Streams

Lawyer for Strauss-Kahn Accuser Hopes Gambles Will Pay Off

Thursday, August 18, 2011

Kenneth Thompson Kenneth Thompson (Stephen Nessen/WNYC)

Prosecutors are expected to announce next Tuesday whether they will proceed with their allegations that former International Monetary Fund chief Dominique Strauss-Kahn sexually assaulted a hotel housekeeper at the Sofitel Hotel in Midtown Manhattan in May.

The case has been on shaky ground since July when the District Attorney announced he had concerns about the credibility of the woman at the center of the case. But there’s one person who has been fighting to keep the prosecution alive: her lawyer, Ken Thompson.

Thompson, 45, introduced himself to the world as Nafissatou Diallo’s lawyer the day prosecutors told the court she had lied on her asylum application, her tax returns and to investigators. 

He says now he hadn’t planned to talk to the press that day.  But as soon as Strauss-Kahn’s lawyers left the courthouse, he strode up to the cluster of microphones and television cameras in front of the building.

As if channeling the graphic, straight-talking former federal prosecutor within him, Thompson gave what sounded like the opening argument in the case against Dominique Strauss-Kahn.

"She got up and started to run for that door and started spitting Dominique Strauss-Kahn’s semen out of her mouth in disgust all over that hotel room," Thompson  thundered, shouting into the flash bulbs.

He went on for more than a half hour. Thompson is praised for being a graphic orator in the courtroom, but that day, critics said he went too far. When he talked about the bruises found on Diallo, he used the word “vagina” five times in 20 seconds.

"That day, July 1, I was under a lot of pressure because everyone thought the case was collapsing," said Thompson in his law office near Union Square. "Everyone thought that Ms. Diallo was a liar. I stood in front of a hostile press corps and wanted to tell the truth."

And once he got going, he didn't stop. As if presenting his own star witness in front of a jury, Thompson soon made Diallo available for interviews with the national media— first Newsweek, then ABC’s "Good Morning America," on which she emotionally claimed she was pushed by Strauss-Kahn in his Sofitel Hotel suite and how terrified she was.

That same week, Thompson invited the international media to meet Diallo at his very own church — Christian Cultural Center in Brooklyn, one of the largest predominantly black mega-churches in the city. Diallo stood on a stage flanked by dozens of African-American community leaders, who ended up taking more air time than she did.  She seemed almost shell-shocked by the camera bulbs flashing in her face

"What happened to me, I don’t want that to happen to any other woman," said Diallo almost inaudibly to the rows of reporters.

Thompson said it was actually Diallo’s idea — not his — to bring her case to the media. He knows it was a gamble.

Sources close to the District Attorney’s office say his decision to go along with the idea irritated prosecutors and only gave them another reason to drop the case. And if Diallo wound up saying anything inconsistent from what she would later say on the stand, the defense lawyers could trounce her in cross-examination.

Thompson said it’s been "awkward and strange" as a former prosecutor watching his relationship with the DA deteriorate – but he truly believes Diallo was assaulted.

"It's as if Ms. Diallo’s being put on trial and it's been sort of surprising to me – the level of hostility that she has and I have encountered," said Thompson.

(Stephen Nessen/WNYC)

A Lawyer For Alleged Victims

Thompson has made a business out of sticking up for high-profile female victims under siege.  

Among his clients are Sherr-Una Booker, the woman who accused an aide to former Governor David Paterson of domestic violence, and Sandra Guzman, an editor who alleged sexual harassment and discrimination against the New York Post.  

Critics say Thompson purposely gravitates toward high-publicity cases, but friends disagree.

"He doesn’t gravitate toward them. They gravitate toward him," said Sterling Johnson, Jr., a federal judge in Brooklyn and a longtime mentor of Thompson’s. "What happens is you have a lawyer who has a reputation of being very good at what he does, people will come to him."

Thompson said that’s how he got the Diallo case. He said her relatives tracked him down in May after hearing about his performance as a young federal prosecutor on the Abner Louima case in which five NYPD officers were indicted for sodomizing a man with a broomstick in 1997.  

Thompson was barely three years into the job when the police officers were charged.  To his surprise, Thompson was tapped to give the opening argument.  He practiced late at night for weeks in the bathroom of the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Brooklyn because it had a mirror and a long sink to pace in front of.

Thompson's opening statement to the jury detailed the attack on Louima in graphic detail:

"Abner Louima was taken into a back room and beaten a third time. That third beating was far more vicious than the first two beatings. And that's because inside that bathroom, Abner Louima suffered more than just a beating. Ladies and gentlemen, Abner Louima was tortured in that bathroom, and his torture was cruel and it was simply inhumane."

Joe Tacopina defended one of the officers in the case and remembers how Thompson captivated the courtroom.

"He did an opening in that case that was fiery and passionate, and most U.S. Attorneys don’t do that stuff,” said Tacopina. "They’re very like, 'The evidence will show…' or 'I submit to you, Ladies and Gentlemen…,' and they talk all robotic, but Kenny doesn’t.”

