Angelo Falcón, president and founder of the National Institute for Latino Policy, discusses how Rick Santorum and Mitt Romney have been campaigning for Puerto Rican votes ahead of the GOP primary on Sunday. 23 delegates are at stake.
Regarding legislating an "official language":
If the United States were to pass a law making English the official language, the negative consequences could be significant. Here's the short list:
> Might it, for example, require all evidence in court to be submitted only as a translation instead of in the original language with translation suggested or attached? Think of the consequences of a bad translation on jury deliberations.
> Non-English speakers (citizens and "aliens") and those who do not have a good working knowledge of English might no longer receive documents, like Social Security statements, in their native language. Misunderstandings and complications would abound.
> Would government agencies and other civil institutions be banned from providing language translation services to clients?
> Puerto Rico would not be able to enter the Union, and probably the function of the Commonwealth's government would suffer. This would create much frustration and possibly encourage vigorous anti-United States sentiment.
We are a multilingual country, even though the one language that unites us is English. However, it's time to look at English as a language that may unify the world in commerce and diplomacy, but we should not consider it the only valid language, especially with growing multilingualism in this country and worldwide — including in Puerto Rico. To do so encourages self-righteous nationalism, a bad thing.
People speak what they speak.It's called freedom.Santorum shows a lack of understanding about human freedom as do politicisns who pass laws mandating knowledge of english as a condition for citizenship.This arrogance and hubris of telling puerto ricans they need to learn english to be considered for statehood is akin to the arrogance of anglos getting in a huff when the french in france speak french even in the presence of anglos.how dare they!
WAR WITHOUT END!
TERRORIST homes used to be blown up, by the British in the 1930s and by the Israelis until some years ago. I've never seen an Arab or anyone starving in ISrael. More people starve in the US than in Israel. You are just spouting a pack of lies. SOrry. that's just a fact.
Sheldon from Brooklyn~
Psychotic disassociation can be VERY scary.
Not anti semitic, just tired of you making every segment about Israel. We could be talking about grass and trees and you will find a way to speak about Israel.
Love Jews and Israel, tired of you.
if PUERTO RICANS in New York or Puerto RIco were firing rockets or sending their children with bombs strapped to them to blow up shopping malls, we'd see how loving and kind the AMerican response would be. If anything, Israel has been too generous and kind to its enemies. I know. I lived in Beersheba for many years, and my ex-mother in law delived 10,000 Arab babies in Soroka hospital, the first hospital the Bedouins ever knew in 3000 years in the desert of the Negev.
The Puerto Ricans are not starved, shot and BULLDOZED to DEATH.
Not even close to being similar subjects.
Please GET A CLUE!!!
No, jaggerbuttz, our issue is with PSYCHOTICS and Israel.
Just to be clear my sarcasm was directed to the US's convoluted relationship with PR NOT the ABHORRENT state of APARTHEID that Israel BRUTALLY subjects the Palestinians to EVREY SINGLE DAY!!
To John and Dboy
No, Jews and Israel are my main issues, and your primary issues are DENIGRATING and attacking Jews and Israel, so I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree. In this case I was pointing out the hypocrisy, and showing that Puerto Rico and Palestine are very similar issues, only most Americans don't realize it. Puerto Rico came under US rule due to the Spanish American war. The West Bank and Gaza came under ISraeli rule due to the 1967 war. What to do with them has been a major issue ever since. I might add, that I know many Americans who have settled in Puerto Rico :) I guess they are "settlers" too.
... yet another psychotic episode.
jaggerbuttz the pedantic.
geezus, no sh*t.
1579, from L.L. sarcasmos, from Gk. sarkasmos "a sneer, jest, taunt, mockery," from sarkazein "to speak bitterly, sneer," lit. "to strip off the flesh," from sarx (gen. sarkos) "flesh," prop. "piece of meat," from PIE base *twerk- "to cut" (cf. Avestan thwares "to cut"). Sarcastic is from 1695. For nuances of usage.
JG - to equate what dboy said with blood libel is scary.
jgarbuz from Queens Jesus Christ! get another issue please
so many myths about PR....first off, lumping all latinos into one category is such a huge mistake for both parties...."the latino vote" is like saying "the white vote". one example- puerto ricans don't care about the immigration issue as they're already citizens. in fact, they're pretty conservative about illegal immigration.
