Department of Education Names More School Closures

Monday, December 06, 2010

The Department of Education named another 14 struggling schools it plans to close Tuesday, bringing the total number to 26 schools the department says should be phased out by next fall. This includes the Kappa II school which it says should be closed by the end of this school year.

Deputy Chancellor Mark Sternberg says, "These are tough decisions, but we cannot afford to let schools continue to fail students when we know we can do better."

Those schools being phased out include Jamaica High School, Columbus High and Paul Robeson High, which were among 19 schools the city tried to close last year before a court found it didn’t provide enough community notification.

On Monday, the department recommended phasing out John F. Kennedy High School in the Bronx, Beach Channel High School in Queens and the Ross Global Academy Charter School in Manhattan, among other schools. In the case of the Ross Academy, the department is recommending the state not renew the school's charter.

Among the schools named Monday, there were four schools named by the Department of Education in the Bronx. Bronx Borough President Reuben Diaz Jr. said school officials should consider other alternatives for the schools, like restructuring them or changing their leadership. Diaz says parents have complained about a lack of resources for science and computer labs. “Over the last eight years, the closings and the re-openings of schools have not led to the progress that is needed,” Diaz said Monday.

He says he'll continue to press officials to find alternatives to school closings. “We're going to fight them at every chance that we get to make sure they're considerate of what the neighborhood, the community, parents, students and teachers want,” Diaz said.

Phasing out a school would occur over the next three years and means the school would stop taking incoming students next September. Kappa II may close by the end of this school year.

The department identified a total of 55 struggling schools earlier this fall that could be phased out, and will announce its decision for the rest of them Tuesday. Those the city decides not to close could receive federal money to improve. There are two ways this can happen: a "transformation model," which keeps most of the staff (see The Big Fix series for more information) or a "turnaround" approach that replaces half of the teachers.

Rene Osborne-Hill, a guidance counselor at the Academy of Environmental Science Secondary School in East Harlem, one of the schools slated for closure said, “It hurts, it’s frustrating, why can't they do something if they see that this is not working? Why can't they fix it? We're losing a high school in the community, that's really sad."

City officials say they are trying to avoid a lawsuit, like last year, but the teacher's union president Michael Mulgrew told reporters that the city can count on seeing the union in court.

List of schools to be closed:

  • P.S. 30 in the Bronx
  • P.S. 260 Breuckelen in Brooklyn
  • M.S. 571 in Brooklyn
  • *Kappa II in Manhattan
  • I.S. 231 Magnetech 2000 in Queens
  • John F. Kennedy High School in the Bronx
  • *Academy of Environmental Science Secondary High School in Manhattan
  • School for Community Research and Learning in the Bronx
  • Beach Channel High School in Brooklyn
  • *New Day Academy in the Bronx
  • The Urban Assembly Academy for History and Citizenship for Young Men
  • Ross Global Academy Charter School in Manhattan
  • P.S. 114 Ryder Elementary School in Brooklyn
  • *P.S. 332 Charles H. Houston School (K-8) in Brooklyn
  • City of New York: Frederick Douglass Academy III (6-12) in Manhattan
  • I.S. 195 Roberto Clemente School (Middle school) in Manhattan
  • *Academy of Collaborative Education (Middle school) in Manhattan
  • P.S. 102 Joseph O Loretan (Elementary school) in the Bronx
  • Metropolitan Corporate Academy (High school) in Manhattan
  • *Monroe Academy for Business and Law (High school) in the Bronx
  • Performance Conservatory High School in the Bronx
  • *Jamaica High School in Queens
  • *Global Enterprise High School in the Bronx
  • *Norman Thomas High School in Manhattan
  • *Paul Robeson High School in Brooklyn
  • *Christopher Columbus High School in the Bronx

(*These were among the 19 low-performing schools the city tried to close this year before a court found that education officials hand't properly notified the affected communities.)

Below is a map of the proposed schools to be closed.

View City Schools to be Phased Out by September 2011 in a larger map


More in:

Comments [3]

Mary Conway-Spiegel from Manhattan

As a volunteer parent/student advocate for Christopher Columbus High School,
I can report first-hand that CCHS and its principal, Lisa Fuentes, embody the definition of a successful school. CCHS welcomes all students, regardless of need, and provides them with the education and tools to become productive members of society. English Language Learners, Special needs children, residents of homeless shelters, ex-offenders and honors students attend CCHS.

Will the DoE’s generic template for successful schools punish these kids, some of whom, due to severe circumstances, may actually graduate seven years after entering high school? Is it a wonder or a miracle that a freshman who reads at a third-grade level or is forced to travel great distances to a school because of rampant zoned school closings actually does graduate? The bottom line here is that they are given the opportunity to graduate.

While Ms. Fuentes and her team of extraordinarily gifted teachers serve the neediest of the needy, they have also crafted a far-reaching, highly thoughtful and inclusive Charter Conversion Proposal. If this application is approved, indeed no child will be left behind.

Dec. 08 2010 03:57 PM

Chris N brings up a really good point. Schools like Beach Channel are pretty far away from other schools. That could turn into a rough commute for students. It would be nice if the Dept. of Education answered these kind of questions now rather than later.

Dec. 07 2010 03:23 PM
Chris N from NYC

Can anyone explain, succinctly, what happens to students at these schools after they are closed? Do they face an untenable commute to another insufficient school? Does the school reorganize and reopen quickly? The answer to this first question is something that I never see addressed in the media

Dec. 07 2010 06:31 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


Latest Newscast




WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public


Supported by