King Hearing on Somali Radicalization Struggles to Stay on Track

Wednesday, July 27, 2011

Rep. Peter King conducted the third in his series of hearings examining radicalization in the Muslim American community, this one focusing on the recruitment of Somali-American youth by the terrorist group Al-Shabaab. But the hearing frequently went off-track, with Democrats using the occasion to attack the very premise of the hearing and King pushing back against criticism from the media in recent days, namely The New York Times.

"I note that certain elements of the politically correct media," said King in his opening remarks, "most egregiously the vacuous ideologues at the New York Times—are shamelessly attempting to exploit the horrific tragedy in Norway to cause me to refocus these hearings away from Muslim-American radicalization."

"Let me make this clear to the New York Times and their acolytes in the politically correct, moral equivalency media," he continued. "I will not back down from holding these hearings."

The hearing featured just one Somali witness, Canadian Ahmed Hussen. He said that low employment within the Somali diaspora allowed some to become alienated “and fall victim to a narrative that turns them against Canada and the United States.”

"This dangerous and constant anti-western narrative is fed to them by radicals in our community," said Hussen, "who do not hesitate to use these vulnerable youth as gun fodder in their desire to establish a base for the Al Qaeda terrorist group in Somalia."

Additional testimony came from Saint Paul, MN police chief Tom Smith, whose outreach to the Somali community garnered attention from the British and Danish governments.

But subsequent questioning from Democratic members of the House Homeland Security Committee rarely probed the substance of the testimony and instead challenged Rep. King for continuing the hearings. Rep. Yvette Clark of Brooklyn said the hearings should've expanded from Muslim radicalization to all forms of radicalization, including gang activity in inner cities.

"When we become fixated on one type of people, we take our eyes off the prize," Clark said to King, adding, "I love you."

At another point, Rep. Al Green of Texas spent several minutes asking the witnesses to confirm, in so many ways, that they did not believe all Muslims are extremists. That provoked a rebuke from Rep. King.

For some observers, the interactions  proved distracting.

Solomon Kleinsmith, who participated in WNYC's live blog of the hearing, said he lived "a few miles" from King's district and didn't agree with him politically.

"But when four experts come to congress to answer questions, they should be taken seriously and the time should be used for substantive inquiry."


More in:

Comments [1]

Nick from New Jersey

A response to this could be a full book. But in general, my opinion is this:
This is just a media circus and a way for King to get his name into the headlines. The substance of this "hearing" is trash. Obviously, all Muslims do not believe in the simple Simon crap that al-Qaeda and fanatical Islamists/Clerics spew out like so many gallons of vomit. Why have a hearing on that?! Also, Somalia is quite possibly in the worst shape it has ever been in, and Peter King chooses this topic? The recruitment of Somali-Americans into al Shabab isn't the problem. The problem is al Shabab, Somalia, Ethiopia, and the heinous drought that is currently gripping the southern half of the country. Want to stop the recruitment of Somali Americans into al Shabab? Maybe start with the causes, not the very end effects. WHO VOTES FOR THESE PEOPLE?!

Jul. 28 2011 03:33 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


Latest Newscast




WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public


Supported by