search supported by:
E-Pledge
July 06, 2008 | 74°F haze

The Brian Lehrer Show

beer milk lettuce

Are You Being Gouged?

Our latest "crowdsourcing" project asks listeners to go to their local grocery store and find out the price of three goods: milk, lettuce and beer. You don’t have to buy them (or consume them), but we want to know how much they cost in different neighborhoods throughout the New York area.

Associate producer Jim Colgan introduces the new project.

View the Results: Lettuce | Beer | Milk

See our previous assignment


Listener Comments Back to Episode
[1]
Posted by: Jim
September 24, 2007 - 08:42AM
Fort Greene, Brooklyn

Milk: $1.50

Lettuce: $1.50

Budweiser: $6.00

Name: Ralph's

Location: Fort Greene/Lafayette Ave. & South Portland

Characteristic: Small neighborhood bodega

Surprised: Yes!

[2]
Posted by: Jim
September 24, 2007 - 11:00AM
Manhattan

Lettuce - $1.99

Budweiser - $6.49

Milk - $1.19*

FreshDirect

Cyberspace

Online Grocer

Surpirsed - No

*not including delivery fee

[3]
Posted by: ellen
September 24, 2007 - 12:06PM
manhattan

milk $1.39/qt

iceberg lettuce $1.99/ head

6 pack Budweiser, bottles $6.99

Gristedes Broadway between 103rd and 104th st

Surprised, no! Prices at this store are rarely a bargain

[4]
Posted by: Miss Kitty
September 24, 2007 - 12:07PM
Gravesend Brooklyn

Local medium sized supermarket:

Fine Fare, 406 Avenue P, Gravesend Brooklyn, NY

Whole Milk - .99 to 1.29

Iceberg - 1.29 to 1.49

Bud 12 pack - 9.99

(they don't carry 6 packs)

The surprise is there is more than one choice of iceberg and that they don't carry 6 packs

[5]
Posted by: Nicole
September 24, 2007 - 01:07PM
East Village

East Village - Ave A at 2nd Street

Graceland Market -- Bodega, family owns several locally

Whole Milk - $1.80

Iceberg - $1.80

6-pack Bud - $9.00

Surprised - Yes, it makes me sad that I chose to give my business to a small family-owned bodega, and they are gouging!

[6]
Posted by: mike
September 24, 2007 - 01:15PM
brooklyn, ny

milk - $2.50

head of iceberg - $2.50

Bud - $7.50

Location: Clinton / 4th Place, Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Name: Clinton Deli & Grocery

Type - Korean Deli

Surprised - yes, especially by the lettuce.

[7]
Posted by: Max Brimberg
September 24, 2007 - 01:40PM
Gold and Fulton Street(Manhattan) Wall Street Area

Milk $1.25(sale)

Iceberg lettuce 1.99

Beer 7.49

Associated Market at 77 Fulton Street

The prices are generally high here but sales are ok and seniors get a 10% discount two days a week.

[8]
Posted by: Suzie
September 24, 2007 - 01:51PM
east of Gramercy

Milk - 1.89

Lettuce - none

Beer - 9.50

Korean Deli

2nd Ave & 22nd St.

----

Milk - 1.29

Lettuce - $2.29

Beer - $7.99

Associated Market

23rd St & 2nd Ave

[9]
Posted by: Benita B.
September 24, 2007 - 01:53PM
Greenwich Village

Milk: $1.69

Lettuce: $1.79

6-pack Bud: $7.00 (excl. tax & deposit)

Green East, Korean deli, corner 10 St & 4th Ave

Surprised? Out of this context, yes, but comparing with the others on this site, not at all.

[10]
Posted by: Pamela
September 24, 2007 - 02:01PM
Union Square

MILK - $1.19

BEER - Not Available. Similar brands, PBR 12 pack of 12 ounce cans $6.49 or Corona, 6 pack of 12 ounce bottles $8.99

LETTUCE - $.99 (this was not listed. I had to ask a clerk how much the lettuce cost so this price is not confirmed.)

Store - Whole Foods, Union Square

Surprised - Yes. I didn't think they would have non-organic milk, or iceberg lettuce. However, it did not surprise me that Budweiser was not available.

[11]
Posted by: Lola
September 24, 2007 - 02:27PM
NYC

Nolita/Little Italy?

(where I work, not where I live)

Met Foods, Mulberry & Prince

mini-grocery store

Milk - $4.49 Gallon

(oops, thought the assignment was a gallon)

Lettuce - $1.79 for romaine

no iceberg for sale

Beer - $6.99 for Rolling Rock

no six packs of Bud

I don't drink milk so I was surprised by how much it costs.

