Photo credit: @julesdwit.
A not-for-profit media organization supported by people like you.
Dr. Nawal El Saadawi, Egyptian feminist and author of The Hidden Face of Eve, joins Yasmin Moll, an Egyptian American PhD student from NYU, to discuss what impact the revolution may have on women's rights.
Henry, most of the Jews in Egypt moved to Israel after it was founded, & most of the rest were already pretty old & have died since then..
It was the regime that burned the churches? Does that include the suicide bomber who blew himself up in the Coptic church in Alexandria? That certainly isn't the impression I got at the time. (But it was great to hear how Muslims went to the church afterwards to protect the Christians who went back there.)
re: "She is an anti american anti semite academic."
aren't they all? why single out this one?
what makes Brian so special is that he allows people of varying viewpoints to express their point of view, without constantly interrupting them, or playing 'gotcha', or trying to prove how much smarter he is than his own guest on the show.
it's hardly as if the views expressed by this guest are constantly being aired in the MSM.
please let Brian be Brian.
Yasmin Moll claimed that concern about Islam's treatment of women is "racist". That there are those who hate Muslims out of bigotry is sadly true, but that does not make all criticism of Islam bigoted, never mind "racist". (How can it be racist if no race is involved? She meant "bigoted", but so be it.) That Dr. Saadawi went along with that claim and actually claimed that Christianity and Judaism are worse in their treatment of women flies in the face of reality. She resorted to limiting the fact-base for her argument to scriptures that are 2000-3000 years old. How ridiculous! The vast numbers of Jews and Christians live in liberal, relatively gender-equal cultures. Sadly, this is not so for Muslims. That two feminists would make the argument that Islam is good for women is sad. That one should be Dr. Sadaawi is doubly sad.
How can Dr. Saadawi both a) blame the West for installing the Islamist regime in Iran to undo that secular revolution, and b) claim that the West is slandering the Muslim Brotherhood as Islamist to undo this secular revolution? These arguments are incorrect both factually and logically, and they contradict each other.
1) The West did not support Khomeni.. In fact, some anti-imperialist, leftist apologists denied he was a tyrant, and claimed that Western opposition to him was imperialist and Orientalist. (Michel Foucault comes to mind.)
2) The Muslim Brotherhood has a long history of supporting theocratic totalitarianism. This is no secret. That they now have supporters who advocate a moderate form Islamism like Turkey's is a recent innovation and far from the mainstream of the organization. Moreover, the differences between Turkey and Egypt are so vast that this comparison is apples and oranges.
3) The Iranian Islamists were happy to participate in a coalition until they coalesced power and marginalized, exiled, imprisoned and executed their opponents. That exists as a risk in Egypt should the MB take power.
4) Many of us in the West, in the Middle East and elsewhere both support democracy and oppose Islamicism as intrinsically contrary to democracy. That Dr. Saadawi disagrees is sad, but does not change my mind. Religious totalitarianism must be opposed everywhere.
5) With all that, I wish the Egyptians well and hope that my fears re the MB never materialize.
Please refer your guest to the Jewish ketubah which is the conjugal and moral responsbility of the husband to his wife. Judaism acknowledges there are DIFFERENCES in the role of men & women and that both roles are viewed as important and purposeful. Her comments were rather superficial and false regarding Judaism.
Brian....you are "mailing it in' these days.
This is cuckoo.She studied the Old Testament?? So what.
Western democracies from the judeo-Christian traditions now have sexual equality...or at least have made a pretty good try.
This is what passes for feminism in Egypt?
Brain can you please contradict this nonsense
...that's because religions where made up by men...
There used to be a sizable Jewish population in Egypt. They are gone. Not even a mention of them in this conversation.
Concern about Islamists is RACISM ????
Ask the young woman shot in Tehran in June 2009.
This segment was surreal, Brian.....absolutely surreal
Hi,I would like to ask Dr. Saadawi if she believes that the opposition is ready and equipped to usher in the democratic process? Also, are the protesters organizing and planning to support a political party? How will they follow through and ensure that their demands will be met?Thank you,Mary Ann RIad
sounds great! now they just have to get the other 90 million egyptians to act like those harvard square protesters... or can they turn this square into its own country? anyway i'm glad these women were around thousands of men yet were not hrrassed and raped.
Oh, this is sad.This poor scarred woman is caught up in the emotions of the moment. If the Brotherhood takes over, she should pack her bags for prison again.
This woman is the reason we support the present ruler.
She is an anti american anti semite academic.
Brian ask her a hard question please.
there are many more religions tan muslim and christian.
Why do women wear head scarves?
This person is lying. If "Hundreds: were killed then the whole world would have heard.This is a liar.
Brian, PLEASE avoid the puff questions and ask your guests from the academic bubble what they think "the people" will do in power when a center-left Pew Poll this past year found that, when given a choice, 59% of the public favored Islamists and a mere 27% favored modernizers. (This poll was widely discussed in the Israeli press, but barely noted by the NYT). Let's get real here.
Email addresses are required but never displayed.
Brian Lehrer leads the conversation about what matters most now in local and national politics, our own communities and our lives.
Subscribe on iTunes
Brian Lehrer Weekend: The Nation Magazine, Des Bishop & Eva Moskowitz
WNYC 93.9 FM and AM 820 are New York's flagship public radio
stations, broadcasting the finest programs from NPR, PRI and American Public Media, as well as a wide range of award-winning local
programming. WNYC is a division of
New York Public Radio.