We invite everyone to track our progress of our "Dollar-A-Day" Challenge.
Bit different approach...strict guidelines...and having to work around a gluten allergy so no wheat, rye, barley, or oats.
Guess what..this is not a "diet". it is about survival. It is one thing to do it as an experiment, quite another when it is a reality...(I was thinking the latter). Yes there are cheap veggies and I agree cabbage is one of them. Also, when in survival mode, you have to know about food, nutrition and how to cook. New Yorkers (and other city folk) are too used to having everything prepared for them.
Come on -- they didn't even mention cabbage. Amateurs, clearly. You want cheap veggies, cabbage is the answer: You can boil it, stir-fry it, curry it, eat it raw, pickle it in vinegar (a la Central America), whatever -- it's what lettuce should be. Cabbage.
Maybe these guests should have joined the Freegans!
To O: 1) Nobody's claiming this diet is healthy or can "work for all people." 2) Type 2 diabetes doesn't mean not being able to eat carbs at all--most can have complex carbs (in fact I've never heard of their having any problem w/them). If you have celiac disease too, that's another story (& I'm sorry you have to deal w/having both). As for heart problems, eating meat is more likely to contribute to them than to help w/them.
No one diet works for everyone, & not even everyone who has (the same type of) diabetes has the same dietary restrictions/requirements.
I listened to the show and believe these people could have eaten more healthfully for the money. If they were serious they would have abandoned veganism and obtained free bones from a butcher to make gallons of a healthful broth. Cheap greens such as the outer leaves of cabbage, collards etc could then be added (they wasted money on broccoli,once,... too expensive, so I listened). To this broth one then adds the cheapest bean and grain (probably pinto beans and rice) then aome tomato paste and potaotes (also pretty cheap). The whole thing could be thickened with a little flour. Bread could made from cheap flour and cornmeal could be dunked into this good soup. This could be eaten at every meal. Jelly (for PB & J) also a waste of money since the diet is sufficiently carb heavy. I believe they key is to create enough bulk, protein, fat and veggies (the soup will do it) so that one can always feel full.
I am interested in the vegetarian plan.There is a social responsibility aspect to a vegetarian or a vegan eating plan, and given what a HUGE problem that Type 2 diabetes has become for state budgets, it would be interesting to learn more.Please note that T2 diabetes is growing into a problem not just here but in industrializing nations, such as China, where there is both a genetic component and a rapidly changing diet and lifestyle.It is also a disease that is preventable with education and activity. Instead, we have invited big pharma to address it with all sorts of nifty insulin delivery devices, etc.
Judging from the comments already posted, some listeners miss the point. It seems the purpose was to have a learning experience that in some gross way similates what more than a billion people worldwide have to do every day. That is, eat on less than a dollar a day. This learning experience demonstrates that it is impossible to eat a healthy and nutrionally sound diet for $1 a day. It does not take into account the availability of having a place to cook, the fuel to cook with,the utensils or the means to shop for the lowest price.
If you have time, please share some details of your vegetarian plan. Do you think Type 2 patients would fare just as well on your plan?There is a recent study showing how well the T2 patients have done on a specific type of low-glycemic diet - even avoiding whole wheat bread to focus on nuts and (this is obviously non-vegan) cheese.
there are many who are "white middle class "who live off $1 a day!personally I put myself through medical school on loans (which amounted to something in the neighborhood of.....with 18000 divided by rent electricity, rent gas, OOOOps forgot to say--- and 8 kids,one was on the way,sneakers on ocasion for at least their feet...well suffice to say there was always "bread and salad" on the table,milk in their cups and a dream in OUR hearts
are you serious about the free oxtail on the UES. I'm scared to draw so many people there, but is it a gourmet supermarket on the south western side of the block? please do tell.
sincerly,Ox Tail Man
People with type 2 diabetes with insulin resistance which is different from type 1 diabetes and the insulin resistance that makes them fat can't have any carbs so they have to live with meat and vegetables, no sugar at all, not even diet soda.Don't discount that other people have other dietary requirements. I get so sick of people touting they are vegetarians and we should all be one. Try living with the hell of being type 2 diabetes and having to avoid all carbs due to diabetes and celiac disease so they can't have the carbs!
As a fellow-vegan, I can't help but wonder why this couple had such trouble incorporating more vegetables into their diet. My husband and I eat very inexpensively on fewer carbohydrates and more vegetables than have been mentioned. When you can buy 3 hearts of romain lettuce for $3.00 in most NYC delis, it seems that you should be able to make this stretch even better than the vat of refried beans....
Based on what I've heard from both of them, Christopher and Kerri need to hurry up and have some babies.
Earth needs more sharp folks, and both Kerri and Chris sound as if they'd make some great ones!
Best of luck!
O from Forest Hills:I have been diabetic type 1 for over 40 years. For almost the past twenty I have followed a vegetarian diet and according to my doctor I am in EXCELLENT health. He says whatever I am doing to take care of myself to keep it up.
interesting topic! one suggestion to augment the menu - grow your own vegetables. i live in NYC and grew more tomatoes, jalepenos, basil, cilantro, sage and dill this summer than my husband and I could eat!
There's lots of cheap/free food out there! On UES I found a great smoked fish place selling smoked salmon scraps (great for omelets!) for 99 cents a pound; soup bones and even oxtails FREE at a major gourmet market. And don't get me started about those catered art openings!!
Comparisons to global poverty are a bit distorted because of the variation in purchasing power of a dollar here vs. the developing world.
This is ridiculous. Some people have diabetes and heart problems and need to eat meat and vegetables and no carbs so this is totally unrealistic to work for all people.
what's a "social justice" teacher? I've never heard of such people before.
Funny -- I assumed this is what President Bush meant in 2003 when he mentioned "retraining" American workers to compete with those in India and China.
I pictured Teamsters in retraining centers learning how to slurp noodles.
Glad to see this movement taking reality.
one suggestion: make a bloody great lentil/vege/potato soup, and eat it for days.
Even a doughnut and twinkies cost more than $1.00
On the blog, the authors discourage others from replicating the experiment, saying that "it isn't healthy and could be dangerous". What was the impact on their health at the during (or at the end of) the project?
Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm
your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the
right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the
Comment Guidelines before
By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's
It's your neighborhood, your city, your country, your world, and now your website. Brian Lehrer delves into the issues and links them to real life.