[12]
Posted by: Gillian
September 24, 2007 - 02:37PM
Washington Heights

Gristede's

4037 Broadway and 170th st

regular grocery store

milk: $1.39

beer: $6.99

lettuce: $1.99

Surprised? Yes, I would have thought/hoped food would be less expensive in a grocery store in a poor neighborhood.

[13]
Posted by: Marge Feder
September 24, 2007 - 02:56PM
White Plains

D'Agostino's Rye Ridge Shopping Ctr Port Chester milk $1.49

lettuce $1.99

6 pack Bud $6.49

Food Emporium 261 S. Ridge St Port Chester

milk $1.20

Lettuce 1.99

Bud 6.49

[14]
Posted by: Marge
September 24, 2007 - 03:00PM
White Plains

Oops, I copied it incorrectly. The Bud at the Food Emporium was $5.49.

[15]
Posted by: Gretchen Nearon Gonzalez
September 24, 2007 - 03:16PM
Crown Heights..Brooklyn N.Y.

Fine Fare

261 Kingston Avenue

Brooklyn, New York 11213

Milk ( Qt Whole) $1.19

Ice berg Lettuce $1.59

(Don't sell Beer)

Associated SuperMarket

975 Nostrand Ave

Brooklyn, New York 11225

Milk $1.39

Bud Beer $5.69

Iceberg lettuce (cello) $1.79

[16]
Posted by: Chris
September 24, 2007 - 03:43PM
Soho

Milk: $1.09

Lettuce: $1.89

Beer: $9.49

Store: Fairways

Address: 480-500 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn 11231

Neighboorhood: RedhookD

Distinguishing characteristic: high-end retailer

Surprised?: Yes. I thought that the beer price was ridiculous!

BTW - this is a great idea.

[17]
Posted by: Roger
September 24, 2007 - 04:37PM
East Village

Milk: $1.25

Lettuce: $2.49

Beer: $6.29

Store: Food Emporium

Address: 10 Union Sq. at 14th St.

Neighboorhood: Union Square

Distinguishing characteristic: supermarket

Surprised?: No.

[18]
Posted by: Philip Dawson
September 24, 2007 - 04:44PM
Seventh Ave. @ 14th St.

Milk: $1.09

Lettuce: $1.49

Beer: $8.99

WestSide Market

77 Seventh Ave. (@ 15th St.)

high-end retailer

date: 24 Sept. 2007

[19]
Posted by: Roger
September 24, 2007 - 04:46PM
East Village

Milk: $1.43

Lettuce: $1.99

Beer: $6.49

Store: Met Food Market

Address: 107 Second Ave (bet. 6th & 7th St.)

Neighboorhood: East Village

Distinguishing characteristic: local grocery

Surprised?: Yes. Higher than expected.

[20]
Posted by: Jerpy
September 24, 2007 - 05:07PM
NY, NY

Lettuce - $1.99

Budweiser - $9

Milk - $1.69*

6 Ave near Charles St

Arab Bodega

[21]
Posted by: PW
September 24, 2007 - 05:10PM
TX

Milk: $1.74

Iceberg: $.99

Bud: $5.49

Not Manhattan but Texas

HEB

South Adams

Fredericksburg

[22]
Posted by: Theresa
September 24, 2007 - 05:21PM
Fire Island, NY

ShopRite in Bay Shore, NY - from their on-line store. Because of where we live (Fire Island), we have our groceries delivered and normally buy directly from their web site.

Note that beer could not be purchased on-line.

Quart of Whole Milk - $1.03

Iceberg Lettuce - $1.99

[23]
Posted by: i
September 24, 2007 - 05:31PM
Queens

Milk $1.19

Beer $4.99

Lettuce $1.49

Astoria--21 street & Broadway

Associated(medium sized supermarket)

Surprised? Not by my local supermarket b/c I shop there often. I am surprised by how much higher prices are in other neighborhoods.

[24]
Posted by: Judy Keane
September 24, 2007 - 05:44PM
Manhattan

Milk - $1.09

Beer - 6.49

Lettuce - $1.98

Met Foods - Third Avenue & 17th Street

Neighborhood -- Union Square???? Area doesn't really have a name.

Not surprised

Grocery Store

[25]
Posted by: Peter Krass
September 24, 2007 - 05:59PM
Park Slope, Brooklyn

Milk: $1.20

Beer: $5.69 (though hard to find - most of the Bud is sold in 12-packs for $10.99)

Lettuce: $1.69

Location: Key Food grocery store, 7th Ave. between Carroll St. and Garfield Pl., Park Slope, Brooklyn.

[26]
Posted by: Peggy Becker
September 24, 2007 - 06:35PM
Stuyvesant Town, Manhatten

Associated Supermarket

East 14 Street between Ist Ave. & Ave.A

1 quart whole milk $1.19

6pk. Budweiser $6.49

Iceburg lettuce $1.29

No, I was not surprised.