In watching Santorum's comments, it appeared he believes that the English language requirement for statehood is already in place. You would think that as a long time member of Congress he would know the law, but apparently he has succumbed to getting his "facts" only from conservative talk media, who either fulminate for effect or are just ignorant )like the ditzes who host the FOX morning show).
That accusation is a BLOOD LIBEL! There is no "apartheid" in Israel. To say that there is apartheid in Israel is to say there is apartheid in America because Puerto Ricans have a separate commonwealth. There is no diffence between Puerto Rico and Palestine. Both can elect their own leaders,and both can become independent as long as they don;'t threaten the US, or Israel respectively. IF Puerto Rico was allowed to have Iranian missiles on Puerto Rican soil pointed at the US, we might not allow it to become independent either.
Greg - DC is fine the way it is.
As a gringo homeowner in Puerto Rico, I know how seriously Puerto Ricans take election.It's a HUGE deal down there, you can't drive anywhere without a parade, big speakers on trucks going up and down the streets, horse and cart parades etc..
A common language makes for a common culture, or country, or people. No way around that.
What about Washington DC? More residents than Wyoming, but not represented by Senators or Congressmen. Talk about taxation without representation! I agree Puerto Rico should become a state- its time to clean up our relationship with the "special' situations like PR, DC and Indian nations...
Santorum has proven yet again why he should never come within 20 feet of our suitcase of nuclear codes.
It's really quite elemental; Israel should CEASE the ABHORRENT state of APARTHEID it maintains!!!
It's NOT rocket science.
Truth & Beauty from Brooklyn
Because he then will emerge as what he is, a big pile of Boo Boo
I thought you knew everything? Puerto Rico was taken by the US from Spain in 1899, and was ruled as a colony until 1954 when Puerto Ricans were allowed to elect their own governors. They were given a made-up status called "Commonwealth," something that does not exist in the US Constitution. They do have the right to decide to become independent, or apply to become a state, or to remain in this ambiguous semi-autonomous status. They are technically American citizens, but cannot vote for Congress or the Presidency, unless they come to live on the mainland. They get US social security and welfare, and can serve in the US military, but are not full citizens while living in Puerto Rico, because of the voting restrictions I mentioned. So that's basically it.
John from Office:
Santorum is indeed a dangerous guy, but with the premise that "you are what you eat," why would you want to subject the unwitting denizens of Puerto Rico to the possibility of eating him?
Santoum is an IDIOT!!
There are so many countries with more than one recognized language (i.e., India, which has 25 official languages), that having one state or territory of the US that is predominantly Spanish-speaking should not be unthinkable. I think that Puertoriquenos probably learn English in school anyway, so what is the problem?
CHANGO, CHANGO CHANGO!!
What do Puerto Ricans think about the Palestinian issue? Should Palestine become part of Israel, or should it become a separate state, or should it remain like Puerto Rico, somewhere in-between?
the vast majority of puerto ricans don't want statehood. and santorum's words concerning language are just ridiculous. spanish is the language of the people of PR. PR was acquired during a dubious war and the people never asked for this- they were forced into submission.
It's time for Puerto Rico to either choose to become a State or be independent. This grey area does Puerto Rico no good.
Can someone, PLEASE explain our relationship with PR???
It's NOT a state, right?? A sovereign country...no??
The language Rick Santorum used to describe his understanding of language issues in PR was disgraceful.
I wish people would stop conflating Puerto Ricans and the Spanish Speaking immigrants in this country. They ARE NOT one in the same and Mexicans are much different people. It is unfair to mix the two, we share a language but we are not the same.
I am using Santaria on Santorum. Wishing him the best of luck. Chango is being invoked! Que viva Chango Que viva Chango
I had hoped that Santorum would not return form PR, he would have made a good lechon or maybe filling for pastelles. Instead, he returns much like Hitler in 31. He is a dangerous guy.
I wondered, do puerto ricans care we on the mainland treat other hispanics who immigrate to the US
Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm
your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the
right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the
Comment Guidelines before
By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's
It's your neighborhood, your city, your country, your world, and now your website. Brian Lehrer delves into the issues and links them to real life.