Anna Lappé, blogger and author of Diet for a Hot Planet, talks about the possible renaming of high fructose corn syrup and takes your calls on suggestions for the new name. Author, blogger and NYU professor Marion Nestle weighs in.
Butch, short for butcher -- first it fattens you up, then it kills you.
(Sorry for the late reply - I caught the late-night encore presentation)
I refer to it as "overprocessed subsidized corn byproduct sugar substitute", but I think it'll end up labeled as "artificial sweetener" - here's why:
 It *is* artificial (man-/machine-made) It *is* used as a sweetener It's a generic label that doesn't faze the public It takes less ink to print than "high fructose corn syrup" And it's better branding than "sugar substitute"
If the goal is to reduce its consumption then either leave it as "high fructose corn syrup" or call it by its chemical compound nomenclature. A rose by any other name would smell as sweet, but saccharin by the name "1,1-Dioxo-1,2-benzothiazol-3-one" leaves a bad taste.
(Of course, if companies really want to increase sales, they would have made their products with "all-natural" sugar from sugar cane in the first place)
One of the callers said "high fructose corn syrup" isn't high in sugar - that's incorrect. It does have a higher percentage of fructose and there are respected studies indicating that our bodies do not absorb HFCS like natural sugar because of this. I
HFCS also tricks your homones to believe that you're hungry when you are likely satisfied.
HFCS has been found to contain mercury.
The bottom line is that HFCS MIGHT not be terribly damaging in minimal amounts but that's difficult for the average consumer to achieve since HFCS is everywhere. To JT's point above, if corn weren't subsidized, it wouldn't be so cheap and food manufacturers wouldn't use it so freely.
I think this is actually a wonderful opportunity to talk about HFCS, and educate consumers on healthy options.
SUGAR3 (as in “sugar cubed”)
(Can't do the superscript but you get the idea)
I see they are considering fructinose also. So... here's take 3: Fructinase
I liked the suggestion "frucrup" (based on "fruc[tose sy]rup") from one of the callers, but I'd divide the words differently: "fructup." Yes, the rhyme is deliberate.
Here's the Center for Science in the Public Interest's take on it: "Proposed Name Change For High-Fructose Corn Syrup Still Misleading" (http://cspinet.org/new/201009151.html).
And I agree w/anonyme that we need to counter the casting of healthy eating as a "lifestyle" rather than a health issue. Also the portrayal of healthy foods as tasting bad!
On the other hand, some of the commenters seem to be confusing the health effects of sugar w/those of fat. Maybe we need a segment on the differences.
war machine chemical grown, gmo, diabetes-promoting, monoculture poison.
But rather than grousing about our victimhood, resolve to buy viable food directly from farmers and learn to cook. Children deserve nothing less and here's a great great talk about those involved in "slow money" organic agriculture, and bringing it even to a wal-mart near you. (It's NOT elitist!!! You feed the corn growers who won't convert to organic by saying "organic's elitist" This is a wonderful hopeful concrete keynote: http://www.midhudsonmedia.com/clients/slowmoney/gary-hirshberg.htm
they shouldn't be allowed to change the name unless they are changing the product. It's like changing the word murder because now it's hard to get a job. That is crazy talk.
Love what Laura from New Canaan, CT wrote:
"C.R.A.P. - corn repurposed as poison"
This is simply a marketing technique to bamboozle the public. The industry should not be allowed to change it.
Why does WNYC keep using Marion Nestle as its source? She constantly misinforms.
For more on why HFCS is different from sucrose (table sugar) and a significant contributor to high rates of Type II Diabetes read this link:
Mr. Patterson from Brokklyn-very very funny.
Estelle, ding ding ding.
Sadly, that may well be a major cause of the all the obesity and early Type II diabetes in kids.
Will the Big Ag Corporate powers win this battle? Or will science be allowed to conitnue to study just what HFCS is doing to us and our children?
Read these Princeton studies. Changed my approach to food buying. Better safe than sorry. And I've had to give up some manufactured foods I really enjoy, but, hey....
Call it Corn Sweetend Syrup-CSS
Corn-hole-lots-of-fungus! Yeah, Mommie, choosie muthas choose it!
Have to retract Fructasia as I see it's really being considered. (Go figure.)
Let's call it Frutisol.
The problem with high fructose corn syrup is that it is NOT ABSORBED by the body and stays there crystalized!
while many of your listeners are right that we consume too many sweets, that point takes the conversation away from the real problem
The new name for high fructose corn syrup should be lowfat corn oil.
refined corn sugar
They can call it anything they want. It still won't get me to eat it, or any other sugar of any kind. I have not eaten any sugar at all, except fresh fruit, for the last 18 months. So take that Monsanto and ADM.
How about calling high fructose corn syrup as "Kid Killa?"
We have a HFCS ringer or stooge or sadly gullible consumer in Marion. eh?
Please read the Princeton studies comparing HFCS to actual sugar.
They are not the same to the rats being studied. Nor, it appears, to human bodies.
I am not eating any more HFCS.
Please ask the guest if pseudonyms are already being used on food labels.
I know what corn syrup is, but are labelers using that name to cover their use of HFCS?
For several years now in our house we refer to it as "Crack." As with creamer, we often say, "Honey, what would you like in your coffee, milk or crack?"
sweet & high
High Fructose Corn Syrup Mellencamp
thumbs up to gilda from manhattan.
Sweet Corn Juice
Compound 1984, as in George Orwell...