[27]
Posted by: Jennifer
September 24, 2007 - 07:06PM
Long Island City, Queens

Milk: $1.59

Lettuce: $1.99

Budweiser: $7.00

Name: E&I Deli

Location: Long Island City/Vernon Boulevard between 50th and 49th Avenues

Characteristic: Neighborhood bodega, but a bodega that carries a lot of organic food

Surprised: I wish I could say that I am, but I'm well aware that they gouge me daily.

[28]
Posted by: Lori
September 24, 2007 - 07:18PM
Kensington, Brooklyn

Milk $1.39

Lettuce $1.49

Bud beer bottle 6 pack $7.00

E. 7th and Caton

Little corner grocery

[29]
Posted by: Laura Fandino Swedowsky
September 24, 2007 - 08:05PM
Bensonhurst brooklyn

Milk: $1.29

Lettuce: $1.59

6pk Bud 12 oz bottles: $5.79 + deposit

Associated supermarket Ave O at west 7th

Not surprised! I know they are gouging me.

[30]
Posted by: Caitlin
September 24, 2007 - 08:41PM
Sunset Park

Sunset Park - C-Town (8th ave & 45th st)

Milk: 2.42

Lettuce: 1.69

Beer: 5.59

I had no idea what to expect, since I can't remember the last time I bought any of these things. I have no idea why the milk is so pricy!

[31]
Posted by: Peter
September 24, 2007 - 08:41PM
Cobble Hill, Brooklyn

Like Chris (comment #16), I went to the Red Hook, Brooklyn Fairway today. I got different prices though. (It IS a large and complicated store layout..maybe designed to confuse? I found european specialty beers, cold beers and room temperature beers in three completely different parts of the store.)

1 Quart of whole milk - $2.15

1 head of iceberg lettuce - $1.89

6 pack Bud in bottles - $5.49

We both seem to have found the same iceberg lettuce, clearly advertised with a sign above it. I saw a whole range of milk at $2.15 and the $5.49 beers were room temperature and near the registers, aisle 1.

Fairway in Red Hook, Brooklyn

480-500 Van Brunt St.

I wasn't really surprised by the prices, more concerned that I got different results than someone else in the the same store on the same day!

Fun project, though.

[32]
Posted by: Jenny
September 24, 2007 - 08:47PM
181st and Fort Washington Ave, "Hudson Heights"

Smile Deli

east of Fort Washington

( walking towards Broadway)

Milk 1.39

Lettuce 1.59

Beer...no price listed

Jin's Deli

West of Fort Washington

( walking towards Cabrini Blvd )

Milk 1.39

Lettuce 1.99

Beer...no price listed

Jin's being more expensive did not surprise me because as you head west from the subway, a more affluent set resides. Jin's though, is also cleaner, friendlier, fresher, and always has someone speaking English at the counter.

[33]
Posted by: terra
September 24, 2007 - 09:11PM
Columbus, OH

milk $1.49

lettuce $.79

beer $4.99

Found at:

Kroger (standard suburban-style supermarket)

Columbus, OH (43215)

Surprised? A little. I knew rent was cheaper here, but you guys are getting seriously ripped off for beer in NYC!

[34]
Posted by: Fred
September 24, 2007 - 09:51PM
Manhattan

Gristedes - University Place between 8th & 9th

milk: $1.25

lettuce: $1.99

beer: $6.99

D'Agostino - University Place between 10th & 11th

milk: $1.59

lettuce: $2.29

beer: $6.49

I wasn't surprised by these prices.

[35]
Posted by: jorge
September 24, 2007 - 10:25PM
Pompton Lakes, NJ

In NJ, supermarkets do not sell beer, but I was able to get prices on lettuce and Milk from the A&P located at 47 Wanaque Ave, Pompton Lakes, NJ 07442.

Milk: $1.39

Lettuce: $1.69

Beer: N/A

I was surprised by the prices, I thought that the lettuce would be 99 cents and that the milk would be more expensive.

[36]
Posted by: susan
September 25, 2007 - 07:45AM
b'way btw 98-99th (west side)

Iceberg lettuce 1.49

6 pack Budweiser in bottles: 9.50

1 qt. regular milk 1.59

[37]
Posted by: susan
September 25, 2007 - 07:45AM
b'way btw 98-99th (west side)

surprised about the beer, esp. when comparing with others so far

[38]
Posted by: Jey
September 25, 2007 - 08:14AM
South Slope

milk $1.20

lettuce $1.29

Bud $5.69

C-Town

Park Slope 9th st.

[39]
Posted by: Deb Kayman
September 25, 2007 - 09:06AM
Upper West Side

I visited 2 stores, 1 in Kingsbridge (near work) & 1 near home (Upper W Side).

