Andrew Cuomo's Hopeful Bad News

Thursday, January 06, 2011

A slide from Andrew Cuomo's 2011 State of the State address depicting the budget process as three battleships captained by Cuomo, Skelos and Silver, and an air strike of special interests (wnyc)

Welcome to Politics Bites, where every afternoon at It's a Free Country, we bring you the unmissable quotes from the morning's political conversations on WNYC. Today on The Brian Lehrer ShowKen LovettDaily News Albany bureau chief, and Azi Paybarah, WNYC reporter and blogger, review Governor Cuomo's first State of the State address.

New Governor Andrew Cuomo delivered his State of the State speech on Wednesday, broadly outlining his plan for major budget cuts to restrain spending, while reclaiming New York's place as the "progressive capital of the nation." He also threw in lo-fi PowerPoint slides, including one with depicting the budget process as three "ships passing in the night" captained by Cuomo, Skelos and Silver, with Cuomo facing a missle siege from "special interests."

The Daily News' Ken Lovett characterized the governor's address as a "very dire, dense speech, filled with a lot of grim messages and a lot of unpopular ideas that he’s asking the lawmakers to undertake." WNYC's Azi Paybarah noted many people's surprise in hearing the son of Mario Cuomo calling for such spending austerity, and found the slide complementary to the general theme of the speech.

The entire speech was geared towards the public and putting public pressure on the legislative process that most people sort of ignore. So actually having a visual way to show that there are people who are attacking him and that there are three components to making the budget, it’s sort of saying “look, I’m responsible for making the budget, but there’s two other people there also.”

It was a notable departure from former Governor Elliot Spitzer, who had emphasized that he alone was going to bring pressure to the statehouse. Cuomo stressed that this term, it will be the people of the state pressuring the lawmakers along with him. 

The speech presented a litany of ways that New York State government is too big, declared upstate “truly an economic crisis,” referred to the “exploding” costs of pensions. "The state of New York spends too much money. It is that blunt, and it is that simple,” Cuomo said. Cuomo mixed his calls for budget cuts with an emphasis on socially-progressive policy, saying, "Yes, we must deal with these fiscal realities...But at the same time we also have to contitnue to achieve the social progress that made this state famous.”   

Lovett said that highlighted an important difference between Cuomo and the standard Republican approach to budget-cutting.

Andrew Cuomo recognizes, like the Republicans, that you need to cut government, that it’s bloated, that they’ve overspent beyond their means and all that. But, at the core, Andrew Cuomo believes in government, whereas a lot of times when you hear the Republicans, [they are] demonizing the government for the problems... Andrew Cuomo, like his father, sees government as a way to help the public, and he feels that what he wants to do is get it under control and then use it as a force for good.

Cuomo repeatedly referred to "special interests" in his speech, but left out exactly who that meant. Both Paybarah and Lovett considered that a reference to teachers' unions, health care unions, and public service workers, not private businesses or real estate interests. Lovett predicts that labor may make formidable opponents for Cuomo.

Those are the groups who put millions of dollars in ads on the radio and television during every budget season, attacking proposals to cut them. Those are the groups that give millions and millions in dollars in donations and wind up, in lot of ways, controlling the lawmakers through threats of not endorsing them and backing other candidates… [Cuomo] sought to buy himself time and neutralize some of them, particularly the health care industry, by forming a commission to come up with recommendations to cut Medicaid and reorganize and revamp the program… and he put the unions on that task force, and what does that do? It’s going to be hard for the unions to attack the governor, at least for the next few months.. hard for them to put up ads when they’re supposed to be helping come up with the solution.

A caller from Rockland didn’t vote for Cuomo but found his speech encouraging. She especially appreciated Cuomo's direct manner of speech, and pointed out that terms like "special interest groups" may mean diffferent things to different audiences.

We’re all talking in euphemisms. We don’t come out with what we really mean. Even the word "change".. Change to me might not be what I want change to be. Things have to be spelled out in simple terms.“  

A caller from Manhattan who went to Albany to hear the speech called it "silly" that the Governor kept referring to the audience as the people. The caller said that because the speech was at 1p.m. on a Wednesday, most people were working, so he believed the audience was comprised mostly of people with interest in government.  

I wandered into a reception afterwards, and there were hundreds and hundreds of people in reception, almost of all of whom were lobbying for something or another. But that’s the nature of government, to point to lobbyists and make them we the people.

Also notable in the speech was the governor's obvious comfort with public speaking. Lovett pointed out that the Governor was speaking from notes, not a script, and had a clear command of the oratory.  

I don’t think we’ve had a governor who could speak like this since Mario Cuomo… the big question is, will he be able to get his agenda items through?

The state will have to wait and see what the specifics are of what gets enacted and what gets done, but Lovett is optimistic.  

After the last four years of dysfunction and corruption and watching New York spin down the drain, there’s at least hope now — cautious hope, given what we’ve seen — but at least there’s some hope, which we didn’t have the last couple of years. 


More in:

Comments [5]

Opal from NYC

I found the Gov.'s speech riddled with cliches and uninspiring (e.g., proof is in the pudding). I'm sure Medicaid can use a rehaul--rid it of fraud and waste--but he has chosen a problem affecting the most vulnerable.
The Gov. mentioned that high taxes are depleting job growth. I never heard him mention the most egrefious Real Estate Industry which has been bleeding the public. I wish he had the man who owned a coffee shop in Queens whose rent was increased from $1500 to $10,000 a month! Obviously the man had to give up his neighborhood business after many, many years.
New York City has been hit the worst --businesses won't move here because they can't pay the rents and there is no reasonable rents where there prospective employees might live.
Gov. Paterson lost his job because he wanted to do the very same things. The new Gov. is a dud.

Jan. 06 2011 10:34 AM
Katie from Huntington, NY

How stupid can that caller be???? All the rich are going to run away from New York? Give me a break. How can middle class America fall for that propaganda???? I am furious. First the President and now the Governor. Don't tax the rich, tax the poor, tax the middle class. Cut Social Security. Cut Medicare, Cut Medicade. Freeze wages. Where is the outrage? Oh, I know. It's all inside of ME!

Jan. 06 2011 10:25 AM

Cuomo never gave specifics on how to cut the budget. Taxes will need to go up, face realty. Why not tax corporations more? Oh no, they will leave NY and jobs will be lost. Come on, don't believe the hype.

Cuomo has a tough battle and will disappoint. It's a no win situation.

GIve us specifics.

Jan. 06 2011 10:25 AM
Amy from Manhattan

Cuomo did specifically mention poor people in his inaugural address, though, saying, "We are rich & we are poor, but we are all New Yorkers" (as part of a series of similar pairs).

Hey, Brian, *thank you* for saying state workers are the governor's "troops"! Exactly, & I'm worried about his apparent approach treating them as an enemy.

Jan. 06 2011 10:18 AM
Robert from NYC

I didn't listen to the speech but from what I'm hearing here I totally agree. I like the way your guest put it. Get rid of the bloat but yet get a handle on it to use it to the state's advantage.

Jan. 06 2011 10:16 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


About It's A Free Country ®

Archive of It's A Free Country articles and posts. Visit the It's A Free Country Home Page for lots more.

Supported by

WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public.  Learn more at


Supported by