Streams

Context and a TV Show: Homeland

Friday, November 23, 2012

Every so often, we pick a popular movie, play, or TV show and talk about the real-life context. Today: Showtime's "Homeland."

Bob Baer, the Intelligence Columnist for TIME Magazine and 21-year veteran of the CIA, talks about what "Homeland" gets right and what it says about counter-terrorism. Then, June Thomas, a culture critic for Slate and host of the new Slate podcast The Afterword, discusses what the show says about the evolution of spy thrillers after 9/11.

Seven Fact-Checks on Homeland from Ex-CIA Agent Bob Baer

1. In response to a clip from the show about surveillance on Sergeant Brody's home and family, Baer pointed out that the CIA doesn't conduct surveillance inside the United States. The FBI does.

2. There's a lot of focus on the motivations of Abu Nazir, the Osama bin Laden character on Homeland. There's more psychological profiling on TV, Baer said. Intelligence officers wouldn't focus so much on the subtle motivations of terrorists, but rather focus more on locating terrorists and getting information from them.

3. The Homeland crew is a little more efficient than the real-life CIA. The intelligence community receives an overwhelming about of surveillance data. Even with many agents working on it, it is sometimes difficult to find the dots and figure out how they connect.

4. It is reasonable that agents would suffer a form of PTSD like those on the show. Carrie probably would feel guilt and a desperate need to avoid another event like 9/11.

5. Hollywood often creates the illusion that torture works. In reality this is unclear.

6. As in the show, the CIA interviews would-be suicide bombers whose vests didn't explode, and has found that suicide bombers in fact have a range of motives and sometimes aren't clear on their targets.

7. It's less sexy in real life. Like many of us, a CIA agent might actually spend most of her day writing reports in the office. 

Guests:

Bob Baer and June Thomas

Comments [3]

Lenore from Manhattan

I think it's time to retire bob Baer from the show. He whitewashes the CIA and I at least find it hard to take him seriously.

"Drones? What drones? Nobody cares about them"--thus bob Baer.

Nov. 23 2012 11:00 AM
paulina from South Plainfiled

What bothered me was the episode when Brody send text message to worn Abu Nazir about his association.
Would he, as possible running mate for presidency, be allowed in the CIA room? And would he be able to send text messages from that roo?

Nov. 23 2012 10:50 AM
jgarbuz from Queens

I've never seen "Homeland" as I do not have cable and don't get HBO. However I have seen the Israeli version called "Prisoners"(Hatufim in Hebrew) on Hulu, and it is a great TV series. I don't know which came first, the US or Israeli version, but I recommend everyone to see "Prisoners" on Hulu if they can. In the ISraeli case it is about 3 who return after 7 horrible years in Syrian captivity.

Nov. 23 2012 10:49 AM

Leave a Comment

Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more. Learn more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting. By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.