Streams

Why the Tax Cut Compromise was a Missed Opportunity

Wednesday, December 08, 2010 - 11:12 AM

Reshma Saujani

Much has been made this week about whether President Obama is a capitulator or an ideologue.

Democrats are angry with the President for compromising with Republicans to extend all of the Bush tax cuts for two years and for cutting the estate tax rate to 35 percent. The White House argues that it's a good trade: in exchange, the Republicans agreed to a thirteen-month extension on unemployment benefits for the long-term jobless, and for a one year cut in payroll taxes.

President Obama defended the deal on the grounds that action is better than gridlock. "People will have the satisfaction of having a purist position and no victories for the American people," he said. "And we will be able to feel good about ourselves and sanctimonious about how pure our intentions are and how tough we are, and in the meantime the American people are still seeing themselves not able to get health insurance because of preexisting condition, or not being able to pay their bills because their unemployment insurance ran out. That can't be the measure of of how we think about our public service. That can't be the measure of what it means to be a Democrat."

An argument in favor of an early resolution on tax cuts is that it removed a procedural hurdle to the DREAM Act and the repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell during the lame duck session, when there is a stronger chance that both of these issues will be resolved favorably. I would take this one step forward and argue that any White House compromise on the tax cuts should have included an agreement from the Republicans to support the passage of the DREAM Act and the repeal of DADT. As a progressive, I think those issues are much more important than online poker.

While a resolution on the tax cuts is critical for working families across the nation, we must also ensure that we remain one of the world's dynamic, competitive, and prosperous economies. In order to do so, we must fundamentally reform our education system, overhaul our broken immigration system, and make sure we honor our nation's values of equality and freedom.

Achieving these goals begins with the passage of the DREAM Act and the repeal of DADT. President Obama should demand the immediate repeal of DADT. An American solider should not die on a battlefield in Afghanistan because a gay American interpreter was not allowed to serve. President Obama should also demand the immediate passage of the DREAM Act. A student who could discover a cure for cancer should not be denied educational opportunities because of petty Washington politics. According to a non-partisan study, 726,000 illegal immigrants would be immediately eligible for the DREAM Act and over two million immigrations would be eligible in the future. Those are a lot of future scientists and entrepreneurs.

If Democrats, Republicans and Independents alike came together on DADT and the DREAM Act, it would demonstrate our commitment to regaining civility in politics again. If we were to do that, there is much we could achieve. Let's stop talking about backbones and start taking about justice and fairness. Let's start talking about collective sacrifice and accept the hard realities of the time we are in. We have to dig deep as one nation, put party politics aside, and ensure that light burns bright for our children.

For all of those Democrats that are looking for a fight, let's demand the immediate passage of the DREAM Act and the repeal of DADT now!

Reshma Saujani ran an unsuccessful campaign in the 2010 Democratic primary against Rep. Carolyn Maloney in New York's 14th district, which covers Manhattan and Western Queens. A community activist, attorney for hedge funds and a legal scholar, she is a graduate of the University of Illinois, received her Masters in Public Policy from the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University and her JD from Yale Law School.

Tags:

More in:

The Morning Brief

Enter your email address and we’ll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.

Comments [2]

Francis from Indianapolis, IN

MAKE--YOUR--VOICE--KNOWN--ON--THE--DREAM--ACT--TRAVESTY. TODAY 4.00 EST

MAKE YOUR EMERGENCY CALL TODAY. NOW! CALL YOUR SENATOR OR HOUSE REPRESENTATIVE.

Those taxpayers who have had enough, BOMBARD your Senators with your words and your Members of Congress to oppose the DREAM Act Amnesty -- 202-224-3121 NumbersUSA for details. NumbersUSA will inform you of the truth.

Majority Senate Whip Dick Durbin of Illinois predicts the Dream act will come up for a vote Wednesday. We cannot let Senator Reid and his demagogues lever this badly worded immigration bill in for a vote. With Senator Reid at the helm of his Liberal ship, he cannot be allowed to pass this law--as is? It will cause another Chain Migration avalanche of family members, who eventually will end up on the welfare rolls. This became predominant after first of sixth amnesties that began in 1986 Simpson-Mazzoli bill.

There is absolutely no question that in the coming years, student family members will become a further economic encumbrance on the middle class once --Chain Migration--is underway. Hundreds of thousands or even millions will enter America through Chain migration. Eventually the sponsor cannot or will not support the immediate family members. This burden will fall upon this nations public benefit system. Old sponsored family members will become sick and without the subsistence of the original sponsor will end up in the emergency county hospital. Hundreds of hospitals right now are overrun with newcomers on dialysis procedures, costing billions of dollars a year. Sisters entering America through the Chain migration in turn will have their own babies who will collect instant citizenship and the whole vicious cycle will never be closed, as our population will explode as with the 1986 Simpson-Mazzoli bill.This nation cannot afford this monstrosity of a bill, in this fiscal period with America teetering on a 14 Trillion dollar edge of insolvency. This is not just about the US treasury, but almost every State the money reservoir are badly depleted from the illegal alien welfare programs.

California-the Sanctuary State—on the front line of illegal immigration has serious money problems. The illegal alien entitlement programs is rampant around this nation.

Dec. 08 2010 04:49 PM
Francis from Indianapolis, IN

MAKE--YOUR--VOICE--KNOWN--ON--THE--DREAM--ACT--TRAVESTY. TODAY 4.00 EST

MAKE YOUR EMERGENCY CALL TODAY. NOW! CALL YOUR SENATOR OR HOUSE REPRESENTATIVE.

Those taxpayers who have had enough, BOMBARD your Senators with your words and your Members of Congress to oppose the DREAM Act Amnesty -- 202-224-3121 NumbersUSA for details. NumbersUSA will inform you of the truth.

Majority Senate Whip Dick Durbin of Illinois predicts the Dream act will come up for a vote Wednesday. We cannot let Senator Reid and his demagogues lever this badly worded immigration bill in for a vote. With Senator Reid at the helm of his Liberal ship, he cannot be allowed to pass this law--as is? It will cause another Chain Migration avalanche of family members, who eventually will end up on the welfare rolls. This became predominant after first of sixth amnesties that began in 1986 Simpson-Mazzoli bill.

There is absolutely no question that in the coming years, student family members will become a further economic encumbrance on the middle class once --Chain Migration--is underway. Hundreds of thousands or even millions will enter America through Chain migration. Eventually the sponsor cannot or will not support the immediate family members. This burden will fall upon this nations public benefit system. Old sponsored family members will become sick and without the subsistence of the original sponsor will end up in the emergency county hospital. Hundreds of hospitals right now are overrun with newcomers on dialysis procedures, costing billions of dollars a year. Sisters entering America through the Chain migration in turn will have their own babies who will collect instant citizenship and the whole vicious cycle will never be closed, as our population will explode as with the 1986 Simpson-Mazzoli bill.This nation cannot afford this monstrosity of a bill, in this fiscal period with America teetering on a 14 Trillion dollar edge of insolvency. This is not just about the US treasury, but almost every State the money reservoir are badly depleted from the illegal alien welfare programs.

California-the Sanctuary State—on the front line of illegal immigration has serious money problems. The illegal alien entitlement programs is rampant around this nation.

Dec. 08 2010 04:49 PM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Sponsored

About It's A Free Blog

Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of a blog, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.

Supported by

WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public.  Learn more at revsonfoundation.org.

Feeds

Supported by