A Man of Few Smiles

Thompson is a tall man with a commanding presence who rarely smiles. But behind the immaculate desk in his office are photos of himself grinning with his son and daughter, 4 and 6, respectively.

"I have this serial killer look all the time, but my son can take that away," said Thompson, staring at one picture of his son climbing on his back. "I don’t know why. It’s just not in me to smile that much. I guess I'm always feeling the weight of the world."

Thompson grew up in public housing in Harlem and was abandoned by his father when he was five. He was raised by his mother, Clara Dolores Thompson, along with his brother and sister, in Co-op City in the Bronx. Thompson’s mother became one of New York City’s first female police officers on patrol.

Thompson went on to John Jay College and then NYU Law School, before becoming a lawyer for the U.S. Treasury Department, a federal prosecutor, an associate in a corporate law firm and finally, a plaintiff’s lawyer on Fifth Avenue.

Thompson said being a plantiff’s attorney is a natural fit; he’s always been drawn to cases, like Diallo’s, where victims seem powerless.

"This is a case about gender and power and class. I’ve said that from day one," said Thompson.

And some seasoned lawyers say being outspoken from day one could end up being Thompson’s greatest strategy in the case.

Sanford Rubenstein represented Abner Louima when Thompson was prosecuting the case. Rubenstein has never been one to shy away from cameras, but at the time, he actually advised Louima not to speak publicly before Thompson and the other prosecutors took the case to trial.  But Rubenstein says Thompson’s different tactic now could be a successful one.

"What it is, is the trial before the trial in the court of public opinion – attempting to influence the public to support the victim," Rubenstein said. "Remember, a jury pool comes from the public, and while the judge will tell the jury that they shouldn't be influenced by anything that they’ve heard before, we don’t know what goes through people’s minds when they sit on a jury."

But at this point, the only jury that may be left to convince is the one that will be hearing the civil suit Diallo filed against Strauss-Kahn last week.  

Several sources have told Thompson the DA will drop the criminal case.  He took some heat for filing a lawsuit so quickly, but Thompson said filing a lawsuit after Strauss-Kahn was off the hook would have drawn ridicule.

And, he added, try serving a complaint on a guy who’s already hightailed it back to France.

Editors:

Karen Frillmann

Tags:

More in:

Comments [14]

Walt from Atlanta

The jury system for trials means that juries are supposed to decide guilt or innocence in criminal cases. For a DA to make that decision just because he does not want to lose a case makes the whole justice system fall back into "Who do you know?" or "How much do I have to pay to get off."
The DA becomes just another politician saying,"What's in it for me?'

Aug. 23 2011 08:10 PM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: 0/0
Lowflyin' Lolana from Los Angeles

I'm amazed at the comments on this site. WYNC. Isn't that public radio? This is what public radio listeners in NY think? Holy crap. Diallo a terrorist?!!! Thompson "unethical"?

I can't believe how successful the smear campaign against this woman has been. And look at New York's public radio audience buying it.

"Not about race and class?" Same audience also smoking crack? How on God's green earth can one exclude race and class from this picture?

Without class, you do not have the money to run a smear campaign against a rape victim. Without race, you do not have hysterical interneters raving about terrorists who are trying to raise money from the lawsuit to commit 'future terrorist acts on US soil.'

What is goin' on over there in NYC, man. Something in the water?!
No justice for people named Diallo, maybe it's a tradition.

As I write this the prosecution just dropped the lawsuit and DSK can now "hop a plane." Of course he's got a lawsuit to face in France from another woman.

Aug. 23 2011 02:35 AM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: 0/0
observer from California

Still wondering what exactly, the NYPD and DA- saw as credibility in the original claim? Because she made the claim itself? We're they ignorant, or too afraid to say no? When I hear something like this, all Ican think about is - all the others men like strauss-kahn, that didn't have the were with all, of strauss-kahn to resist- and are now crushed for life by the Justice System.

Aug. 21 2011 11:10 PM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: 0/0
Fuva from Harlemworld

(sorry, correction: "...the willingness of a privileged and powerful man TO EXPLOIT the de..."

Aug. 19 2011 11:16 AM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: 0/0
Fuva from Harlemworld

...And I don't mean to trivialize rape with the whiplash comparison. I'm making it in reference to accusations against Diallo for supposed inconsistencies in her account of what happened afterward (though her account of what happened DURING has apparently never wavered)...

Aug. 19 2011 10:43 AM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: 0/0
Fuva from Harlemworld

...Yall are all over the place with this...To say this is not about race or class is to be race and class ignorant, which is so widespread that even WNYC patrons suffer from it. Even if she was HOOKING, which is apparently not the case here, it would have been about race and/or class, and the willingness of a privileged and powerful (and supposedly progressive?) man exploiting the desperate act of a subordinate. There is NO scenario in which this is not opportunistic sex on the part of DSK. And the scenario in which it was purely consensual for her is less plausible...There's critical perspective lacking in the criminal justice system and the media...What constitutes forcible sex/ rape? Because someone lies on their asylum form and their taxes makes a rape accusation incredible?...The validity of many claims made against Diallo is questionable and needs clarification. IF they pan out, this is likely a whiplash case, involving a bit of embellishment from the victim, but victimization nevertheless.

