Maia Szalavitz, neuroscience journalist and contributor to Time magazine's Healthland blog, discusses some of the research examining the connection between marijuana use and psychosis.
RE: Schizophrenia and marijuana
There are two people who are close to me who have schizophrenia. Both had smoked alot of pot but chose not to continue smoking after their diagnosis – mostly because of the negative effects on their mental state (ie, they no longer enjoyed it because their delusions became more prominent and/or disturbing). I would not blame pot for causing their illnesses, however I believe that it could have contributed to their initial "breakdowns". I have nothing against pot (so back down, people who get defensive about it). I just believe that if you have certain genes that make you more susceptible to mental illness (as both people I know have family histories with mental illness) – it might be wise to steer clear of (or limit) drugs. Drugs mixed with impressionable chemistry seems too risky to me.
**Brian, you should do a program on schizophrenia: What is schizophrenia and what it is like for an individual and their families/friends.
There's a debilitating amount misinformation and social stigma surrounding this illness.
NOT ALL schizophrenics are violent.Not all schizophrenics continue drug use.
With early detection and the right treatment, many people with schizophrenia do not have to suffer and have a chance to lead healthy lives. Unfortunately, people with this illness are often unaware of their behavior or hide it due to confusion and shame. Those close to them are just as confused and sometimes in denial. Left untreated, symptoms can definitely get worse. In some cases, it can lead to the person slipping into a catatonic state. Some can lead to the violent/disturbing episodes that make the news headlines.
Educating people would help parents/friends detect early symptoms - this can often be crucial to how well individuals will respond to treatment. It would give the public a better understanding of the illness, families and friends the courage to seek assistance and those that suffer from it a chance to lead healthy, productive lives.
Ms. Szalavitz is so wrong about the addictive potential of marijuana. She said that the drug doesn't cause physical symptoms when stopped, like heroin. Well, just because it doesn't cause physical withdrawal effects upon terminating the drug, that doesn't mean that it isn't additive. There are different types of additction, including physical addiction, psychological addiction, habituation, and compulsive drug use. Marijuana has been associated with psychological addicition and habituation, and is known to alter brain chemistry.
schizophrenia should not be the determinant marker. a diagnosis is such a subjective individual thing based on empirical observation exclusively. not to mention how many people never ever go to shrinks.
err.. I mean LSD
Two words to refute this ridiculous claim: Louis Armstrong.
I'm no scientist, but reefer seems too soft to cause a breakdown in someone prone to psychosis.
I'm betting this kid also used LCD or other hallucinatory drugs.
drugs should be legal,human beings should be treated with dignity, not as crimminals. however,i don't feel i need to say, that pot is perfectly harmless, to bolster my case. i don't think it is harmless. i end up being the lefty, left out of the party on this issue. there is too much 60's romance around reefer,and, i think people feel, they have to say that pot is okay, in order to bolster their contrarian views to the [very insane] drug policies in our country. why can't we parce reality, in, a much more sane, sensible, and nuanced manner? drug policies stink [and],pot damages brain cells and does induce horrible anxiety/paranoia in some.
Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm
your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the
right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the
Comment Guidelines before
By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's
It's your neighborhood, your city, your country, your world, and now your website. Brian Lehrer delves into the issues and links them to real life.