Kingsbridge: Pioneer Supermarket/Caribe Deli (different entrances at same address), 125 W, Kingsbridge Rd., Bronx.

Milk $1.19; lettuce $1.29 (that was the posted price; however, when asked, the cashier told me $1.49); beer (available only at Caribe) $6.00.

Upper West Side: Fairway, 2127 Broadway @ 74th St. Milk $1.09; lettuce $1.89; beer $5.79.

For me, the only surprise was that the price for lettuce was higher at Fairway.

[40]
Posted by: Salvo
September 25, 2007 - 10:06AM
Morningside Heights

@ Morton Williams Supermarket, 2941 Broadway at 115th Street:

Lettuce: $1.89

Milk: $1.29

Beer: $5.99

This store caters mostly to the Columbia University community. The lettuce seemed a bit steep to me, but the milk and beer were what I expected.

[41]
Posted by: Francyne Pelchar
September 25, 2007 - 10:36AM
NYC

Key Foods, general supermarket, Westchester Avenue near terminus of #6 line, Pelham Bay, Bronx

Milk....$1.20

Budweiser Beer.....$5.29

Iceberg Lettuce....$1.99

I never buy iceberg lettuce because it is so tasteless, so I was surprised that it seems rather expensive.

[42]
Posted by: william
September 25, 2007 - 10:38AM
Lower East Side

Milk: $1.19

Head of Romaine Lettuce: $1.29

Six of Bud (12 oz): $4.99

Grand Street. LES, Fine Fare Supermarket (found typically in poor neighborhoods)

[43]
Posted by: Christopher
September 25, 2007 - 10:55AM
Brooklyn, NY

Quart of milk: $1.20

Head of iceberg lettuce: $1.79

Six pack of Bud, 12oz. bottles $5.99

Super Foodtown 1420 Fulton Street, Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn 11216

[44]
Posted by: Laura
September 25, 2007 - 10:55AM
NJ

Quart of (non-organic)Whole Milk: $0.99

Head of IceBerg Lettuce: 1.99

They don't sell alcohol in supermarkets in my town which is Nutley

These prices from:

ShopRite of Nutley

437 Franklin Ave

Nutley, NJ 07110

(It's a REALLY big supermarket, biggest in the area.)

I was surprised that regular milk could be that cheap, I usually buy organic.

[45]
Posted by: Lynn Shaw
September 25, 2007 - 11:01AM
Riverdale, Bronx, N.Y

Key Food (a medium sized chain supermarket) at the corner of 235th St. and Oxford Ave.

1 Qt. Whol Milk $1.29

6-Pack Budweiser Beer, 12oz.bottles$5.69

Head of Iceberg Lettuce $1.99

Couldn't compare prices of iceberg lettuce or Bud.beer, as I don't buy either. Will go to Fairway (where I usually shop) and check prices there.

[46]
Posted by: bernice rotondi
September 25, 2007 - 11:11AM
MANHATTAN

MILK $1.59

BEER $6.49

LETTUCE $2.49

BRIDGEMARKET. FOOD EMPORIUM

60th and 1st Ave. Manhattan

High End Mkt.

Not Surprised

[47]
Posted by: Melissa
September 25, 2007 - 11:49AM
Sunset Park

National Supermarket, 4th Ave b/w 48th & 49th St.

milk: $1.39

lettuce: $1.39

budwiser: $5.69

type: small chain grocery store - recently and nicely renovated

surprised? not really, though the range in beer prices was surprising - 6 pack of 12 oz. brooklyn wiess for $10!

[48]
Posted by: Jill Mont
September 25, 2007 - 12:00PM
Park Slope Brooklyn

Lettuce: $1.99

Beer: $5.69

Milk: $1.20

Pathmark at 13th street and 3rd Ave

(big chain grocery store)

[49]
Posted by: Francyne Pelchar
September 25, 2007 - 12:10PM
NYC

Bodega, Middletown Rd. near Crosby Ave, Pelham Bay Pk. Bronx

6 pack Bud....$6.00

milk.....$1.49

no lettuce or other veg

Korean Veg Mart, Crosby near Westchester Ave.

Milk.....$1.39

Lettuce...$1.29

no beer

Korean Veg Mart, Buhre near Westchester Ave.

Milk...$1.49

Lettuce...$1.39

no beer

Surprised? No, I usually buy my veg at these shops as the veg is cheaper and better quality than the supermarket.

[50]
Posted by: DavidG
September 25, 2007 - 12:16PM
Kennsington, Brooklyn

milk: $1.39 qt.

lettuce: $1.49

6 pk. Budweiser $7.00

good Korean grocery, Caton Ave. near E. 7th St.

