Streams

OSAMA BIN LADEN IS DEAD

Throngs of New Yorkers flock to WTC site

Sunday, May 01, 2011

WNYC

Osama bin Laden, the mastermind behind the September 11 attacks, was killed by U.S. military action during a firefight in Pakistan nearly a decade after the terror attacks and was later buried at sea, officials said.

Bin Laden was killed during a 40-minute raid on the heavily fortified compound in Pakistan identified by the CIA as the terror mastermind's hideout. About two dozen troops from counter-terrorism unit Navy SEAL Team Six went into the compound and shot bin Laden in the head, officials said. 

Officials said bin Laden "resisted the assault" and was killed in the ensuing firefight.

"Justice has been done," President Barack Obama said in a rare, late-night Sunday nationally televised address.

People gathered outside the White House, at the World Trade Center site and at sites around the world Sunday night to celebrate the death of the man once considered the most wanted terrorist in the world.

Al Qaeda is also blamed for the 1998 U.S. embassy bombings in Africa that killed 231 people and the 2000 attack on the USS Cole that killed 17 American sailors in Yemen.

With the Associated Press


Marianne McCune/WNYC
Marianne McCune/WNYC
Marianne McCune/WNYC
Marianne McCune/WNYC
Jody Avirgan
Jody Avirgan
"We thought we wouldn't be able to use these for three more years" said the two men who brought their vuvuzelas to the WTC celebration
Two workers arrive for their morning shift at ground zero
A quiet moment at the edge of the WTC site, 200 yards from the crowd

More in:

Comments [54]

Greg Caulfield from New York

I remember 20 years age when the golf war started
I was working with my school newspaper , they were talking about Soviet Union strong hole on Afghanistan and the departure of Soviet's in 1989 ... And that was first time I heard about Bin Laden , Half American never heard of BIn Laden before Spt,10 2001.

May. 03 2011 07:21 PM
thatsme from NY

Anybody notice that Hamas is not nice people?
http://www.mideastmag.com/35634/video-hamas-declares-osama-bin-laden-a-martyr-and-holy-warrior/

May. 03 2011 05:48 AM
Vic from .

Now, that Osama Bin Laden has been killed, we can finally direct our attention to the even more hideous criminals > those who were responsible for the controlled demolition of the World Trade Center Towers.
The truth is plain to see & hear in the documentary -
911 MYSTERIES - The Demolition
Check it out on the internet -
& then ask yourself, why (?)

May. 03 2011 03:20 AM

Immediately buried at sea? What kind of BS is that?

It's typical of anything the US Government does that we just have to take their word for it, and we will not be allowed proof of it.

The disconnect between the triumphant announcement of an historic event, and the simultaneous absolute lack of proof of it for the world to see, is pyschotic.

We are living in a time where everything is hot air, and there is no concrete proof of anything. Americans become stupider and stupider.

May. 02 2011 02:37 PM
Blossom in L.B. from Long Beach, New York

The death of OBL does not free us from the fanatical forces that continue to conspire to destroy not only America but all nations that do not entertain radical extremism. While this is a tremendous victory for President Obama and especially the brave Navy Seals who executed this mission, I feel we must be prudent in our response. This is NOT a time to celebrate but a time to reflect and respectfully honor those who perished on 9/11. I was fortunate not to have lost anyone close to me on 9/11, but as an American, I grieved and nothing has ever been the same. Was this the right thing to do, execute Bin Laden? Absolutely, justice has been served. But it is not a time for raucous celebrations. When all our brave men and women are safely stateside from Afghanistan and Iraq, then we can truly celebrate. Please bring them home Mr. President.

May. 02 2011 01:59 PM
Laura from UWS

NOTE: John McCain said he would NOT go into Pakistan to get Bin Laden because Pakistan is a sovereign nation. I remember very clearly when Barack Obama said in the primaries that he would go into Pakistan like this.

For a really good time, go back and read the party platforms for the year 2000; Dems named Bin Laden as a definite priority, Republicans did not.

And if we're going to go all political about this, don't you remember who George Bush, Sr. was having breakfast with on 9/11?

May. 02 2011 11:57 AM
DevilIsInTheDetails from NYC

Brian Lehrer just said:

"...they dumped the body at sea"

So, which is it?

Burial at sea, because they wanted to follow the 24-hour burial strictures of Islamic practice?
Or, they "..dumped the body at sea"?