Aug. 19 2011 10:24 AM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: 0/0
Kismet from US

Devout Muslim woman who dresses as a Westerner. An unmarried imam's daughter, who was well versed and trained on how to get an entrance to US and very well placed at the international hotel Sofitel. She says that she is illiterate but it has been proven that she managed to commit tax fraud by claiming two extra children and underreporting her income. A person who is associated with a convicted drug dealer who laundered money through her bank accounts.
She looks like sleeping agent of a terrorist cell who is eager to fleece a wealthy Jew from France to finance the future terrorist acts on US soil. Perhaps an explosion at the hotel Sofitel, or even a bomb at the Christian Cultural Center, a mega church in New York, that supports her. As you know, a Muslim can pretend to befriend infidels (in violation of the teachings of Islam) by lying to non-Muslims in order to be able to operate freely amongst enemies... Unlike most religions, within Islam there are certain provisions under which lying is not simply tolerated, but actually encouraged. It is also clear that if forced to do so, Muslims can lie while under oath...
And she has already reportedly lied under oath when she testified to the grand jury.
You have to be blind to support this serial liar.

Aug. 18 2011 04:26 PM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: -2/2
Fuva from Harlemworld

...Granted, it's not clear that all evidence has been revealed or reliably reported to the public. But, whatever it is, I'm hoping it's revealing. Because we have waaaaay to many people passing judgment on Diallo, and very clumsily attempting to interpret her behavior, who not only know NOTHING about her reality, but don't even know that they don't know (and are working with insufficient information)...And, of course, these types are overrepresented in the criminal justice system and media...A read of Sarah Burns' recently published "Central Park Five" may provide perspective...

Aug. 18 2011 12:53 PM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: 0/2
Mark

Thanks to this two-bit hustler we now have the odious Christine Lagarde running the IMF during what's becoming another financial crises. Since Diallo seems to be pretty erratic and untrustworthy I'm hoping when she loses she'll break down and expose how she got the idea to set DSK up. Did someone whisper in her ear?

Aug. 18 2011 12:53 PM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: 0/2
Fuva from Harlemworld

If, in a reported 9-minute period, Diallo happened upon a naked DSK and suddenly got hot for his old, flabby a---, then proceeded to willingly have her genitals bruised and stockings ripped, and then spit semen on the wall because she liked it, then it must be proven at trial.

Aug. 18 2011 12:39 PM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: 0/2

This case is NOT a case about race or class, it is a case between two individuals. Thompson attempts to make it a case about race and class because it's his only way to gain the sympathy of the public opinion. He turned the case into a circus by trying it in front cameras and pressuring the DA's office using his political connections. That's the main contradiction, isn't it? Insulting the DA's office implying that they don't want to go forward with the case because of DSK's political high profile while using politics to put pressure on them.

Diallo lied too much to be credible. Even the medical file which Thompson shared with the French media is not strong enough to support her accusations against DSK.

His behavior has been highly unprofessional and completely unethical.

Aug. 18 2011 12:27 PM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: 2/2
Wendy from New York

Kudos to Ken Thompson. His speech on the courthouse steps was brilliant, moving and probably entirely appropriate to the moment. Trying cases in the court of public opinion is not always justified, fair or good. And the "perp walk" is also not fair or good. But, when a prosecutor is going to drop such a potentially important case that may (we are told) have very strong corroborating physical evidence because the victim lied in an asylum application AND because the prosecutor's team may have had a mistranslation of a conversation.... This was the right thing to do!!!!!!!

Aug. 18 2011 11:07 AM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: -3/5
JL from Brooklyn

"What happened to me, I don’t want that to happen to any other woman," said Diallo almost inaudibly to the rows of reporters.

This is a brilliant statement to put forward. I worked in a top NYC hotel (just two blocks south of Central Park), and many, many female housekeepers and massage therapists are verbally, physically, and sexually harassed by wealthy influential male hotel guests.

Ms. Diallo's plight is not unusual, because people like Strauss-Kahn are quite used to getting away with abusing women who are in fear of losing their jobs.

Aug. 18 2011 09:11 AM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: -3/7
kirin


A very interesting article. It adds credibility to the maid's manipulative character and naive belief that she could use her acting skills, (same skills she used to the investigators on recounting her gang rape tale with tears and appearing very distraught) to rally the public to her cause.

It was her idea all along not Thompson's and it looks like he is not happy with it either, else, why come out and reveal it now?

Naffisato Diallo is making a mockery of the law, and the sympathies of the American people. Deport her.

Aug. 18 2011 08:49 AM
Vote this comment up Vote this comment down Score: 0/6

Leave a Comment

Register for your own account so you can vote on comments, save your favorites, and more. Learn more.
Please stay on topic, be civil, and be brief.
Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. Names are displayed with all comments. We reserve the right to edit any comments posted on this site. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting. By leaving a comment, you agree to New York Public Radio's Privacy Policy and Terms Of Use.







URL

If you enter anything in this field your comment will be treated as spam
Location
* Denotes a required field

Sponsored

Feeds

Supported by