[51]
Posted by: carol
September 25, 2007 - 12:44PM
Brooklyn Heights

Iceberg Lettuce: $1.99

Quart Whole Milk: $1.20

6 Pack Bud: $5.99

Not so bad, considering.

Where: Key Food

Montague Street, Bklyn Hgts.

[52]
Posted by: Valerie L.
September 25, 2007 - 12:45PM
Gramercy Park

milk qt. non-organic 1.29

iceberg lettuce - Not available

6-pack Bud 6.79

Associated at 22 St and Park Ave. South

I was surprised that this store, which I always assumed to be way more expensive than most - was actually in the range of most others around...although they definitely are more expensive on other items, and they always have shabby veggies. Met Foods on 3d Ave. and 17th is always more reasonable and fresher.

[53]
Posted by: Philip Dawson
September 25, 2007 - 12:50PM
Seventh Ave. @ 14th St.

Prices at Food Emporium

475 Sixth Ave. (@ 12th St.)

Milk: $1.25

Lettuce $1.49

Beer $6.49

Not surprised

[54]
Posted by: Jennifer Tuttle
September 25, 2007 - 01:03PM
Astoria

Trade Fair Supermarket - Astoria, 30th Ave./31st St. (Open 24/7!)

Milk: $1.09

Lettuce: $.99

Beer: $7.99 for 12-pack

Not surprised, but pleased, by prices - I moved here partly for these kind of prices.

[55]
Posted by: Emily B.
September 25, 2007 - 01:06PM

Food Emporium on 1st Ave. and 71st Street

Milk: $1.39

Lettuce: $2.49

Beer: $6.49

Surprised? Yes, I thought the beer would be more. We lovingly refer to this particular FE location as 'Food Extortion'

[56]
Posted by: Tim B
September 25, 2007 - 01:37PM
Staten Island

Beyer's Market, 2241 Victory Blvd, Staten Island

Milk: $1.39

Lettuce: $1.99

Bud Beer: $5.99

One-off, family owned market that's a little bigger than a standard 7-11 store, with a full deli counter and butcher counter. Surprised the beer is not more and that the milk is not at a loss leader price to match the Pathmark.

Pathmark, 1351 Forest Ave, Staten Island

Milk: $1.20

Lettuce: $1.99

Bud Beer: $5.69

I never get my milk here as it never lasts to the sell-by date.

[57]
Posted by: John Hahn
September 25, 2007 - 01:45PM
NJ

(2) locations in NJ

Pathmark 2200 Maple Ave Fair Lawn NJ 07410

Milk $1.39

Lettuce $1.99

Beer $6.35* Liquor store next to Pathmark run by an Asian man

Food Basic 929 Lincoln Ave, Glen Rock NJ 07452

Milk $1.19

Lettuce. $.88

Beer $5.48

[58]
Posted by: John Hahn
September 25, 2007 - 01:51PM
NJ

NJ Gtrocery stores can sell alcohol. They need to have a Liquor license which is controlled by the community. No law against booze & food.

[59]
Posted by: Linda
September 25, 2007 - 02:43PM
Park Slope, Brooklyn

milk: $1.20

Bud $5.67

Iceberg $1.69

7th Avenue, between Caroll and Garfield Streets

Key Food

Supermarket

[60]
Posted by: kevin
September 25, 2007 - 03:09PM
Chelsea

Kevin

Milk 1.49

Lettuce 1.99

Buds 6.99

Gristede's Mega Mart

8th ave at 22nd street....Chelsea

Not suprized

[61]
Posted by: Michael
September 25, 2007 - 03:11PM
Boerum Hill, Brooklyn

Quart of whole (non-organic) milk: $1.19

a head of iceberg lettuce: $1.59

6 pack of 12oz. bottles of Budweiser: $6.29

Location: Met Food, 197 Smith Street in Boerum Hill, Brooklyn. A medium sized chain supermarket that has been in the neighborhood for 20+ years.

Surprised? a little by the high price for iceberg lettuce and the beer and the low price for milk.

[62]
Posted by: Tomara
September 25, 2007 - 04:51PM
Sunset Park, Brooklyn

iceberg: 1.49/head

bud bottles: 5.49

milk: 3.39

Keyfood Store #432

4320 5th Ave

Bklyn, NY 11232

[63]
Posted by: Tomara
September 25, 2007 - 04:52PM
Sunset Park, Brooklyn

Sorry, the milk should have been 1.99. 3.39 was for a gallon.

Sorry...

[64]
Posted by: Mike O
September 25, 2007 - 04:57PM
Monroe, NY

Qt. whole milk: $1.20

Iceberg lettuce: $1.49

6-pack bottles Bud: $5.29

Location: ShopRite, Route 17M Monroe, NY (Orange Co.)

No surprises.