May. 02 2011 11:12 AM
Smokey from LES

Obama was very smart to decide to kill bin Laden and not capture him. Otherwise I'm sure the Republicans would have appointed Casey and Rumsfeld to take turns waterboarding him and he would have been one more reason why Guantanamo will never be closed.

May. 02 2011 11:06 AM

My best friend from growing up and a roommate from college joined the State Dept. in 1978. He was unlucky enough to be stationed in Nairobi, Kenya during that bombing. He was lucky enough to be out of the office that day. His administrative assistant was killed.

I am happy that our President and our military stayed on the case and that UBL is now dead. I am amazed that it took nearly thirteen years to get it done.

What has happened to the American ability to get things done? Has the Internet - or whatever other distraction you care to fill in the blank with -- damaged our fundamental character that much?

May. 02 2011 10:47 AM

Buried at sea?

Smells like BS to me.

May. 02 2011 10:45 AM
Pakistani American liberal from nyc

THE WAR IS OVER! CAN WE HAVE A DISNEY MOVIE !

The least bloody (for us) and longest war in our nations history (for them) is over..!

everybody happy ending? THE SITH LORD IS DEAD!

May. 02 2011 10:34 AM
mgdu from manhattan

Caller says the targeted killing of OBL was not an “extra-judicial execution” because OBL posed an ongoing threat of terrorist attacks. That argument refutes itself. If OBL did pose any ongoing threat it would have been crucial to capture him alive.
The fact that we chose to execute OBL rather than to capture him shows clearly that our priority was not to prevent further terrorism, much less to achieve justice, but rather to silence OBL, to prevent the information that he has from being made public.
Bob Henley conveys the misinfo that OBL was killed during a firefight, but our president clearly stated that OBL was killed not ‘during’ but “after” the firefight.

May. 02 2011 10:34 AM
Dan from Manhattan

Don't want to rain on the parade but I am sorry, I don't buy the whole 'we need to bury him in a hurry because he is a muslim and nobody wants his body lying around..' Chances are we could have found a place to bury him in the US, even if that meant a secret location. Flying a body does not take more than 24 hrs from Pakistan and muslim tradition tolerates that kind of delay. Second, outside of the muslim countries that would always oppose the US, the vast majority of muslim countries would have understood that the US would need to follow some level of domestic 'due process' before disposing of OBL's body. (they DO have forensic analysis in Pakistan, too). Third, a DNA sample fails to prove the time of death, the way the death happened and for that matter, the death in itself. Burying a body at sea is also very convenient if one wants to avoid further investigation on all these elements. Fourth, the fact that the Pakistani were not aware is also very doubtful. The operation was conducted with US helicopters in a location that was well within Pakistani territory and Pakistan has excellent radars because of its ongoing military tension with India...

These elements are clearly obvious. So, why?...

May. 02 2011 10:33 AM
Kal Wagenheim from Millburn NJ

This just in! Donald Trump has expressed doubt about President Obama's
claim that Osama Bin Laden was killed. "Until I see a certified Proof of
Death Certificate from the Government of Pakistan, I won't be sure," said The Donald. Rush Limbaugh and several Tea Party sources have expressed doubt that President Obama would approve the killing of a fellow Muslim. "Maybe Dick Cheney gave the order," Limbaugh said.

May. 02 2011 10:31 AM
Brooklyn_Working_MOM from B

A Master of Doom and Destruction is dead - may the civilized world rest in peace! I will never forget watching friends, colleagues and so many others perish in the smoking, flaming inferno. What a horrible image – I wish it could be erased from my memory. I still recall the faces of mothers, husbands, brothers & other loved ones posted throughout the city; so tragic. Why do I feel so bad – perhaps this is just a terrible reminder of that sunny and bright but eternally dark morning.

May. 02 2011 10:31 AM
Philip Blitz from Sraten Island, NY

A Chatholic philosopher (who's name escapes at the moment) said that the death of one man deminishs us all. I don't feel deminished at all.

May. 02 2011 10:26 AM
Chris from Brooklyn, NY

No evidence tying Bin Laden to 9/11.

http://www.ibtimes.com/articles/140099/20110502/osama-bin-laden-never-charged-for-911-inside-job-likely-wtc7.htm

May. 02 2011 10:21 AM
Simone from Brooklyn, NY

On the death of OBL. I think of Shakespeare's words.

