Influencing Steiner

Can Anyone Get to the Man who will Decide Cathie Black's Fate?

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Mayor Bloomberg appoints Cathie Black, as Joel Klein steps down (Edward Reed/WNYC)

Right now, there is only one person who can block Mayor Bloomberg’s controversial nominee from actually getting the job of running the nation’s largest school system: David Steiner.

As commissioner of the state Department of Education, Steiner will decide whether to grant “a waiver” to Bloomberg’s pick Cathie Black, since she does not have the requisite work or education background for the job. Black, a magazine publisher until Bloomberg offered her the job “out of left field,” did not attend public school, and sent her children to boarding school in another state.

Those are just some of the complaints critics have raised about Black. Others' objections are less personal. Some critics say the job is too complex for anyone to master in three years. (Bloomberg’s latest term in City Hall is set to expire on December 31, 2013. He says he will not seek to extend his term by rejiggering the city’s term limits law again.)

Waivers have been granted before to candidates like Black. Frank Macchiarola, deemed “the undisputed boss of the public schools” by New York magazine, got one. So did Harold O. Levy, the guy tapped to run city schools by Mayor Rudy Giuliani, a hard-nosed manager in his own right with a penchant for driving critics out of the city (Police Commissioner Bratton fled to L.A., while Schools Chancellor Rudy Crew went to Miami).

Bloomberg has already won one waiver from the state when he selected his first chancellor, Joel I. Klein.

But the world was different then. At that time in 2002, the state legislature had just granted Bloomberg mayoral control of schools, and denying him his pick to run the schools would have required unusually cohesive opposition. None existed, in no small part because Bloomberg was a new mayor (read: had made no enemies). And Klein was, in some ways, an ideal person for a waiver. Not only did he quickly master much of the district's arcane data, but he spoke convincingly about his own experiences in the New York City public education system. To this day, his name is still on the Wall of Honor at the public school he attended in Astoria, Queens.

But none of those waivers were granted by Steiner, who became the state education commissioner in the summer of last year.

So far, he’s shied away from saying what he thinks of Black’s candidacy.

While City Hall has pointed to Black’s notable supporters, including former Mayors Guiliani, Dinkins, and Koch, a resolution opposing Black’s nomination was circulated in the New York City Council.

Few lawmakers have come out in her defense, but there hasn't been a lot of protest from legislators either. (State Senator-elect Tony Avella is an exception - he immediately announced his desire to see her blocked after Black’s surprise nomination was announced on November 9.)

But there is some grousing about the process. Assemblyman Hakeem Jeffries of Brooklyn notes, with some displeasure, that Steiner is obligated to create a screening panel to review Black’s waiver request, but, that’s about all Steiner has to do.

“The only obligation that constrains [Steiner] is that he appoint a screening panel that will evaluate the waiver request and then make a recommendation to him, said Jeffries. “He does not have to accept the recommendation by the screening panel.”

Jeffries also noted there are no “parameters about the makeup of the screening panel” that Steiner has to put together.

Despite the wide latitude Steiner has, he is constrained, somewhat, by the reality that he is operating, for better or worse, in Albany. (A place that Governor Paterson, in moments of frustration, he refers to as a separate planet where even the laws of physics don’t apply.)

While lawmakers have no formal role in granting the kind of waiver that only Steiner can issue, they do have some things that he wants: control of the education budget.

“Certainly the legislature has budgetary and oversight” power, noted Jeffries, who said he was confident that Steiner would want to “maintain a continuing relationship with the Senate and Assembly moving forward.”

“I’m sure he understands the need to be responsive, sensitive and respectful throughout this wavier process,” said Jeffries.

So, they do have a way to make their voices heard.

Another source who follows state education policy said the waiver issue, like anything else in Albany, is impacted by the lawmakers who decide to get involved. Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver is declining to comment, seeing no need to lend any of his significant influence to the matter.

The chair of the Education Committee in the New York State Senate, Suzi Oppenheimer, has not commented publicly yet, and did not return a call seeking comment. She’s also busy with an unresolved recount in her re-elction campaign, where she holds a lead over  a Republican challenger who had the distinct benefit of being endorsed by…Mayor Bloomberg.

Whether Black gets the waiver is “a close call,” said Jeffries. Steiner “can go in either direction.”


More in:

Comments [3]

Gerry Segal from Manhattan

In Education: Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose

New York City just got a new Chancellor of Education who never taught a class.

I taught in the south Bronx 45 years ago. Same problems..­.different players. Nobody cares about the kids. This song I wrote in 1966 tells the whole story.

Nov. 19 2010 10:04 AM
Albion from NYC

Ms Black, like the mayor is a business professional. The experiment with Klein managing the school system has clearly not worked. The numerical indicators he and the mayor used to justify installing a non-education professional as chancellor were bogus as evidenced by the change in their meaning. There are enough education professionals available nationwide to find a competent individual to operate our schools. Schools are not businesses; they are learning institutions and should be led by teachers or educators. Steiner should not approve the waiver, the mayor whose constituencies are business people should not be able to once again force his way on the citizens and students

Nov. 18 2010 11:22 AM
Marianne Bongolan from Staten Island

Ms. Black is just a person, who doesn't know much. What's important is the dictatorship of the Mayor, the secretiveness and totally un-democratic process he made this (and other) decisions and that no one is able/wiling to stop the inappropriateness of a selection such as Ms.Black's. Her "talent" as an executive is rather checkered, as reported by the Wall Street Journal's media-speaker this morning on The Takaway.
I suppose, children can now ask for waivers as well if they don't make the grade -- why nor? -- she is a prime exemple.

As a taxpayer, we have the right to know how much is the Mayor charging the taxpayers for this inapproriateness, most likely resulting in an educational fiasco on the top. What would be Ms.Black's salary for not having any experience in the field and not knowing much about education?

Nov. 18 2010 10:54 AM

Leave a Comment

Email addresses are required but never displayed.

Get the WNYC Morning Brief in your inbox.
We'll send you our top 5 stories every day, plus breaking news and weather.


About It's A Free Country ®

Archive of It's A Free Country articles and posts. Visit the It's A Free Country Home Page for lots more.

Supported by

WNYC is supported by the Charles H. Revson Foundation: Because a great city needs an informed and engaged public.  Learn more at


Supported by