[65]
Posted by: Spencer
September 25, 2007 - 05:05PM
South Harlem

milk $1.16

lettuce $1.79

Bud $5.99

Associated

96th and Lexington

[66]
Posted by: Eveline
September 25, 2007 - 05:08PM
New York City

D'Agostino

1St Avenue and 53 street

Manhattan

Milk $1.59

lettuce $2.29

Beer 6.49

[67]
Posted by: Jam
September 25, 2007 - 05:11PM
Jackson Heights

milk $1.49

lettuce $1.99

beer$5.99

Trade Fair

76th St/37th Ave

Jackson Heights, Queens

no surprises.

after buying organic for so long,

almost made me want to switch back.

[68]
Posted by: Mark Hardison
September 25, 2007 - 05:26PM
East Village

I'm a 37 yr old male college student. Things are tight, no doubt. I have to ask the question: When a local business, for example,

asks the customer for three dollars for a doughnut.. a doughnut.. people, why is it that

people just pay it.. and of course give a dollar tip on top of that.. it's just a doughnut people.. only $3,000 a month for a studio apartment??.why let me give you $4000.

What I'm saying if we, collectively, refuse to pay it; then perhaps we won't keep being asked to pay such insane prices. It's up to us to create our own change.

Peace,

Mark Hardison

[69]
Posted by: Linda Lawrence
September 25, 2007 - 05:27PM
King Kullen Supermarket,Sunrise Highway,Rockville Centre, Long Island

iceberg lettuce $1.99

6 pk Bud $5.49

Qt whole milk $1.20 in cardboard and $1.30 in plastic.

I was surprised by the difference in price for milk depending on the container

[70]
Posted by: Laura G.
September 25, 2007 - 05:57PM
West Caldwell, NJ

Milk: $1.19

Lettuce: $1.69

Budweiser: N/A (New Jersey)

Name: Whole Foods

Location: 235 Prospect Ave, West Orange, NJ

Characteristic: You know, whole foods!

Surprised: No.

[71]
Posted by: Liz Miller
September 25, 2007 - 06:30PM
Brooklyn

One quart regular milk: $1.09

Iceberg lettuce: $1.89

Six-pack 12 oz. Bud: $5.49

Store: Fairway Market

Location: Van Brunt Street, Red Hook, Brooklyn

Type of store: Large supermarket/regular and high-end

Surprised: yes, given it was Fairway, I thought it would be more expensive

[72]
Posted by: Lucy
September 25, 2007 - 06:46PM
Brooklyn

1 Quart wh. Milk: $1.19

Lettuce: $0.99

6 pack Budweiser can: $5.49

Store: Key Food

Location:120 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11217-3226

Type Of Store:Large Supermarket

I was not really suprised

[73]
Posted by: Susan
September 25, 2007 - 07:19PM
Brooklyn Heights

Iceberg lettuce - $1.99

1 qt. whole milk - $1.20

6-pack Bud (bottles) - $5.99 (on sale, don't know the regular price)

Key Food, Montague St. betw. Hicks & Henry

Also:

Iceberg lettuce - $1.99

1 qt. whole milk - $1.39

6-pack Bud (bottles) - $6.99

Gristede's - Henry St. betw. Pineapple & Clark

Surprised? No, I knew Gristede's would be more.

[74]
Posted by: Smokey Forester
September 25, 2007 - 07:20PM
LES

Milk - $2.59

Iceberg Lettuce - $1.29

6-pack Bud bottles - $6.00

Essex Market

120 Essex Street

New York, NY

Gentrifying Hispanic market

Not surprised

[75]
Posted by: Jim
September 25, 2007 - 08:06PM
Clifton, NJ

Milk: $1.39

Lettuce: $1.99

Budweiser: $5.49

Name: Shop-Rite

Location: 1409 Broad St, Bloomfield, NJ 07003

Characteristic: Middle-class suburban supermarket.

Surprised: By the milk and lettuce, yes, but not by the beer. As mentioned above, NJ laws on alcohol vary by municipality.

[76]
Posted by: m.
September 25, 2007 - 08:30PM
Brooklyn

Milk: $1.39

Lettuce: $0.99

Bud: $5.49

Name: Food Bazaar

Location: 21 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206

Characteristic: Mid-sized supermarket.

Surprised: Yes, compared to the prices below.

---

Milk: $1.29

Lettuce: $1.79

Bud: $5.49

Name: La Famosa

Location: Corner of Broadway and Malcolm X Blvd., Brooklyn, NY 11221

Characteristic: Neighborhood bodega

Surprised: $1.79 for iceberg lettuce?!

[77]
Posted by: JoAnne
September 25, 2007 - 08:30PM
Montclair, NJ

Whole Milk quart - $1.49 (store brand)

Iceberg lettuce head - $1.99

both from Montclair Pathmark Supermarket Bloomfield Avenue at Grove Street.