Highly fattening sugar syrup
if sugar = white deathhfcs = yellow death
Can we speak to that article in the Times? What gives....it read exactly like propaganda.
High Metabolic Syndrome Syrup
High Fructose Death Syrup
"corn handles" since this stuff ends up on your waist
You probably can't say this on the air but I think it should be "Huge Fat Ass Corn Syrup"
1. Corn Jelly2. Fortified Corn Kernel Extract3. Other Sugars
I seem to remember when FDA-required nutrition facts on food labels listed
The point is not whether the artist formerly known as HFCS is healthy or unhealthy. The point is that it's in EVERYTHING.
As "autolyzed yeast" is used as a replacement for MSG in processed foods (referencing how it is produced)...
"Enzyme-converted starch" based on the process that is used to create it.
Colonel Sugar, the animated spokesman.
Sweet and Really Low
Meant to say: Freedom Nectar
Zea Mays Based Sweetener
Sure Sugar. ("sure yeah, this is sugar...")
Colestra - or brand name: Colean
(for those consumers who remember the fun-to -impugn fat substitute Olestra - brand name Olean)
sap formerly known as high fructose corn syrup
how about PTD (pathway to diease)or RCC (really cheap crap) or GMP (genertically modified poison)
Liquid Maizeulose: "Why resist? It's in everything you eat!"
It should be called Corn Krack made from cracked corn! Can't remember where I saw the graphs, but remembered seeing graphs that showed the parallel relationship between HFCS usage, US obesity rates along with US Type II diabetes rates..... a very significant and strong correlation; ergo Corn Krack- America's unforgiving addiction.
SuSuSy for Super Sugar Syrup.
"Amaizin" could be a new name for high fructose corn syrup. "Maize" is another word for corn. Saying there is "a bit of maize in this product" can be shortened to "Amaizin".
Setebaid™, (diabetes spelled backwards)
"Sweet poison" - it will never be used by the industry but that is essentially what it is
What's the point in changing the name. High Fructose Corn Syrup Sucks so... don't use it!Use real juice as a sweetener. Think about doing the right thing.
C.R.A.P. - corn repurposed as poison
(etymology: mon from French = mine, + santo from Latin = health)
How 'bout CORN TAR or MAIZE HONEY.
Personally I prefer Corn Tar but it might wind-up another pr problem.
"I Can't Believe It's Not Sugar!"....... (lol)
i knew we could count on wnyc's wonderful audience to call it as it is as far as opinions on what high-fructose corn syrup is....
but I want to comment that this effort here by you, Brian, and your producers, is an absolutely classic example of trying to make consumers & audiences work for free (which so much corporate 'outreach' to audiences, especially via the internet, consists of). Efforts to build audiences by making them feel important & part of a 'family" by responding to a request from the radio host is more free labor social-media style and is a sign that every show on wnyc wants to be the Takeaway (yuck!) And here I am, doing it! Seductive!
High Fructose Obesity SauceObesity SyrupCheap Fat Corn Sugar
Type 2 Diabetes Inducer - which when abbreviated takes on a certain Stars Wars sound - tee 2 dee eye
how about "mis-sugar" and slogan- you have to be meshuggah to eat it!!!!
Sweet Killer or Sweet Poison or Sweet Death
May I ask why are you helping the industry re-brand such a harmful and easily replaceable sweetener? The problem with HFCS is not the image, but the reality.
obesity elixer, diabetes drink, high mortaility corn sugar
cheap sticky child fattening yuck
Corporate SugarHigh Profit SugarIndustrial Complex SugarRonald Reagan Sugar
Cancer Candy! YUM!!!
How about "Submit To Corn, Your Overlord"
"Happy Juice by Archer Daniels Midland"
"Hi. We're from the government. We're here to make your food tasty!"
Sweet Subsidy Jelly
New name for High Fructose Corn Syrup:
How about Highly Subsidized Corn Syrup?
The Devil. that's what I've called it for years.
Let's rename HFCS the "Silent Killer"
PSwhy is the industry aloud to change the name of this product. sounds like bait and switch to me, just when people are learning the dangers of HFCS.
Corn Fructose Unhealthy Clogging Killer -- the acronym is particularly apt...
How about "Diabetes Starter"?
government liquid sugar
survial of the fittest juice
Sweet Juice of Death
The Evil Elixir.
Rotnfat. (rots your teeth, makes you fat)
Subsyr. (because its a subsidized syrup)
How about SFP (sweetfattypoison)?
the whole high fructose corn syrup things makes me angry. we subsidies corn farmers so this crap is so damn cheap they put it in everything. And its processed like crazy. you wanna call normal corn syrup "corn sugars", fine. it's misleading since it's a syrup, so why not just call it syrup. my major problem is with the over processed "high fructose" type that has it's glucose turned into fructose. i'm sure 90% of americans consume way to much of this stuff and don't even realize how many things its in.
How about "fat, fat, fatty, fat sugar"?
HAPPY FUN CORN SUGAR
GO SUGAR !
Why does HFCS exist?
Governments give subsidies to corn farmers to produce more corn than we need. We end creating products like this just use the corn and then complain about how unhealthy the results are. Why doesn't the government cut the subsidies? It should be easy to pass when budgets have to be cut.Taxing soda makes no sense when we subsidize the people that make cheap drinks possible.
Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm
your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the
right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the
Comment Guidelines before
By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's
It's your neighborhood, your city, your country, your world, and now your website. Brian Lehrer delves into the issues and links them to real life.