We have scorched the snake, not killed it.
She’ll close and be herself whilst our poor malice Remains in danger of her former tooth. But let the frame of things disjoint, both the worlds suffer, Ere we will eat our meal in fear, and sleep In the affliction of these terrible dreams That shake us nightly. Better be with the dead, Whom we, to gain our peace, have sent to peace, Than on the torture of the mind to lie In restless ecstasy.

Macbeth Act III , Scene 2

May. 02 2011 10:20 AM
Noticed_It from NY

Yes, indeed I noticed the freudian slip from your news reporter this morning..."O?ama is Dead!" and no one attempted to correct or apologize so I suppose it wasn't a mistake.

May. 02 2011 10:19 AM
Andres from NYC

Why the reluctance to release photos of Bin Ladin’s body? After all, gruesome photos of Sadam Hussein’s son’s corpses, and Sadam’s corpse were all over the media.
Sadam was doubtless an evil SOB, but he never attacked the US.

May. 02 2011 10:17 AM
Chris from Brooklyn, NY

I'm still not convinced Osama was behind the 9/11 attacks. Too many laws of physics were shattered on that terrible day. The official story does not add up if you can open your eyes and look at the evidence.

Official story disputes aside, the outward celebration should be kept to a minimum lest we further exacerbate our strained relations with the muslim world.

May. 02 2011 10:15 AM
john from office

I almost died in 911. I cannot believe anyone would not be happy over this. If he was captured there would have been a trial and it would have been a circus and soapbox for an evil man.

God bless America, the Seals, The flag.
He died by an American bullet, from an American hand, there is a god.

May. 02 2011 10:14 AM
Anthony from New York, NY

Thank you for allowing another voice in this media frenzy. We are not showing the world a better way. Why are leaders still afraid to take what we know to be higher ground. It is good Osama is gone, but cheering at a death, while understandable, shows the lowest response of culture... that of vengeance, not to mention short sightedness.
Osama’s act was a great offense and tragety, but a far greater tragety was our overwhelmingly military guided reaction to 9/11. And what we know now were lies by our leaders, we continue to today. Exemplifying for China and the world, we have spent the vast amount of our resources and budget and gone deeply in debt by continuing to build a massive military complex. Our media doesn’t even count the greater tragety, the death of innocents that have followed. Literallly at least 200 times the amount of innocent people have been killed in these specific reactive wars. Why is this not considered equally? Is this what the 3000 and their families wanted?
Special ops, a surgical strike was always the way to deal with such a crime, not huge military buildups and permanent bases. And people talk about not growing government? Pres Obama is wrong to support the notion that our most significant acheivement against terror to date is this strike. It would have been (and still remains) creating a more fair, honest and just world. Imagine if we put the untold spent billions toward education and projects that promote civilization, international cooperation and trust building. Imagine if we learned how to share resources instead of “protecting them” competively. Then the lives of the 3000 here would have not been in vain. Until we admit our failure, this great wrong, we continue down a path that repeats the worst of humanity... and supports the cycle of vengeance.

May. 02 2011 10:12 AM
Kash from New Jersey

I have waited to hear this news for so long and now I have mixed feelings instead of pure joy. What I feel is dread of what has to come. We are not dealing with humans here...We have the Pakistani taliban to deal with for instance and being the animals that they are, I only fear the worst to come. May God keep us all safe. I have loved ones captured by the taliban and I fear innocent people paying the price once again.

May. 02 2011 10:11 AM
LB from Manhattan

Remember the Public Enemy song?..."Don't Believe the Hype". I just don't believe it took this many years to find Bin Laden and now, he's supposedly dead and his body so quickly buried at sea with no absolute proof??? I wan't to see pictures, video or something concrete. As much as I can't stand Donald Trump, maybe he can get someone to show us a death certificate or proof of his death.

May. 02 2011 10:09 AM
DoyleDoyle from Northern NJ

Applause to the courageous Navy Seals for mission accomplished. A range of emotions zipping inside of me today. Mostly reliving the images and feelings from 9/11, and hoping that the families who lost loved ones, now have some peace.

May. 02 2011 10:00 AM
Roger

I almost died on 9/11, and I lost friends and loved ones and saw my life forever changed.

Don't tell me what I can and can't feel today, and what I can and can't do today.

If you don't like it, I don't care. Today is not about your considered sociopolitical commentary.

It is about the memory of all of those people who died almost a decade ago, on that cool, beautiful day.

Today is a great day.

May. 02 2011 09:28 AM
Tyler from New York, NY

buried at sea? wow, more bs in war on terror...

