our wages are down, our economy's at a standstill because of health care. And we're fixing that problem because your team didn't do it." 

Incoming Rep. Bob Turner, August 2011

"The first thing I would propose is the repeal of Obamacare."


The Politics of Medicare  

Then-Rep. Anthony Weiner, April 2011

“This week on the House floor, Republicans are going to say, we’re against Medicare. They want to eliminate it as it stands. Now, isn't it ironic they spent all last year in criticizing the health care act because it harmed Medicare. Now, suddenly, they want to eliminate it. Hypocrisy!"

Incoming Rep. Bob Turner, Campaign Website

“I believe that these programs should be preserved as they are for those in or near retirement and that we should work to strengthen and preserve them for our children and future generations. I oppose efforts to privatize or bankrupt either [Medicare or Social Security]. I would work with members of both parties to reach a solution that will meet our obligations on both of these programs.”


That last point may be the most interesting to watch for 2012. Democratic attack ads aimed straight at Turner's position on Medicare, but his talking points here sound awfully close to those of President Obama's. Remember that the president took time in his jobs speech last week to press the need to “gradually reform the system while protecting current beneficiaries."


More in:

Comments [10]

Daniel from Bronx

DemocRats thought that the pendulum would swing back for 2012 once Dear Leader’s policies crushed the middle class and they in turn ‘Blamed it on Bush!’. 2012 will make 2010 look like the good old days for many Marxists. I predict that DemocRats will lose more House seats, the Republicans will gain control of the Senate, and Obama will be a private citizen reviled by both sides.

Sep. 19 2011 01:36 PM
Juven from Brooklyn

Finally Obamascare will now disappear from New York.

Sep. 14 2011 10:15 PM
DEMs threw Weiner under the bus & suffer results

Looks like the Democrats are paying the price for their shameful public humiliation and destruction of Rep. Weiner - a patriot who stood up to moneyed interests and defended 9/11 first responders.

Unlike Clinton - Weiner didn't even have an affair - he just flirted foolishly. But the Democratic gender police destroyed him anyway for demonstrating normal male sexuality. As usual they claim that because he didn't want his trivial and frivolous recreational behavior to destroy his lifetime of serious and beneficial work and because he didn't race to air his dirty laundry in public, he should be destroyed for covering up. Yes, the Democratic gender police are shamefully willing to use a DOUBLE BIIND - if he'd admitted it, he would also have been unjustly publicly humiliated and destroyed.

What sexist hypocricy - one never sees the Democratic gender police seek to destroy a female politician for her pecadillos - doing so would be "repressing" her rights to free expression.

The eagerness and complicity of the Democratic gender police - caused grave harm to the Democrats and people who rely on them for sound policy back in Clinton's term.

Now, they've destroyed Rep. Weiner - a fundamentally good man.

So the DEMS have gotten what they deserved - they destroyed their own unjustly, and empowered their opponents.

Serves them right.

Hopefully, they'll be less eager to destroy an innocent in the future, and focus on their own personal morality before they throw stones at their neighbors and supporters.

Sep. 14 2011 03:37 PM

Hi Customer Service, I bought a ticket bound for the U.S of A but there seems to be a mistake... I don't recognize this country. Please help :(

Sep. 14 2011 11:13 AM

I'm not predicting that the DNC and Independents will take this vote as a wake up call but they ought to. Obama did not cause the recession. Stimulatory fiscal policy and bad regulatory oversight did. Both of these were GOP operating procedure. Obama has not been able to repair the damage of the prior 14 years of mismanagement. Electing born-again fiscal conservatives is a guarantee of more of the same.
My hope is that Democrats and Independents will stop the race to the bottom that is the GOP goal.
My fear is that too many voters will be confused or allow themselves to become disaffected by the circus.
If he's tossed out in Nov2012 (as I fonldy hope) will Mr. Turner still get a government pension?

Sep. 14 2011 11:04 AM
Fed Up from California

A Statement to Obama!! New York sent you a message your agenda does not work green is out , oil is our economy, next year you will be out pack your family up and go back to Chicago with the rest of your outcast so called politicians.

Sep. 14 2011 10:46 AM

The government has nothing until it confiscates it from the people. Stop the madness.

Sep. 14 2011 10:25 AM

How much doe's it cost tax payers for obama's travels around the country campaining to better himself in the eyes of the public

Sep. 14 2011 10:22 AM
YaYa OK from Oklahoma

This districts election was more about the current administration not coddling Israel and for the administration's stance of Israel continuing to steal land in the form of "new" settlements on Palestinian land.

But of course, it will be spun as a statement against the Obama economy.

Sep. 14 2011 10:15 AM

ugh, please tell me in 2012 we're not looking at loonies on a gut-the-government binge.

Sep. 14 2011 10:10 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


About It's A Free Country ®

Archive of It's A Free Country articles and posts. Visit the It's A Free Country Home Page for lots more.

Supported by

WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public.  Learn more at


Supported by