if people don't want to be deployed don't join up. duh so tied of that lame song 0 compassion for that perspective
gee i think i'll buy a house with no money down
born on the left moving to the right democracy is a snake eating its tail the people are not fit to rule themselves
Support Barack Support the Troops !
Mar. 05 2009 12:04 PM
Score: 0/0
John-Paul G
from Elizabeth, NJ
Could we have those links discussed put up? I'm hoping to check some before the show is archived. Thank you
Mar. 05 2009 12:01 PM
Score: 0/0
the truth
from Atlanta/New York
Caller, sympathies, but your son is over there under bush, that is a question should have asked bush after your sons 2nd tour.
Mar. 05 2009 11:53 AM
Score: 0/0
Brian Lehrer Show Producer
from Varick St.
[[BL Moderator Writes: This is an early reminder to keep your comments relevant to the discussion taking place on the air. This is a segment about the Obama administration's plan to draw troops down from Iraq. Thank you. -BL Show-]]
Mar. 05 2009 11:52 AM
Score: 0/0
Alex
from Queens
As a former US Army Air Defense Artillery officer who served in Iraq in 2003, I can say that the verteran NEEDS to take care of his own business first. The returning soldier needs to be proactive and not wait for things to come to them. They can not let paper work and other types of obstacles delay their progression.
Mar. 05 2009 11:51 AM
Score: 0/0
billbad
from NYC
ok that is pretty much a lie, Isreal continues, right now, this very day, to take more land, in violation of the Geneva convention and U.N. resolutions but you don't want to talk about that do you, just keep taking land for illegal settlements. You don't want to talk about how the stern gang massacred palestine ciillians in thier homes do you, or what teh Haggana did, and how to date there has not been one single cent paid to those people to compensate them for the loss of their lands, livelihood and lives. You don't want to talk about how Neten-yahoo does not want a two state solution and embraces open discrimation against arabs who hold Isreali citzenship. Isreal is the new South Africa. But yo don't want to talk about that, you want to say that palestines are bad because they did not protest against Saddam, well so what, neither did Americans. You are so intellectually dishonest its not even funny. One has nothing to do with the other. I don't see Isreal protesting against China over Tibet, so by your "logic" therefore Isreal is far worse. what bunk.
Mar. 05 2009 11:47 AM
Score: 0/0
Robert
What exactly are "non-combat troops"? Is there such a thing?
Mar. 05 2009 11:42 AM
Score: 0/0
Peter
from Sunset Park
The Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America Web site offers some refreshingly frank and salient points about the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. In a recent article posted on the site, Leslie H. Gelb writes:
“But let’s stop kidding ourselves: No sane leaders anywhere in the world would trust their security to the word of people who are publicly committed to their destruction and who have actually been trying to destroy them for half a century. Palestinians and Arabs will have to understand that they must make some serious concessions on security matters and on verification in order to give Israelis the necessary confidence to establish the two-state solution they desire.”
Gelb adds:
“Arab leaders committed far greater atrocities on Arab people than the Israelis ever committed upon the Palestinians. Who among them condemned Saddam Hussein’s atrocities over the years? Which of their leaders has raised the alarms about the most serious human-rights violations in Iran? And who among these Arab humanitarians have condemned the horrible treatment of women in so many Muslim societies? The daily treatment of women throughout a good deal of the Arab world is far worse than the Israeli treatment of Palestinians. The Israelis are no angels in how they treat the Palestinians, but their record is far, far better than how most Arab leaders treat their own people.”
Please ask Mr. Rieckhoff to weigh in on this topic. Why are these views important for American veterans and his organization? Does this position impact American's role in regional conflicts such as Iraq as well as in covert ops most surely going on in Iran and other countries?
I wonder if this post is sufficiently liberal for WNYC? We shall see.
Mar. 05 2009 08:53 AM
Score: 0/0
Leave a Comment
Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more.
Learn more. Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm
your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the
right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the
Comment Guidelines before
posting.
By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's
Privacy Policy and
Terms Of Use.
Comments [8]
if people don't want to be deployed
don't join up. duh
so tied of that lame song
0 compassion for that perspective
gee i think i'll buy a house with no money down
born on the left moving to the right
democracy is a snake eating its tail
the people are not fit to rule themselves
Support Barack
Support the Troops !
Could we have those links discussed put up? I'm hoping to check some before the show is archived.
Thank you
Caller, sympathies, but your son is over there under bush, that is a question should have asked bush after your sons 2nd tour.
[[BL Moderator Writes:
This is an early reminder to keep your comments relevant to the discussion taking place on the air. This is a segment about the Obama administration's plan to draw troops down from Iraq. Thank you.
-BL Show-]]
As a former US Army Air Defense Artillery officer who served in Iraq in 2003, I can say that the verteran NEEDS to take care of his own business first. The returning soldier needs to be proactive and not wait for things to come to them. They can not let paper work and other types of obstacles delay their progression.
ok that is pretty much a lie, Isreal continues, right now, this very day, to take more land, in violation of the Geneva convention and U.N. resolutions but you don't want to talk about that do you, just keep taking land for illegal settlements. You don't want to talk about how the stern gang massacred palestine ciillians in thier homes do you, or what teh Haggana did, and how to date there has not been one single cent paid to those people to compensate them for the loss of their lands, livelihood and lives. You don't want to talk about how Neten-yahoo does not want a two state solution and embraces open discrimation against arabs who hold Isreali citzenship. Isreal is the new South Africa. But yo don't want to talk about that, you want to say that palestines are bad because they did not protest against Saddam, well so what, neither did Americans. You are so intellectually dishonest its not even funny. One has nothing to do with the other. I don't see Isreal protesting against China over Tibet, so by your "logic" therefore Isreal is far worse. what bunk.
What exactly are "non-combat troops"? Is there such a thing?
The Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America Web site offers some refreshingly frank and salient points about the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. In a recent article posted on the site, Leslie H. Gelb writes:
“But let’s stop kidding ourselves: No sane leaders anywhere in the world would trust their security to the word of people who are publicly committed to their destruction and who have actually been trying to destroy them for half a century. Palestinians and Arabs will have to understand that they must make some serious concessions on security matters and on verification in order to give Israelis the necessary confidence to establish the two-state solution they desire.”
Gelb adds:
“Arab leaders committed far greater atrocities on Arab people than the Israelis ever committed upon the Palestinians. Who among them condemned Saddam Hussein’s atrocities over the years? Which of their leaders has raised the alarms about the most serious human-rights violations in Iran? And who among these Arab humanitarians have condemned the horrible treatment of women in so many Muslim societies? The daily treatment of women throughout a good deal of the Arab world is far worse than the Israeli treatment of Palestinians. The Israelis are no angels in how they treat the Palestinians, but their record is far, far better than how most Arab leaders treat their own people.”
Please ask Mr. Rieckhoff to weigh in on this topic. Why are these views important for American veterans and his organization? Does this position impact American's role in regional conflicts such as Iraq as well as in covert ops most surely going on in Iran and other countries?
I wonder if this post is sufficiently liberal for WNYC? We shall see.
Leave a Comment
Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more. Learn more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting. By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.