Stephen Reader covers politics for It's a Free Country, WNYC's interactive politics site. He joined the station in 2010 and has also worked for Studio 360, WNYC's Peabody Award-winning show about art, culture, and creativity.
For Liberals, Little Comfort in Tax Cut Compromise
Friday, December 10, 2010
Welcome to Politics Bites, where every afternoon at It's A Free Country we bring you the unmissable quotes from political conversations on WNYC. On today's Brian Lehrer Show, Lawrence Mishel, president of the Economic Policy Institute, talks about whether liberals should still be upset with the details of the plan.
When asked if he had reconsidered his opposition to President Obama's tax cut compromise since Monday night, Lawrence Mishel couldn't give a definite yes or no. The most he could say for certain is that liberals got more out of the deal than anybody thought they would.
This is a deal that actually provides more stimulus about jobs and lowering unemployment than I would have expected a week ago. I met with the president on Tuesday and he said we got much more than he thought was available a month ago if you asked him. The Republicans did what they do, which is defend the ability of people with great wealth to be able to have very little taxes on their inheritances and to cut back on the taxes they pay on their incomes. What the president got was 13 months continuation of the unemployment plan, which most of us here in Washington didn't think we were going to get.
So given the choice between raising federal revenues and cutting spending to deal with massive budget shortfalls, the government chose neither. Mishel said that this illustrated the "deficit hysteria" that's run rampant on Capitol Hill since Obama took office. In recent months, worries about the deficit have helped Republicans take back the House of Representatives and forced Democrats to relent on a number of fiscal policy issues, all in the service of what many liberal economists believe to be a non-issue.
The Republicans are hypocrites because these tax cuts for the rich, they'd like that to be deficit financed, but they're not willing to deficit finance unemployment benefits. For some reason, a dollar being taken out of a rich person's pocket is really horrible for the economy, but a dollar in the pocket of an unemployed worker doesn't help the economy whatsoever. On the Democrats' side, they now have to defend raising the deficit, but that's good policy.
While there are some things in this compromise for liberals to be happy about, Mishel thinks that Obama and Congressional Democrats could have held out longer and gotten a better result, both economically and politically.
If you let the tax cuts expire and all the taxes go up, you get the people's attention, then you have a much more fervent debate, and you actually get people to pay attention to who's defending the rich and who's defending the middle class.
Liberal callers said they didn't need to pay any more attention to who's defending which class. While Mishel seemed ultimately ambivalent about the compromise, people on the phone were furious. A woman named Linda was especially fed up with Democrats' concessions.
I think the Democrats need to draw a line in the sand now. They were real wimps during the election and Republicans were all about the deficit, the deficit, the deficit. And now they want to give all this money to the top one percent. It's crap! I heard so many people complain about bailouts. They should be crying about giving all this money to rich people.
A man named James echoed her sentiments, but was more bewildered than angry. Like Linda, and most of the liberal base that Obama called out during his Tuesday press conference, James just can't wrap his head around providing economic relief for the wealthiest Americans, even if it's given in exchange for other items on the liberal wish list.
[The rich have] got so much money, if they lived to be a thousand they couldn't spend it. And yet they want more, I don't understand it. The poor people are in trouble, obviously, there's no jobs out here. The middle class are getting squeezed to death. I work for the city, they're laying off people like crazy. I don't know what to say. It's very discouraging out here.
» Listen to the entire conversation on The Brian Lehrer Show.