Budwiser 6 pack of bottles - $6.05

from Romany Liquor Shop 227 Glen Ridge Ave Montclair. (no alcohol in supermarket)

Not surprised as I don't ever buy any of these.

[78]
Posted by: Jane
September 25, 2007 - 09:25PM
Prospect Heights, Brooklyn

Met Food Markets

632 Vanderbilt Avenue

btwn Prospect Place and Park Place

milk - $1.19

lettuce - $1.49

beer - $5.99

Not surprised by the prices, but I was surprised by the quality of iceberg lettuce: every head I picked up was rotten to the point of dripping. (Blech!)

[79]
Posted by: Barbara Anne
September 25, 2007 - 09:37PM
Long Beach, Long Island, NY

whole milk 1 qt. $1.25

iceberg lettuce $1.99

6 pack Bud bottles $5.49

All food has gone up considerably in the last year. It's awful!!

[80]
Posted by: Lori
September 25, 2007 - 09:48PM
Kensington, Brooklyn

Lettuce 1.29

Milk 1.39

Beer 5.79

Golden Farms 24 hour multi-ethnic large fruit-veg grocery

Church Avenue and E. 4th Street

[81]
Posted by: Natasha
September 25, 2007 - 09:58PM
East Village

East Village - 4th St and 2 Ave

East Village Farms Health Food & Grocery -- Bodega, family owned, I believe.

Whole Milk - $1.99

Iceberg - $1.99

6-pack Bud - $8.94 ($1.49 per bottle, didn't see any 6-pack-specific price)

Surprised - Somewhat when compared the prices to some of the other listings here. Expected it to be cheaper than Whole Foods, for example. But this bodega is at a major intersection in the East Village, so no real bewilderment here.

[82]
Posted by: Libby Kessman
September 25, 2007 - 10:03PM
Upper West Side of Manhattan

quart of milk--$1.15

iceberg lettuce--$1.69

no Budweiser beer at this store! (many other kinds, though...)

West Side Market

Broadway and 110th Street

Not surprised, as I shop here frequently and find the prices fair (although I NEVER buy iceberg lettuce!).

[83]
Posted by: joan
September 25, 2007 - 11:03PM
brooklyn - associated mkt. E. 16th and Newkirk

Bud: 5.49

lettuce: 1.59

milk: 1.29

in general I thought these prices were high - but not when I looked at others.

[84]
Posted by: jane stein
September 25, 2007 - 11:23PM
new rochelle, new york

Food Emporium on Quaker Ridge Road New Rochelle

Milk...$1.20

Lettuce....$1.99

Beer.........$5.49 + deposit.

The price of iceberg lettuce surprised me. I remember when it was 49 cents and overpriced at that.

[85]
Posted by: Dorothy
September 25, 2007 - 11:38PM
Trumbull, CT

Milk - $1.59

Iceberg Lettuce - $1.79

6-pk. Bud bottles - $5.99

Trumbull Super Stop & Shop

Trumbull, CT

National supermaret chain

Surprised - thought I'd get better prices than smaller markets and delis in the city. These are comparable and, sometimes, higher. Disappointing.

[86]
Posted by: ileen
September 25, 2007 - 11:41PM
uws

Shim Si grocery - Korean deli 524 Columbus bet 85-86

milk $1.89

lettuce $1.99

beer $7.00

surprised? Yes, since I don't buy iceberg lettuce or beer, and only buy organic milk.

[87]
Posted by: Lis F
September 26, 2007 - 12:52AM
Short Hills, NJ

At Livingston Shop-Rite, Livingston, NJ:

1 quart whole milk: $1.35

same for low fat.

1/2 gallon of both: $2.69

[88]
Posted by: Diana
September 26, 2007 - 09:40AM
Manhattan

Neighborhood: Upper East Side

Gristedes, East End Ave at 81st St., a small supermarket

Whole Milk: $1.59/qt

Lettuce: $1.99

Beer: $6.99

Surprised by the cost of milk, but then it seems to go up every week.

[89]
Posted by: Michael Lavin
September 26, 2007 - 09:44AM
Upper east side at work

Foxy iceberg $3.99 (organic is all they stock)

Milk $1.39

Bud long neck $ 6.49

Food Emporium

Madison 87/88sts.

[90]
Posted by: Rachel
September 26, 2007 - 09:53AM
Upper West Side

Food Emporium on Broadway and 90th Street

Milk: $1.39

Lettuce: 2.49

Beer: $6.49

I was surprised by the milk. I feel like it was just $1.03

[91]
Posted by: Lynn Shaw
September 26, 2007 - 10:56AM
Riverdale, Bronx, N.Y

Fairway, 125th off Henry Hudson Pkwy.