May. 02 2011 09:21 AM
Tyler from New York, NY

buried at sea? wow, more bs in war on terror...

May. 02 2011 09:20 AM
Theodora Egbuchulam

The celebrations today are not celebrations of the death of Osama bin Ladan, but celebrations for the lives we lost on 9/11 and the lives of all peace loving people all over the world who can now live with a greater sense of security and peace not known since 9/11. A promise kept to those we lost is now a promise fulfilled!

May. 02 2011 09:20 AM
Giddian from NJ

I await the Republican response to the killing of Ben Ladin. How will they spin this to minimize any credit to Obama?

May. 02 2011 09:16 AM
downtown NYer from Tribeca

I can see Ground Zero from where I sit typing. Walking through the streets this morning, the majority of New Yorkers are somber. A very small and very young minority are wrapping themselves in flags and cheering. It is an immature response by very young "adults/kids". One hopes that with age, they will look back with embarrassment at their actions. However, the media should right now be shamefaced for their unbalanced coverage of this small group of misguided youth. Everytime NPR, CNN, NYT, Fox News highlights this small group, you, the media, are making the next attack against us more likely. Shame - again - on you all.

May. 02 2011 09:12 AM
Habeas Corpus from NYC

The U.S. has made an ENORMOUS strategic error, if they do not have definitive evidence of the death and the body, which they quickly present.

In the absence of this, we're seeing the birth of yet another conspiracy theory system... and there appears to already be a faked photo circulating.

In today's world the U.S. can't allow a media vacuum on this evidence.

May. 02 2011 09:01 AM
Mark from Astoria

It seems to me that this should be a time for somber reflection - not a time for jubilation - and especially not a time for drinking and celebrating in the streets. As one or two people posted previously, celebrating "as though we won a football game" seems to be the opposite of what we want the world to see. Somber reflection would be the mature, responsible response.

May. 02 2011 08:57 AM
Kate from New Jersey

The first news I got was on facebook. I then went to a news site to watch the video clip of the President. I truly didn't feel a joyful response for the news, I felt gratitude for the men and women who have served in the military and all that they and their families have given. I also reflected on all of the stories that I had heard of the terror that this group of people enacted on men, women, and children in their own county and around the world.

While this might be viewed as a milestone it is not or should not be viewed as a victory. Children have been groomed and trained in the ideology and beliefs of these supporters and I would imagine that they are quiet angry now.

Even if he was caught I don't think that he would have provided information that would have benefited anyone. He is a warrior and I doubt that he would have gave up information that would have helped the dismantling of his movement.

May. 02 2011 08:51 AM
Anne Moss from Texas

This display on your site is inhuman. You are a media outlet for the republicans now? We know that Bin Laden Was a CIA asset on our payroll for years. The Bushs hired him to do their/our dirty work.Now we kill him with out a trial?? The war on terror will not end until we kill ourselves at this rate. America my country of terrorists.

May. 02 2011 08:42 AM
Steven

This event is true litmus test for our citizens.

A man with the blood of thousands of innocent lives on his hands, innocents from every religion and most nations, and a mind full of hate, is killed through a decade of hard work by the men and women who defend us.

Some will be relieved, and others proud. Some, whose lives were changed by his acts of war, might even rejoice.

And others will continue in lockstep with the dogmatic drivel they learned in graduate school and elsewhere. Ramblings about why he wasn't captured and tried in court, or how this is a discredit to our nation, or whatever.

These are the citizens on the left, who like their corresponding ones on the right, are making us a worse nation than we could be.

Today, pleas, stuff it. A man who would behead your daughter, who has indeed beheaded our sons and daugthers, has been called to accout.

Allahu Akhbar. God bless America.

May. 02 2011 08:40 AM

I will have to agree with the German architect in this morning report about people gathering at Ground Zero. I wish some people didn't respond as if they won a football game. While I am glad this is a form of closure for the families of 9/11 victims, but I wish people didn't scream & yell. Made me sad that some people used this occasion as a drinking fest.

May. 02 2011 08:39 AM
Louis from Jersey Shore

That's what happens when you want Israel out of the West Bank.

May. 02 2011 08:34 AM
pete from brooklyn

I don't celebrate violence. I hope this event is only succeeded by greater peace. The enthusiasm around this death makes me uncomfortable.

May. 02 2011 08:33 AM
mgdu from manhattan

Why was bin Laden executed in the field--by being shot in the head, according to NBC--rather than being captured and brought to trial? This question needs to be answered directly because President Obama made clear in his carefully worded statement that bin Laden was killed “after a firefight”--not ‘during a firefight’--and also that there was such ineffective resistance by bin Laden’s forces that “No Americans were harmed”.

