Photo credit: @julesdwit.
A not-for-profit media organization supported by people like you.
Sasha Frere-Jones, pop music critic for the New Yorker magazine, compares the current leading ladies of pop.
hands down adele..forget the other two.
and the wiener is ..kate perryyy :D!!!!
Beyonce: Athletic, rhythmic, interactive showmanship. In the tradition of James Brown, Tina Turner, Michael Jackson, etc. -- minus, perhaps, the vocal character, depth, pathos, etc.
Adele: The sweet catharsis of blues and soul, and its perennial cross-cultural/racial/national appeal.
Lady Gaga: Performance art (I guess), perhaps at unfortunate expense of the music. (Disclaimer: I've heard/seen very little of her work, because what I have seen/heard hasn't inspired me to wanna see/hear more...)
Marilyn Manson preached all this too but you never herd any one talking positive about him. hypocrites
fame is not an indicator of talent. gaga being the example.and being famous doesn't make someone more intelligent, insightful, or knowledgeable than anyone else.anyone who takes their life cues from these artists is a very sad person...
vanity is the nemesis of progress. our society is degenerating and we are wasting time discussing divas.
really love gaga, really love beyonce.
what I like about their latest songs, and one of the reasons they feel like someone you could identify with...so accessible... is that they are singing to the audience in their more anthem-style songs...not about themselves, but an encouragement to the listener.
this topic is further proof of the decline of western civilization.
"Anyone would be won over by her""It's impossible to not like that", etc, etc
Um.....I don't like it
And don't forget Nicki Minaj -- in October 2010, Minaj became the first artist to have seven songs on the Billboard Hot 100 chart simultaneously! (source: Wikipedia)
Is it coincidence that the 2 people putting Robert's opinion down are women? Possibly fans of any of these "artists"? This is a waste of public radio airwaves. We have nuclear disasters, weather disasters, financial crisis, political mayhem and other issues concerning us. Leave theses topics to "Soundcheck"
It'd be great if they had a three-way fight to the death!
Hazel, agreed. This is apples to oranges. Musician vs. Entertainers.
Why is Adele being compared to such products of the star making machinery as Gaga and Beyonce? Adele has serious talent and does not have to rely on gimmicks or cheap flash to keep get her music across.
Robert, Jane is right, you are being a snob. You do realize that pop culture says something about our culture as a whole? Right? And how about you listen to the interview first before you decide it shouldn't be on the radio. Lehrer covers a wide range of topics everyday, and some of those topics I myself would have never thought to even think about; but I listened and learned something I never knew before. Let Brian help you open your mind a little bit.
Oh Robert, settle down. It's ONE topic,not a 'degeneration', and popular culture is very relevant, too.
Really? This is what public radio has degenerated into over the past decade, comparing female pop superstars?! I've watched, or rather listened to, the gradual decline into mundanity of public radio over the past decade but this has to be a new low. lol. Good luck!
Email addresses are required but never displayed.
Brian Lehrer leads the conversation about what matters most now in local and national politics, our own communities and our lives.
Subscribe on iTunes
WNYC 93.9 FM and AM 820 are New York's flagship public radio
stations, broadcasting the finest programs from NPR and PRI, as well as a wide range of award-winning local
programming. WNYC is a division of
New York Public Radio.