1 Qt Whole Milk $1.09

Iceberg Lettuce $1.89

Budweiser 12oz. bottles (18 Pack) $14.99

(didn't have 6-packs)

Was surprised to find prices lower than at my neighborhood supermarket (which I checked out the day before). A checkout clerk told me that Firway's milk is the cheapest in the city.

[92]
Posted by: bk
September 26, 2007 - 10:57AM
nyc

milk - 1.50

lettuce - 2.29

bud beer - 10.99

D'agastino on Lexington b'twn 35th st. & 36th st

I was shocked.

Then went to my local Gourmet Garage on the corner or Mercer & Broome in Soho

1 milk 1.29

1 ice lettuce 1.50

beer - no bud but premium beer starts at 10.99

[93]
Posted by: Rachael
September 26, 2007 - 10:59AM
Park Slope, Brooklyn

@ Associated, on 5th Ave. btw Union St. and President St. in Park Slope:

- 1 qt milk = 1.19

- 1 head iceberg lettuce = 1.69

- no beer sold here

I buy just about everything but my produce (and beer) here. I'm surprised the iceberg lettuce costs so much, and I'm surprised how much the cost of milk has gone up. It can't have been too long ago (within the past year?) that I was buying 1 qt milk at Associated for 85 cents.

[94]
Posted by: Kale
September 26, 2007 - 11:01AM
NYC

Price for a six pack of Bud in cans:

6 X $6.75 = $40.50 !

This is at Shea Stadium. At least they open it for you.

Surprised? Not if the Bullpen is strong. Lately though the price is getting a bit surprising, yes.

[95]
Posted by: justin
September 26, 2007 - 11:28AM
Manhattan

As much as I would like to state that there maybe price gouging I am also forced to state that depending on the location one is likely to find that the Retail outlets pay different rents. Thus the costs to the Retailer are going to be different and thus I am not sure if there is a fairness in stating that it is price gouging.

[96]
Posted by: Miriam Winocour
September 26, 2007 - 11:30AM
Morningside Heights

Westside Market (110th & Bway)

Milk $1.15

Iceberg $1.69

6-pack Budweiser $7.14

D'Agostino (110th & Bway)

Milk $1.49

Iceberg $1.59

6-pack Budweiser $6.49

[97]
Posted by: Jenn
September 26, 2007 - 11:32AM
South Bound Brook NJ

Milk: $1.69

Lettuce: $0.99 on sale, reg.$1.99

This is from a Shop Rite in Bound Brook NJ.

Recently, I was shocked to find a price difference of $0.70 in a gallon of milk sold there and at a Shop Rite in Hillsborough, 15 minutes away.

[98]
Posted by: Laura
September 26, 2007 - 11:33AM
Manhattan - 26th between Broadway & 6th

I shop three different places:

Whole Food in Chelsea

CVS on 25th & 6th

Fresh Direct (internet)

These three prices are from Fresh Direct:

Whole Milk = $1.19

Iceberg Lettuce = $1.99

Budweiser Beer/6 pack = $6.49

I however routinely buy enriched non fat milk, more expensive types of lettuce, and non-domestic beer.

I was not surprised by the Fresh Direct prices.

[99]
Posted by: LIz
September 26, 2007 - 11:38AM
Lower Manhattan

Food Emporium, Greenwich St, Tribeca

Milk - $1.20

Iceberg Lettuce - $2.49

6 pack Bud - $6.49

I'm not surprised that the food emporium is right up there for high prices (except for milk, which seems low, as it should be, since it goes bad about three days after you buy it).

[100]
Posted by: al x
September 26, 2007 - 12:02PM

A & P 87 Main St.

Hastings-on-Hudson

Milk: $ 1.20

iceberg: $ 1.99

beer: $ 5.49

no surprises here

This thread is closed.


1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next | Back to Episode

Web tools supported by
Print friendly format
supported by
Listen Live
FM 93.9 Windows 20k
MP3 32k
On Air: Jonathan Schwartz - The Sunday Show

Due to contractual obligations, Jonathan Schwartz - The Sunday Show is not available on our audio stream.

AM 820 Windows 20k
MP3 32k
On Air: A Prairie Home Companion
Shopping Online?
Start your Amazon shopping on WNYC.org and a portion of your total purchase goes to WNYC.


Audio Search

Search current and archival WNYC broadcasts. More

In The Spotlight
YOU PRODUCE The Brian Lehrer Show
Be a listener-producer with facts, questions and people you'd like to hear on the air.
More
The Brian Lehrer Show Scrapbook
Visit the scrapbook for daily photos and miscellany from The Brian Lehrer Show.
More
Shop at Amazon!
The Brian Lehrer Show picks
Start your Amazon shopping on WNYC.org and a portion of your total purchase goes to WNYC.
More
Most Emailed