"Get over the race issue already!"
I always love when this canard is thrown out.
I graduated from an HBCU, Fisk University, more than 30 years ago and I know I got a great education which provided an excellent foundation for my success at the white universities where I attended graduate school. However, the HBCUs of yesteryear are not the HBCUs of today. Many of them have outlived their purpose and have lowered their academic standards of excellence to still have a student body; most have become little more than glorified remedial training schools with limited equipment, materials and facilities to keep students current with today's educational marketplace.
A few schools like Spelman, Morehouse, Howard University and Hampton should be maintained because they have continued to grow and be competitive as well as historically representative of an historical period that hasn't completely disappeared but most of them should be closed, merged, upgraded or seriously revamped if they are going to serve a useful purpose to anyone.
'The past is the past,' but it's not far enough yet in the past. Blacks are historically AND presently underserved in this country. HBCUs provide a focused and empowering environment for black students -- as caller Juanita attested to. As an Asian-American, I would be proud to teach at a HBCU.
The United Methodist Church supports more HBCU's in the US than any other religious body and has bylaws to fund them. Learn more here: http://www.gbhem.org/site/c.lsKSL3POLvF/b.3486287/k.BBD3/Black_College_Fund.htm
I feel like something is missing here.
Is this taxpayer supported or do the students pay? If the second, it's a non issue.
If it is so essential to black culture that these insititions remain then people who feel that way must find a way to support this place privately.
Lots of institutions are supported this way!!!!
HEY!!! As the product of 12 years of Catholic school, 4 of them all girls, then of art school, I agree that it's perfectly valid to have "specialty" institutions - and I for one would not like to see our black heritage overwhelmed by the predominant culture! That would be something like the gentrification of Manhattan which has taken so much away from us culturally. (We are an arts city only institutionally now - and we are not a city of ideas any more either - we became a city of money (and chain stores) and now with the finaancial industry in shambles - what are we?
There is no right or wrong here, but if students are worried that they may get a break because they are black they need to get over it. Would it be wrong to get preference because a professor likes guys, gals, Northerners, Southerners, immigrants, art students, etc.? Maybe we should all go to college on the Internet - NOT!
Colleges have always been tailored to prepare students from specific perspectives, be it Cal Tech's focus on engineering, or Bryn Mawr's focus on women's issues. Historically-black colleges acknowledge race as a factor in American life. To eliminate them would be to pretend that race is no longer a subject worthy of focused study.
Your guests attitude, which is common, is a big reason for the large disparity between the success of AA's and the expatriots from Africa and the Caribbean. Get over the race issue already!
You are all missing the point. There is not a single HBCU in existence today that restricts enrollment to black or any other race. In fact, much of the discussion among black college students is whether those HBCUs are in fact, recruiting white and Asian students. I am a graduate of Hampton University, where the engineering and physics department (both growing in recognition) are more and more white, Indian, and otherwise ethnically diverse. Everyone needs to update their thinking by about 20 years.
That being said, my position is that all colleges should exist on the basis of their academic credentials and reputation, and ability to maintain funding. Schools like Hampton and Spelman are able to thrive. Some other schools, including some HBCUs, won't. That's that.
The past is the past and I don't see a problem with referring to them as "historically black" that is fine, but not all whites ever saw the need for segregation is correct.
To say all whites are racist is a generalization and a stereotype which is not true or accurate.
Times have changed, but let's not forget about the white people that were part of the underground railroad and fought for abolition. There have always been people that were colorblind and loved everyone. There have always been interracial couples. I am surprised at how many people I meet black or white that think "mixing the races" is wrong. you love who you love, skin color shouldn't be the factor, do they respect you and love you and treat you right that is what counts.
OH this caller is laughable, wonder if he marched against segregation in the 50's 60's?
Actually there is data that clearly indicates that many students black and white do better at HBC's than other schools.
(Although -- the only thing I learned in college was about people who were different than myself. Fared me well in this multiracial society.)
Predominately black schools have always been open in terms of admission. Last year's Morehouse's valedictorian was white.
Brian, please ask Dr. Cobb whether he's aware of any other moves to merge either in other states or among private/parochial HBCU's.
Yes. If enough people want a black college -- enough to pay for it -- then who on earth has the right to say "no"?
GOD BLESS AMERICA
These type institutions are a part of history. Hopefully the future will very positive for them, anyone should be allowed to attend, but I don't believe the title should change, they should forever be known as "Historically Black" Institutions of higher learning.
Some whites never did see a need for segregation.
Excuse me, some white people.
How convenient that white people now do not see a need for segregation.
I'm a white woman and if I wanted to go to this college, I should be able to. Segregation is over. That is in the past. We are all the same under our skin, same organs, blood is the same color, we need to stop looking at the skin color.
I don't think segregation of any kind is good. It sets back the Civil Rights movement hundreds of years and you can't have it both ways.
Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm
your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the
right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the
Comment Guidelines before
By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's
It's your neighborhood, your city, your country, your world, and now your website. Brian Lehrer delves into the issues and links them to real life.