Streams

East Village Bar Accused of Racist Door Policy

Monday, January 31, 2011

New York nightclub dress codes that may disguise racial discrimination are under scrutiny.

The New York City Commission on Human Rights is investigating an allegedly racist door policy at The Continental, an East Village bar popular with college students for its cheap drink specials. This past weekend, an anti-discrimination group picketed outside the bar in solidarity with an African-American woman named Thelecia Covington, who filed a complaint in December claiming that she was turned away from the bar because of her race.

The bar's owner, Trigger Smith, says he turns away over 200 people a night, and that a dress code is necessary for survival in the nightclub business. He claims that it’s about a certain style and subculture—not race. “We turn away people in baggy jeans and saggy jeans and gangster clothes,” says Smith. “I’ve turned away people of all colors, and there are people of all colors inside my bar. We turn away white trash, we turn away the 'Jersey Shore' types. I have a blanket rule about that. I’m not judging anybody. I’m just running a business here.”

Jeanette Caceres, a public school teacher and member of the racial action group ANSWER, believes that Smith’s comments about dress are disguising an overtly racist policy. Caceres first contacted the bar's owner after a friend of another member of ANSWER, Shaniqua Pippen, was denied entrance to the club. Caceres found similar stories online, on sites such as Citysearch and Yelp. She also tracked down a Facebook group called “Boycott the Continental Bar NYC” with over 100 members who posted stories of being refused entry. Many were told that they didn’t meet the dress code, or that the bar was only letting in “people that they knew.”

“We thought there could possibly be a door policy that was discriminatory,” says Caceres. “There was no official written dress code. There was no dress code posted on the Web site of the bar. We asked the bouncers if there was a list. There was no such list.”

Caceres says she tried to set up a meeting with Smith to discuss the allegations, but that they could not agree on a meeting place. Caceres and ANSWER have since organized two pickets of the bar, and flyered the neighborhood with signs telling passers-by to boycott the club. She also sent a letter asking Smith to attend racial sensitivity training classes and host multicultural theme nights at the bar.

“I’ll discuss the door policy with you, but as far as hosting theme nights, when you start paying rent here, I’ll start talking about it,” says Smith, who vehemently denies any charges of racist door policy. “I don’t have a racist bone in my body,” says Smith. “I would be militant if I was a person of color and I was turned away from because of my color. I was born and raised in New York. I’ve played sports with people of all colors. I’ve dated women of all colors.”

The Continental used to be one of the city’s top punk rock venues, but Trigger Smith changed the bar into a cheap-shots college drinking hole a few years ago, and says he’s finally turning a profit for the first time. A banner hanging over the entrance reads “5 Shots of Anything $10 All Day/All Night (Yes, we’re Serious).” On weekends, revelers line up outside around the block to take advantage of the deals before heading off elsewhere. Smith describes the bar as a “classy dive,” and says that he turns away more people than most Meatpacking District clubs. “It was either institute a door policy and a dress code, or lose my place and my staff. And that’s the truth.”

But is the Continental bar's policy legal? Kenji Yoshino, who teaches at NYU Law and specializes in discrimination cases, says that dress code discrimination suits are very common and very tricky. “In the first generation of discrimination, discrimination was very easy to spot, it took the form of ‘No Racial Minorities Allowed’. And that discrimination was easy to fight,” says Yoshino. “What we’re seeing is that there’s a second generation of discrimination that’s harder to spot. That takes the forms of employee or patron dress codes, for example. It doesn’t actually cut out all members of the group, but it will cut out members of that group that refuse to assimilate into the white mainstream.”

Yoshino says that even if the defendant--in this case the bar owner--is shown not to have discriminatory motives behind the policy, he can be found liable if the policy disproportionally affects minorities, unless he or she can prove a legitimate business purpose behind it. “So far, the precedents generally flow in favoring the employer (or bar owner),” says Yoshino. “But recently courts have been more sympathetic to these claims.”

In the complaint filed against Trigger Smith, Thelicia Covington claims that she and several African-American friends were turned away, and a group of white women on line behind them were let in without question. When they questioned the bouncer, who was also black, about the basis of the denial, he allegedly responded: “This is what the owner wants. Do you think I like denying my own people?”

If the Commission for Human Rights finds Smith guilty of discrimination, he may have to change his dress codes policies or pay damages to the city and Ms. Covington. “Unfortunately this happens all throughout the city,” says Jeanette Caceres. “It is unfortunate that one bar has to be targeted, but we feel we have proof that discrimination is happening at the Continental. It’s illegal and we’re standing against it because it’s a social injustice."

At the picket this weekend, Smith spoke with some of the protesters, and he says he’s willing to listen. “I understand it’s a sensitive issue, and that’s why I’m willing to meet with anybody. This is a sensitive thing. And people have the right to express themselves and be respected.”