Why, furthermore, has bin Laden’s body been disappeared rather than being brought for medical examination? Was the corpse disappeared to get rid of forensic evidence that bin Laden was executed after he had been captured?

Was bin Laden executed rather than brought to trial in order to conceal the information he could have given about the development and actions of al Qaeda--particularly about its current plans going forward and about what nations, intelligence services, and other groups and individuals were involved in the planning and carrying out of the 9/11 terrorist attacks on America?

May. 02 2011 08:26 AM
Cupcake from Brooklyn, NY

Once again we have failed as human beings.

May. 02 2011 08:23 AM
clyde turner from Brooklyn NY

There were Pakistanis who knew all along where Osama bin Lauden was but they cooperated with President Obama and not former President Bush. I hope that Mr. Trump will not insist on a "Long form" death certificate to accept that bin Lauden has been killed!

May. 02 2011 08:23 AM
Stanley from NYC

This wall to wall coverage of Bin Laden, consisting of 30 to 60 seconds of news and, by now, many hours of speculation and conjecture, makes your service seem no more valuable than any of the networks, including Fox, and, certainly no more endurable. Pacifica's coverage is, at least, more nuanced and "Democracy Now" has been excellent.

May. 02 2011 08:19 AM
bob

so, can they come home now?

May. 02 2011 08:12 AM
Guenevere Pendragon

Why was he assassinated instead of captured and dealt with through an international tribunal? This makes the US look like we are operating without laws. It's not the first time since 9/1/2001 that we seem to have sunk to the the level of the worst of our enemies. We claim to have special "American values" but we are clearly not special. We seem to be ordinary thugs. And I am very sad to see the celebrations in the street at someone's death. Did we learn that from Al Qaeda?

May. 02 2011 08:12 AM
Liz from Greenwich Village

It saddens me that we live in a world in which we celebrate in the streets the death on any man.

May. 02 2011 08:03 AM
kumru toktamis from brooklyn NY

OBL has been succesfully eliminated through a remarkable intelligence operation, as those of us against a war in Afganistan (and in Iraq) have been saying all along for years. We needn't declare war in several corners of the world and galvanize new recruits for Al-Qaida to kill an international criminal; sound and smart intelligence operations would have done the job and did it.

May. 02 2011 07:54 AM
john from office

Last night I felf a great hate and weight lifted from me. I left my bed to go to the scene of the crime, ground zero, and I sang patriotic songs with strangers, tears running down my face.

I was in the middle of 911, I remember the sights and sounds to this day and I believe it really affected me.

I remember seeing the first building on fire, I remember seeing the second plane hit the next tower, I remember seeing people falling, some on fire, I remember the sound on bodies hitting concrete, I remember seeing weeks of photos of the lost, a city shut down, I remember the smell of human flesh burning that lasted weeks if not months.

I feel renewed. May god bless America. Never again, Never forgive, Never Forget.

May. 02 2011 07:52 AM
Neil from NYC

Isn't it suspicious that US decided to go ahead with liquidation of BinLaden (after "months" of intelligence and preparation) just when top news was dominated by the embarassing botched attempt to assassinate Col. Qaddafi that killed his son and three grandchildren? Was main purpose to push that off front pages?

May. 02 2011 07:48 AM

I went to bed happy, but now I am worried. I can't possibly imagine that the administration would be so stupid as to take possession of the body and then bury it at sea without it having undergo some outside scrutiny by the public. Hell, they even put Bonnie and Clyde on display! Please tell me That they were smarter than that. Please!?!?!??

May. 02 2011 07:14 AM
sofia from delhi

Nice post , find more details at

http://hi5sms.in/worlds-wanted-terrorist-dead.php

May. 02 2011 06:44 AM
ljhs from NY/Jerusaelm

I am proud of the mission accomplished.
I am not proud of the throngs of people cheering and celebrating. It reminds me all too much of the pictures of ecstatic Gazans celebrating at the success of a terrorist bombing in Israel. The US should be more sober in its realization that this is the head of the hydra and there are many arms to al Quida still working towards its demise.

May. 02 2011 05:12 AM

Good job! Congratulations New York!!!

May. 02 2011 01:15 AM

Leave a Comment

Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more. Learn more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting. By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.

Sponsored

Feeds

Supported by