Updated 2/1/11: This story has been updated with more information about the allegations against the Continental.

Tags:

More in:

Comments [9]

Everett-Delaware from Earth

Not letting paying patrons in 4 any reason is discriminatory.When I lived in Balto.Md. The Gay club I went to would keep out people of color by a sign that read NO hats allowed! Or three ID's. That was in the 1980's. I had the 3 ID's pulled on me @ the "Crisco Disco" in NYC in the 80's. I am white & in my 60's now. It's alful that this still go's on!. I face discirmination all the time. Age & Gay!.

PLEASE STOP THIS WE ARE ALL HUMANS!!!

Sep. 17 2012 11:08 AM
???! from D.C.

There's not a coherent thought among most of you, nor a nod to syntax and grammar.
I've never been to this club, and am not likely to go, but have you considered- maybe you were rejected because this is not the sound stage for the Jerry Springer show?

Sep. 15 2012 05:02 PM
taha F. from harlem

So me and my best friend Ari go downtown for his birthday to this place to get drunk real quick and chill. We bot are dressed trendy, and I have to say that my jeans were 30 inches long right now. We get there, and this African American bouncer with a fitted hat and baggy jeans tells my friend that he can get in , but that my jeans were too baggy and I couldn't get in. Then that I couldn't get in because I had on a tie cap (aka a du-rag), and then finally we couldn't get in because the spot is actually only for white people. ?THE SPOT IS ONLY FOR WHITE PEOPLE ? I think he was drunk when he told me that, Because here's this fat ass black guy telling my toned up black ass that I COULDN'T GET INTO THIS WHITE SPOT? And after reading reviews about how dirty the place was, and about how watery the drinks are, im a bit glad that I wasn't allowed in. but seriously if this place is only for WHITE people I want those ni**as fired... To top it off he tells my boy about some bar 3 long avenues across that wasnt even there

Sep. 11 2011 05:00 PM
wahtabotus from nyc

I live in east village and ny. ihave not ever gone in continental because it looks to jersey. But i was kind of set back by the rally , because i have been a discriminaton target abuse magnet by all kinds of people. gay, young, and in my job because people took me as because i had challenges as the one to abuse to make sure i did not rise.
i also had to stay in hostels in harlem. and the people from foreign countries and other college age like the ones turend away were also completely discriminitory in jazz hostels. the one girl a german db braged she was going to me more disciminatory to who she let in. one gay male terrorized me going and follow me from one hostel to other becuase i kept to myself avoid problematic people to keep thelife god gave me while i tried to survive medical condtions. i have also been a targert of blaks who are totaly discriminatory beligerently. up to recently where my medical condtions began to fail i had thick skim to people but the hostel situation i began to get sick of because the gay male told people some insane story so i could ont have a place to stay while i had to look for places to live. which was totaly illegal and creepy. he was a creep and would be any where i was. i sensed him three months after i left nyc anc came back and hewaited at door of a new place for me to be there that day i came out of taxi. i freaked out. i would back them if they backed me. sorry.

Jun. 22 2011 06:34 PM
rash from east village

Yes! of course they do when you have Cocaine drug dealing Criminal Nazi's like Jimmy gestapo "aka" James Dressler Of the coke front band murphys law running amoke in the club. you have metal biker guido nazi's there who follow him. he should be put away. he's a threat to the Community!

Feb. 02 2011 02:56 PM
algore from brooklyn, new york

I was a bartender at Continental and I can tell you this guy is a monster, and his club needs to be shut down. That part about "not letting in Jersey Shore types either" almost made me laugh, on any given friday the bar is filled, with nothing BUT New Jersey kids. He is lying. Also Trigger has a policy that you are not allowed to give any customer WATER ever, or you are fired on the spot. They can buy a bottle of water, but even if they've had two hundred dollars worth of booze, no tap water. Is this legal? I've never seen so many kids get sick from drinking. Hope he pays thru the teeth, since money is the only thing he likes. Hey Trigger...Instant Karma's gonna get ya!

Feb. 01 2011 02:41 PM
chaz van queen from Harlem NYC

Is this a call for "secret clubbers"?
I volunteer! I'll bring back a thorough, honest report.

Feb. 01 2011 02:29 AM
Lady Zombie from NYC

I am not surprised - it's about time. I wrote a blog about this place and their VERY discriminatory door policy... check it out here: http://ladyzombienyc.blogspot.com/2009/10/prejudice-in-east-village-written-by.html

Jan. 31 2011 11:41 PM
J.York from Brooklyn,Ny

I use to work there back in the 90's and I can say that Trigger 'Smith' does not like anyone of color in his establishment.

Jan. 31 2011 05:04 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.

Sponsored

Feeds

Supported by